Erection of first floor side extension. Erection of rear extension. Raising of eaves and ridge levels to form living accommodation with associated works
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 22 March 2021
by L Wilson BA (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 31 March 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/W4705/D/21/3267513
Two Chimneys, Mytholmes, Haworth, Keighley BD22 7RB
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Jake Crossley against the decision of City of Bradford
Metropolitan District Council.
• The application Ref 20/03686/HOU, dated 21 August 2020, was refused by notice dated
15 December 2020.
• The development proposed is erection of first floor side extension. Erection of rear
extension. Raising of eaves and ridge levels to form living accommodation with
associated works.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are as follows:
• Whether the proposal is inappropriate development in the Green Belt for
the purposes of the National Planning Policy Framework (the
‘Framework’) and development plan policy;
• The effect of the proposal on the openness of the Green Belt;
• The effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the host
property and the surrounding area; and
• If the development is inappropriate, whether the harm, by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations. If so, would this amount to the very special
circumstances required to justify the proposal.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
3. Paragraph 145 of the Framework states that new buildings are inappropriate in
the Green Belt unless they fall within the given list of exceptions. Under section
c) of that paragraph an extension to a building will not be inappropriate
provided that it would not result in disproportionate additions over and above
the size of the original building.
Appeal Decision APP/W4705/D/21/3267513
2
4. The Framework defines an original building as a building as it existed on 1 July
1948 or, if constructed after 1 July 1948, as it was built originally. However, it
does not specify what might be a disproportionate addition over and above the
size of the original building.
5. The Council’s Householder Supplementary Planning Document (2012) (SPD)
states that where proposals result in an addition of over 30% of the original
cubic volume, they are likely to be considered disproportionate. Both main
parties agree that the proposed development would be marginally above this
threshold.
6. Although I acknowledge that the scheme would only be slightly over the 30%
threshold, and a degree of the volume increase would be to the rear, the
scheme would result in a bulkier building due to the increase in volume and
floorspace. The proposed development would result in a significant increase in
the scale and massing of the dwelling compared to the original building as the
scheme would substantially increase the height of the building as well as
incorporating extensions to the side and rear. Therefore, having regard to the
volume and floorspace increase, the scheme would result in a disproportionate
addition over and above the size of the original building.
7. Accordingly, based on the evidence presented, the proposal would not fall
under any of the exceptions listed in the Framework and would be
inappropriate development in the Green Belt, having regard to Policy SC7 of
the Local Plan for the Bradford District: Core Strategy Development Plan
Document (2017) (CS), which seeks to protect the Green Belt, and the SPD.
Openness
8. The fundamental aim of Green Belt policy is to prevent urban sprawl by
keeping land permanently open; the essential characteristics of Green Belts are
their openness and their permanence.
9. The front and side elevations of the property are clearly visible from the
surrounding area because the appeal site abuts the pavement and due to the
topography of the area. The removal of the outbuilding would have a spatial
benefit upon the openness of the Green Belt. However, the outbuilding is
visually unobtrusive and currently has limited visual impact upon the openness
of the Green Belt because it is well screened from the highway due to the
existing dwelling.
10. The proposed development would have a visual impact upon the openness of
the Green Belt as a result of the increase in height and massing which would be
conspicuous from public vantage points.
11. The majority of the additional floorspace would be above the existing footprint
of the building. Nevertheless, the scheme would have a spatial impact upon the
Green Belt given the significant increase in scale and massing which would
result in a significant erosion of three-dimensional space and thus erosion of
openness.
12. Accordingly, having regard to the physical size of the proposal as well as the
removal of the outbuilding, the development would have a detrimental effect
upon the openness of the Green Belt. As such, the proposal would conflict with
the purposes of Green Belt policy, as stated in the Framework, to keep land
permanently open.
Appeal Decision APP/W4705/D/21/3267513
3
Character and appearance
13. The host property is a prominent stone-built dwelling which reads as a two-
storey building from the road. The Council highlight that the appeal site is
located within the Worth Valley/ North Beck Landscape Character Area.
