To install new windows and doors to the front and rear, two roof lights to front elevation, to construct a dormer to rear elevation and carry out associated works
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decisions
Site visit made on 13 April 2021
by J Williamson BSc (Hons) MPlan MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 18 August 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/Z4310/D/21/3268615
72 Adelaide Road, Liverpool, L7 8SQ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Emperor Property against the decision of Liverpool City Council.
• The application Ref 20H/0961, dated 30 March 2020, was refused by notice dated
29 January 2021.
• The development is to install new windows and doors to the front and rear, two roof
lights to front elevation, to construct a dormer to rear elevation and carry out
associated works.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. I have used the amended description of development, as agreed by the parties,
which includes alterations to front and rear windows.
3. I observed during my site visit that development has begun. The application is
therefore retrospective, and I have made my decision on this basis.
4. ‘Development’ is defined in s55 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990;
s55(2)(a) states that, for the purposes of the Act, the following operations shall
not be taken to involve development of land:
“the carrying out for the maintenance, improvement or other alteration of any
building of works which –
(i) affect only the interior of the building, or
(ii) do not materially affect the external appearance of the building…”
5. One of the Councils reasons for refusal relates to the effect of the internal
alterations to floor/ceiling levels on the primary elevation of the property. In
my opinion, contrary to the Council’s view, the altered ceilings/floors are set
back from the windows; as such they are barely perceptible from outside of the
property. I therefore consider that the alterations only affect the interior of the
building and do not materially affect its external appearance. Consequently, I
conclude that such works are not development and therefore do not require
planning permission. I have therefore made my decision on the basis that the
alterations to floor/ceiling levels do not form part of the appeal before me.
Appeal Decisions APP/Z4310/D/21/3268615
2
6. The appellant suggests that the proposed fenestration alterations at the rear of
the property do not require planning permission. I note that the Article 4(2)
direction applied to the CA prevents certain elements of development that
would usually constitute permitted development being undertaken without
planning permission. Most of the restrictions in the Article 4(2) relate to works
that would “front a relevant location”; “relevant location” is defined in The
Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995,
(GPDO), as referring to a “highway, waterway or open space”.
7. I do not have sufficient information before me to be able to conclude whether
the alley between the rear of the site and the terrace opposite would constitute
a “highway” for the purposes of the GPDO. The appellant has not provided any
details as to why they consider the proposed alterations to fenestration at the
rear of the property do not require planning permission. Within the context
outlined above, I have made my decision on the basis that the proposed
fenestration alterations at the rear of the property form part of the appeal.
8. I note that a revised National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) was
published on 20 July 2021. As the requirements of policies relating to design
and heritage essentially remain the same as those in the July 2019 version, I
consider it was not necessary to reconsult parties.
Application for costs
9. An application for costs was made by Emperor Property against Liverpool City
Council. This application will be the subject of a separate Decision.
Main Issues
10. The main issues are the effect of the proposal on the character or appearance
of the host property and whether it protects or enhances the character or
appearance of the Kensington Fields Conservation Area (CA).
Reasons
11. I have a statutory duty to pay special attention to the desirability of preserving
or enhancing the character or appearance of the CA. Additionally, paragraph
189 of the Framework advises that heritage assets are an irreplaceable
resource and should be conserved in a manner appropriate to their
significance; and paragraph 199 advises that great weight should be given to
the conservation of such assets when considering the impact of development
on the significance of a designated heritage asset.
12. The CA derives its significance primarily from being a typical example of by-law
terraced housing constructed during the late 19th Century. The terraced
properties are laid out in a strong, parallel grid pattern, fronting roads with
alleys running between the terraces at the rear. The pattern of development is
of high density, close knit composition. The terraced dwellings have been
constructed with a uniformity of scale, design, and architectural detail.
13. The dwellings are mainly two-storey terraced properties set behind dwarf walls
with stone capping and black metal railings. The buildings have dual-pitched
roofs running the length of each terrace, chimneys, double-height canted bay
windows at the front (except for a small number of terraced rows located in the
north-western corner of the CA) and 2-storey outriggers to the rear. The
materials used externally are pressed brick for the front elevations, common
Appeal Decisions APP/Z4310/D/21/3268615
3
brick at the rear and stone sills and headers. Roofs would originally have been
covered in slate, window frames would have been timber sliding sash and doors
would have been timber.
14. Properties in the CA have been subject to alterations over the years. Many of
the dwellings have been extended and/or altered at the rear, including
alterations to fenestration openings, which are widespread. Several have had
dormers inserted in the rear roof slopes. Many have had roof lights inserted in
the front and/or rear roof slopes. Most of the timber sash window frames and
doors have been replaced with upvc or aluminium frames and upvc or
composite doors. A lot of the slate roof tiles have been replaced with concrete
roof tiles, and a few of the properties have lost their iron railings.
