Existing conservatory
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Fallback Position
Policy Weight
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 21 May 2021
by Christopher Miell MPlan MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 8 June 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/B9506/D/21/3269573
Warwick Farmhouse, Beckley Road, Beckley BH23 7ED
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr T Goode against the decision of New Forest National Park
Authority.
• The application Ref 20/00893, dated 2 December 2020, was refused by notice dated
26 January 2021.
• The development is an existing conservatory.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for an existing
conservatory at Warwick Farmhouse, Beckley Road, Beckley BH23 7ED in
accordance with the terms of the application, Ref: 20/00893, dated
2 December 2020, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans: Drawing Nos: MBA/100/100 (Existing
Location Plans), MBA/100/101 (Existing Floor Plans) and MBA/100/102
(Existing Elevations).
2) The external surfaces of the development hereby permitted shall be
constructed in the materials shown on Drawing No. MBA/100/102.
Background
2. The conservatory was constructed at the appeal property in Spring 2020.
Following construction, the appellant was notified by the Authority’s
Enforcement Officer that the works required planning permission. The applicant
made an application to the Authority for planning permission on 2 December
2020 to retain the conservatory as built, which was refused by notice dated 26
January 2021. The Authority’s refusal to grant planning permission forms the
basis of this appeal. Given that the works have been completed, I am
considering this appeal as a retrospective development.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are: (i) whether the development adheres to the Authority’s
strategy for the extension of existing dwellings within the New Forest National
Park, in the context of adopted policy; and (ii) if harm arises, whether this is
outweighed by other material considerations.
Appeal Decision APP/B9506/D/21/3269573
2
Reasons
The Authority’s strategy for the extension of existing dwellings
4. Warwick Farmhouse is a large detached dwelling located off Beckley Road
situated within the New Forest National Park (the ‘National Park’). The property
occupies a substantial plot in a rural location.
5. The supporting text for Policy DP36 of the New Forest National Park Local Plan
2016-2036 (the ‘LP’) explains that proposals to incrementally extend dwellings
in a nationally designated landscape can affect the locally distinctive character
of the built environment of the New Forest. In addition, extensions can over
time cause an imbalance in the range and mix of housing stock available. For
these reasons, the policy aims to restrict the size of extensions which will be
permitted to existing dwellings.
6. For dwellings which are not small dwellings1 and are outside the defined
villages, as is the case with the appeal property, the policy states that
extensions must not increase the floorspace of the existing dwelling by more
than 30%. Paragraph 7.82 of the LP explains that the term ‘existing dwelling’
means the dwelling as it existed on 1 July 1982, or as the dwelling was
originally built or legally established, if the residential use post-dates 1 July
1982.
7. The Authority explain that the original dwelling had a gross internal floor area
of 132 square metres. They further state that previous extensions undertaken
at the property taken together with the existing conservatory would amount to
a floorspace increase of about 98% of the internal habitable floor area of the
original dwelling. These calculations have not been disputed by the appellant.
8. Consequently, the retention of the existing conservatory together with the
previous works would amount to a floorspace increase of more than 30% of the
internal habitable floor area of the existing dwelling, which would conflict with
Policy DP36 of the LP.
9. In design terms, I am cognisant of the shared position between the main
parties that the conservatory does not result in any visual harm to the
character of the wider area. Nevertheless, this does not overcome or outweigh
the very weighty conflict with Policy DP36 which seeks to limit the extension of
existing properties in order to prevent the harmful incremental extension of
dwellings within the National Park, which is a nationally designated landscape.
10. For the reasons set out above, I conclude that the development would exceed
the 30% criterion set out in Policy DP36 of the LP. Therefore, the development
is contrary to Policy DP36, which aims to prevent the harmful incremental
extension of dwellings in the National Park.
11. The development plan policy aligns with the aims of Paragraph 172 of the
National Planning Policy Framework (the ‘Framework’) which states that great
weight should be given to conserving and enhancing landscape and scenic
beauty in National Parks. The development does not accord with the
Framework in these respects.
1 Paragraph 7.82, part of the supporting text for Policy DP36, explains that the term ‘small dwelling’ means a
dwelling with a floor area of 80 sq. metres or less as it existed on 1 July 1982, or as the dwelling was originally
built or legally established, if the residential use post-dates 1 July 1982.
Appeal Decision APP/B9506/D/21/3269573
3
Other Considerations
12. Planning law2, as noted by Paragraph 12 of the Framework, requires that
applications for planning permission be determined in accordance with the
development plan, unless material considerations indicate otherwise.
13. In this instance, it has been brought to my attention that the Authority granted
planning permission3 in November 2020 for alterations to the existing
conservatory to create a detached garden room to the rear of the appeal
property. The approved drawings4 show that a small section of the existing
conservatory would be removed to form a detached garden room. The works
would result in a gap of approximately 0.2m between the conservatory and the
appeal property.
14. The Courts have set out a two-stage approach where a determination must
first be made concerning whether the fallback position is a material
consideration, before weight is ascribed. The first stage is to determine
whether there is a greater than a theoretical possibility that the development
might take place. The second stage is that if it is found that there is a greater
than theoretical possibility, then the decision-maker should exercise their
planning judgement to determine what weight should be ascribed to the
fallback position.
15. The appellant explains that there is a realistic prospect of the approved
development being delivered at the appeal site. Given the minor extent of the
works that would be required to alter the existing conservatory to form the
approved garden room, I am satisfied that there is a greater than theoretical
possibility of this fallback option being implemented. As such, I have afforded
significant weight to this fallback position as a material consideration.
16. The approved garden room would be physically detached from the host
building, and, thus it would not increase the internal habitable floor area of the
existing dwelling. However, by virtue of its very close proximity to the appeal
property, and, its convenient access with doors sited near to the existing
dwelling, I consider that the garden room could reasonably function as an
extension to the main dwelling by providing additional floorspace for occupants
of the appeal property, which could be used on a frequent basis.
17. Moreover, given that the garden room would be sited in an identical position to
the existing conservatory, with the exception of the 0.2m gap, the retention of
the existing conservatory would have no materially greater impact on the
landscape and scenic beauty of the National Park when compared to the
approved development.
18. For these reasons, I afford significant weight to the appellant’s fallback position
as a material consideration. I have found that the implementation of the
approved development would have a similar effect to the appeal development.
Therefore, notwithstanding the conflict with Policy DP36 of the LP, the material
considerations in this case indicate that planning permission should be granted.
2 Section 38(6) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004
3 Authority Ref: 20/00601
4 Drawing Nos: MBA/100/104 and MB/100/105
Appeal Decision APP/B9506/D/21/3269573
4
Other Matters
19. The Authority argue that allowing this appeal would set an undesirable
precedent which would make it difficult for them to resist similar development
in the National Park. However, I have considered the development on its
individual planning merits and, despite the identified conflict with the
development plan, I have found that other material considerations indicate that
planning permission should be granted. As such, the appeal decision would not
set an undesirable precedent.
Conditions
20. The development pursuant to this appeal has already commenced and this
appeal has been determined on a retrospective basis. Therefore, it is not
necessary to impose the standard three-year time limit condition.
21. It is necessary that the development is carried out in accordance with the
approved plans, for the avoidance of doubt and in the interests of certainty.
22. In the interests of the character and appearance of the area, it is necessary to
impose a condition requiring the external materials to be those as specified on
the drawings hereby approved.
Conclusion
23. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should succeed.
Christopher Miell
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.