14. Within the surrounding area dwellings vary in their design, scale and massing.
In the immediate street scene are primarily traditional two-storey, stone
terraces. There are also a small number of three-storey properties. The appeal
building currently makes a positive contribution to the area because of its
traditional, well-proportioned appearance and attractive architectural features
including the two chimneys and window sills.
15. The scheme would result in both the eaves and ridge height increasing,
extensions to the side and rear as well as alterations to the two chimney
stacks. The appellant highlights that the use of traditional features,
contemporary elements and matching materials have been implemented to
achieve good design and to enhance the architectural appearance of the
existing dwelling.
16. The creation of an additional floor to the front elevation would significantly alter
the character and appearance of the host dwelling. The proposed increase in
scale and massing would fail to respect the proportions of the existing building
which is currently well balanced. The extension would dominate the existing
building rather than reading as subordinate to the main form of the house.
17. The development would overwhelm the original design of the building and
would not respect the basic shape, proportions and size of the existing property
due to the increase in height and additional scale and massing. The
continuation of the extension from the existing building is also likely to result in
an awkward join of new and old materials. The alterations to the rear elevation
would have less of a harmful impact as the rear is not conspicuous from public
vantage points.
18. The two chimney stacks are a key and prominent feature of the design of the
existing property and presumably link to the name of the property. Prominent
chimneys are also an important feature of traditional buildings within the
surrounding area. The amended stacks would be significantly smaller and
would not reflect the appearance of the existing stacks due to primarily their
height. The proposed alterations to the chimneys would therefore be harmful
as they are an important element of the building. Thus, the scheme would
compromise the character and appearance of the host property and
surrounding area because it would detract from the character and appearance
of the original building.
19. Consequently, the scheme would conflict with Policies EN4, DS1, DS2 and DS3
of the CS which seek, amongst other matters, to ensure development
proposals achieve good design through responding to the character of the area.
Other considerations
20. Development should not be approved unless the harm to the Green Belt, and
any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other considerations.
21. The appellant states that the majority of the works could be completed under
permitted development rights. They also highlight that the scheme would have
Appeal Decision APP/W4705/D/21/3267513
4
a smaller volume increase and would be architecturally more appropriate than
that allowed under permitted development. However, I have no substantive
evidence which demonstrates that an alternative scheme would be carried out
under permitted development rights should this appeal be dismissed.
Accordingly, I attach very limited weight to this matter, in any event, I must
determine the appeal based on the merits of the scheme.
22. The appellant also highlights that the demolition of the outbuilding would be a
benefit to the landscape. The removal of the outbuilding does weigh in favour
of the scheme. Nonetheless, as highlighted above, it is located to the rear of
the property and therefore has limited visual impact upon the Green Belt and
character of the surrounding area compared to the obtrusive and
disproportionate proposed development. Thus, I attach very limited weight to
this consideration.
Whether very special circumstances exist
23. The Framework identifies that substantial weight should be given to any harm
to the Green Belt and that inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful
to the Green Belt. I have concluded that the development constitutes
inappropriate development in the Green Belt and would cause harm to the
openness of the Green Belt. This is a matter which carries substantial weight.
Additional weight is given to the harm to the character and appearance of the
host property and surrounding area. As cited above, the proposal conflicts with
both local and national planning policy.
24. The advanced considerations relating to permitted development rights and the
outbuilding are given very limited weight. When drawing this together, the
matters in support of the appeal whether taken individually or cumulatively, do
not, on balance clearly outweigh the conflict with planning policies that seek to
protect the Green Belt. Therefore, the very special circumstances necessary to
justify the development do not exist.
Conclusion
25. For the reasons given above, the proposal would amount to ‘inappropriate
development’ that would cause harm to the openness of the Green Belt. There
are no very special circumstances to outweigh this harm. Furthermore, the
proposal would significantly harm the character and appearance of the host
property and surrounding area. The development is contrary to the relevant
policies of the CS and would also not comply with the SPD or the Framework.
The proposal would therefore conflict with the development plan and there are
no other considerations that outweigh this conflict.
26. For all of those reasons, the appeal should be dismissed.
L M Wilson
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.