15. The appeal property is a typical example of a two-storey, mid-terrace by-law
dwelling, as described above, located on one of the central streets within the
CA. The original timber sash windows and timber doors have been replaced
with mainly upvc goods, concrete roof tiles have replaced the original slates
and some detailing to the chimney has been lost. Nevertheless, the building as
it stands contributes to the significance of the CA as a whole.
16. The development includes the insertion of a dormer in the rear roof slope, sited
above the 2-storey outrigger. It would be the width of the outrigger and have a
flat roof set below the existing main roof ridge. I consider the siting, size and
design of the dormer would significantly interrupt the original uniform roof
slope of the property and that of the terrace within which it is positioned. The
dormer would be clearly visible from several surrounding properties and by
users of the alley (although I acknowledge that access to the alley appears to
be restricted). It would be an incongruous, obtrusive feature within the
roofscape. As such, I conclude that the dormer would have a detrimental
impact on the host property, and it would neither preserve nor enhance the
character or appearance of the CA.
17. Although I do not know the full details of other cases the appellant has drawn
my attention to, I acknowledge that there are dormers within the vicinity of the
site, some of which, according to the appellant, have been granted planning
permission during the current plan period. However, there are currently only a
small number in the terrace the appeal property is located within and the
terrace to the rear of the site, on Empress Road. Furthermore, the dormers
that I was able to see also, in my opinion, had a detrimental effect on the
character and appearance of the CA. I consider such examples should therefore
not be sited as justification for further harmful development. I disagree with
the appellant’s assertion that dormers are now an established part of the
character and appearance of the area.
18. With regard to the alterations to fenestration at the rear of the property and
insertion of 2 roof lights at the front, I acknowledge the Council’s view that the
fenestration as altered would not be in keeping with the original uniformity of
the size of openings. However, given the restricted view of the proposed
fenestration changes, due to the presence of rear outriggers, and the
widespread presence of alterations to the rear of the terrace and the terrace
opposite, I consider such alterations have a neutral effect on the character and
appearance of the host property and the terrace. I consider that the
conservation style roof lights that would be inserted in the front roof slope,
which would barely project above the existing roof pitch, would not significantly
Appeal Decisions APP/Z4310/D/21/3268615
4
alter the roofscape of the property or the terrace. Bearing these factors in
mind, I therefore conclude that the alterations to the rear fenestration and
insertion of 2 sky lights at the front would have a neutral effect on the
character and appearance of the CA.
19. The development also includes replacing the existing window frames on the
front of the property with sliding sash, timber frames and replacing the existing
door with a 4-panelled, Victorian style timber composite door. I consider these
aspects would, to a minor degree, enhance the appearance of the property,
which would therefore enhance the appearance of the CA.
20. With reference to paragraph 202 of the Framework, I consider the degree of
harm to the character and appearance of the CA resulting from the dormer to
be less than substantial. The Framework advises that such harm should be
weighed against any public benefits resulting from the proposal.
Other Considerations/Planning Balance
21. I have found that the replacement windows at the front, front door and
replacement railings would enhance the appearance of the property and the CA
to a limited degree; as such, I attach limited weight to this aspect. The
development would also provide minor economic benefits, mainly during the
construction phase, to which I also attach limited weight, given their small
scale. The up grading of the property would be of minor social benefit to future
occupiers of the property; as such, I also attach limited weight to this matter.
22. Notwithstanding my conclusions regarding alterations to fenestration, the
insertion of sky lights, the minor enhancements resulting from replacement
front windows, door and railings at the front of the property, and the minor
social benefits, I consider the significant harm to the character and appearance
of the CA resulting from the proposed dormer would not be outweighed by the
other considerations outlined.
23. Consequently, the development as a whole does not accord with saved policies
HD10 and HD18 of the Liverpool City Council Unitary Development Plan (2002),
which I consider to be consistent with design and heritage policies in the
Framework in respect of their overall aim to preserve or enhance heritage
assets. Nor does the proposal accord with policies HD1, UD1 and UD7 of the
Emerging Liverpool Local Plan 2013-2033, to which I attach moderate weight
overall, given the outstanding requirement for the Council to consult on main
modifications. Collectively, and among other things, these policies require
development to respect the character of existing buildings, retain/conserve
distinctive historic features/aspects that contribute to the significance of
heritage assets, ensure development does not adversely affect the character or
appearance of a CA and ensure, in terms of design, that the scale and massing
of development relate to the locality and characteristics of local distinctiveness.
