For a loft conversion involving a change in the roof height and the addition of rooflights, new exterior finish, demolition of existing garage and replacement with a two bay carport
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Rural Impact
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 16 March 2021
by Elizabeth Lawrence BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 06 May 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/C1435/D/21/3266652
Looking West, Monastery Gardens, Rotherfield, Crowborough, East Sussex,
TN6 3NB
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Alan Bond against the decision of Wealden District Council.
• The application Ref WD/2020/0253/F, dated 3 February 2020, was refused by notice
dated 1 December 2020
• The development proposed is for a loft conversion involving a change in the roof height
and the addition of rooflights, new exterior finish, demolition of existing garage and
replacement with a two bay carport.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for a loft conversion
involving a change in the roof height and the addition of rooflights, new
exterior finish, demolition of existing garage and replacement with a two bay
carport at Looking West, Monastery Gardens, Rotherfield, Crowborough, East
Sussex, TN6 3NB in accordance with the terms of the application, Ref
WD/2020/0253/F, dated 3 February 2020, and the plans submitted with it,
subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years from the
date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the
following approved plans: 668-01 Rev.A, 668-02, 668-03 Rev. A, 668-04, 668-
05, 668-06.
3) Prior to the commencement of the development hereby permitted
details/samples of the materials to be used in the construction of the external
surfaces of the walls and roof of the dwelling and the structural supports and
roof of the carport have been submitted to and approved in writing by the local
planning authority. Such details shall include the type of timber and the colour
and tone of any staining/painting; the form, colour, tone and finish of the
standing seam zinc cladding; and the colour and tone of the steel columns. The
development shall be carried out strictly in accordance with the approved
details/samples.
4) Prior to the commencement of the development hereby permitted, including
demolition, the existing hedgerow along the western boundary of the site shall
be protected by a fence providing a landscape buffer in accordance with a
scheme that shall first have been submitted to and approved in writing by the
local planning authority. The scheme shall include plans showing the type and
position of all protective fencing. The landscape buffer shall be undisturbed
Appeal Decision APP/C1435/D/21/3266652
2
during the construction period and the fencing shall be maintained until all
equipment, machinery and surplus materials have been removed from the site.
5) The development hereby permitted shall be subject to a Bat Mitigation Licence
approved by Natural England and carried out in accordance with the mitigation
and enhancement measures recommended in paragraph 5 of the Bat Presence &
Absence Survey issued by Mountfield Ecology on 17 July 2020.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the host property and the surrounding area, including the setting of the
Rotherfield Conservation Area (RCA).
Reasons
3. The appeal site is located on the edge of the built-up area of Rotherfield and
borders onto gardens and an area of undulating open countryside. It is within
the High Weald Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) and abuts the RCA.
4. The RCA is irregular shaped and spirals out from St Deny’s Church. It
encompasses the historic buildings and areas of land throughout the village,
which are predominantly two storeys in height. They include a mixture of
detached, semi-detached and terraced buildings typically with brick, tile hung
and weatherboarded walls, along with some exposed timber-framing, stucco
and roughcast render. The vast majority of their roofs comprise plain clay
tiles, with some slate.
5. The church grounds, Green and small areas of open space help link the RCA to
the countryside. The views out of the village and over the surrounding rural
landscape reinforce its rural village landscape. In views into the village the
church spire forms a focal point, which together with the historic buildings
reinforces the rural and historic origins of the RCA.
6. These features all contribute to the character, appearance and significance of
the RCA.
7. The RCA excludes the modern housing developments within the village and this
includes Monastery Gardens. Monastery Gardens slopes down to the west and
the Appeal property is situated at the western end of the cul-de-sac. The
northern part of the appeal site abuts modern housing on two sides and the
open countryside, which falls away to the west.
8. The southern part of the appeal site abuts the RCA on three sides. This
includes a private drive with part of the rear garden to Town Hill House beyond.
Town Hill House comprises a grade II listed 18th century red brick and tile hung
dwelling. It has a generous sized garden and a large historic outbuilding
located between the dwelling and the appeal site. This outbuilding has brick
walls with exposed timber frames and a 45 degree pitched plain clay tiled roof
with gable ends. Town Hill House fronts onto Church Road and sits diagonally
opposite the church, which is set back from the road and occupies an open,
spacious and elevated position within the street scene.