Other Matters
24.The appellant has expressed dissatisfaction with the Council’s processing of the
planning application. Although I appreciate the concerns expressed, they are
matters that are not relevant to the appeal decision.
Appeal Decisions APP/Z4310/D/21/3268615
5
Conclusion
25. For the reasons outlined, I conclude that the appeal is dismissed.
J Williamson
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 13 April 2021
by J Williamson BSc (Hons) MPlan MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 18 August 2021
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/Z4310/D/21/3268615
72 Adelaide Road, Liverpool L7 8SG
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Emperor Property for an award of costs against Liverpool
City Council.
• The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission to install new windows and
doors to the front and rear, two roof lights to front elevation and to construct a dormer
to rear elevation and carry out associated works.
Decision
1. The application for a partial award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. Irrespective of the outcome of an appeal, the National Planning Practice
Guidance (PPG) advises that costs may be awarded where a party has
behaved unreasonably, and the unreasonable behaviour has directly caused
another party to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process.
Unreasonable behaviour may be procedural (relating to the process) or
substantive (relating to the issues arising from the merits of the appeal).
3. In summary, the applicant considers an award of costs is justified for the
following reasons: i) there was a substantial delay in the Council determining
the application due to delays with consultations, displaying the site notice
and advertising the application; ii) the Council considered the proposal to
include a change of use to a House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) and to
include certain works which the applicant considered to be Permitted
Development (PD); iii) the Officer Report (OR) and consultee comments
were not readily available to the applicant; iv) the Council didn’t take full
account of its own policies, emphasised the Article 4 Direction, did not
recognise the positive enhancements of the proposal in a planning balance
and the reasons for refusal were not supported by policy; v) overall there
was a lack of communication from the Council and additional time was taken
undertaking site visits and chasing up the Officer.
4. The Council claim, in response, that at the time the application was
submitted the LPA was adjusting to the new working arrangements
prompted by the Covid 19 pandemic, which resulted in significant delays in
determining applications. The Council suggest that the delay in
determination was also due to parties agreeing extensions of time to the
determination date, to allow the applicant to submit a heritage statement
and revised proposals. The Council is of the view that Council Officers
communicated with the appellant throughout the process, which included
explaining in detail the reasons for the objections to the proposal.
Additionally, it is asserted that the applicant was informed that the OR was
publicly available on the Council’s website, and that this included a full
explanation of the Conservation Officer’s consultee comments.
5. From the evidence before me, I have no doubt that there has been a
significant delay in determining the application. Although Covid 19 will
evidently have had some impact on determination times, it is evident that
there were other reasons for the delay. Additionally, it appears that both
parties played a part in the delay, though from the evidence before me I am
not able to conclude the extent to which each party contributed to the delay
in determination.
6. However, even if the Council did not communicate with the applicant to a
standard they expect and which they consider to be unreasonable, such
matters have not resulted in the appellant incurring wasted time or expense
in the appeal process. It seems to me that even if there were no delays and
communications were of an agreeable standard, the Council would have still
refused the application, thereby leaving the applicant with the option of
pursuing an appeal. Therefore, if the applicant wishes to pursue such
matters further, I suggest the Council’s complaints procedure is potentially
the appropriate method for dealing with them.
7. With regard to matters relating to PD rights and a change of use that was
not applied for, I note that the issue of whether the site was to be used as a
HMO was raised in representations. As such, I consider the matter had to be
addressed in the OR. The matter is raised in the OR, and it clearly says that
the description of development does not include a change of use. It
subsequently says that as the applicant could use the property as a 6 bed
HMO without planning permission, the assessment was confined to the
operational development applied for.
8. In respect of PD rights, although I have reached a different view to the
Council in the associated appeal decision on the matter of the impact of the
proposed alterations to floors & ceilings on the appearance of the building,
the Council is entitled to reach the view that it did. Thus, in the Council’s
opinion, the internal alterations had a material impact on the external
appearance of the property and therefore such works were deemed to be
development that required planning permission.
9. On matters of taking account of and referencing policies, the OR lists the
range of policies relevant to the determination of the application and the
relevant policies are referred to in the reasons for refusal. Although the
applicant considers the proposal satisfies such policies, this appears to be a
difference of opinion, rather than the Council not acknowledging
development plan policies.
10. In terms of the planning balance, although this could be more clearly laid out
in the OR, the OR does refer to the proposal including the reinstatement of
some traditional details and that these would enhance the appearance of the
property. The Officer concludes that these aspects would not outweigh the
harm identified.
11. For the reasons outlined above, I therefore conclude that it has not been
demonstrated that the Council’s behaviour during the application process
was unreasonable behaviour which caused the applicant to incur
unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process, as described in the
PPG. Therefore, an award of costs is not justified.
J Williamson
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.