9. The appeal dwelling sits at a lower level to Monastery Road and the other
dwellings within the road. Unlike the other dwellings the appeal dwelling is set
back from the street scene and comprises a 1960’s bungalow with a shallow
pitched roof. The bungalow is visually bland and singularly unattractive. It is
Appeal Decision APP/C1435/D/21/3266652
3
however screened by existing dwellings in views along Monastery Gardens and
from High Street and is only clearly visible from the western end of Monastery
Gardens and the open field beyond. To the front of the dwelling, occupying a
prominent position at the end of Monastery Gardens, is a single garage with
brick and block walls, a white painted metal up and over door and an
asymmetrical shallow pitched roof.
10. The other dwellings in Monastery Gardens comprise a diverse range of two
storey family sized dwellings with red and multi bricks, render, tile hanging and
painted timber boarded walls under slate and plain tiled roofs. The older
dwellings have steeply pitched roofs and strong gable features, which is a
common feature within the RCA. Whilst there are a number of flat and pitched
roofed garages within Monastery Gardens they are located to the sides of the
dwellings they serve and set back from the street scene.
11. The settlement, together with the surrounding undulating fields that are
enclosed by mature trees and hedgerows and the area of woodland to the
northwest of Rotherfield all contribute to the quality and scenic beauty of this
part of the AONB.
12. Overall, I find that the appeal dwelling and garage are unattractive, visually
tired and out of keeping with the other dwellings in the road and this part of
the RCA. They have a degrading impact on their immediate surroundings,
including the open countryside to the west, detracting from their quality,
character and appearance. However, as views of the site from the RCA and
Town Hill House are very limited, the appeal property has a neutral impact on
their character, appearance and significance.
3. Section 66 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990
(LBCA Act) requires that when assessing proposals for new development which
affects the setting of a listed building, special attention shall be paid to the
desirability of preserving its setting. Section 72 of the LBCA Act requires that
in the exercise, with respect to any buildings or other land in a conservation
area, of any functions under or by virtue of any of the provisions referred to,
special attention shall be paid to the desirability of preserving or enhancing its
character or appearance.
4. Section 16 of the National Planning Policy Framework (Framework) states that
when considering the impact of a development on the significance of a
designated heritage asset great weight should be given to its conservation.
Any harm to the significance of a designated heritage asset from development
within its setting requires clear and convincing justification. Where a proposal
would lead to less than substantial harm to a designated heritage asset, this
harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal.
5. Together and amongst other things policies WCS14, SPO1 and SPO13 of the
Wealden Core Strategy Local Plan 2013 (CS), policies GD1, EN1, EN6, EN27
and HG10 of the Wealden Local Plan 1998 (LP) and sections 2, 12, 15 and 16
of the Framework, promote sustainable forms of development. They seek to
protect and enhance the distinct landscapes of the District and promote local
distinctiveness through good design. Within the AONB new development
should conserve or enhance the natural beauty and landscape value of the
landscape and particular regard will be paid to building styles and materials.
New development will be permitted where it respects the character of adjoining
Appeal Decision APP/C1435/D/21/3266652
4
development and where possible promote local distinctiveness. Extensions
should be sympathetic and appropriate in relation to existing buildings.
6. The overall size, form, design and use of standing seam zinc and timber
cladding would result in the dwelling having a simple contemporary and
agricultural character and appearance. The proposed informal fenestration
would add to its agricultural barn appearance. These features would not be out
of place having regard to the location of the appeal site immediately adjoining
the open countryside and set against a backcloth of mature planting to the rear
and the flank wall of a taller dwelling to the east.
7. The height, roof pitch and strong gable features of the resultant dwelling would
respect and reinforce the prevailing character and appearance of Monastery
Gardens. At the same time the dwelling would remain lower than the adjacent
dwellings and largely hidden within the street scene. Whilst contemporary the
timber cladding within the gable ends would reflect the use of timber cladding
in Monastery Gardens. The standing seam zinc cladding on the main walls and
roof of the dwelling would be visually distinct from other buildings in the area.
However, the dwellings within Monastery Gardens include a diverse mix and
colour of external materials and the use of zinc would simply add to this mix.
8. For these reasons, subject to the colour, tone and finish of the standing seam
zinc and timber cladding, the resultant dwelling would appear semi-agricultural
and visually discrete against the backcloth of existing dwellings and mature
planting in views from the adjacent open countryside. It would form an
appropriate transition between the adjacent dwellings both in Monastery
Gardens and Church Road and the open countryside. Also, due to the location
of the site on the edge of the settlement, the resultant dwelling would make an
appropriate contribution to the diverse range of building forms, designs and
materials within the locality.
9. The proposed carport would be visually slimline and lightweight. Unlike the
existing garage, it would provide views through to and from the open
countryside at the end of Monastery Gardens. As with the resultant dwelling it
would appear semi-agricultural and subject to the colour, tone and finish of the
steel supports and roof covering it would blend in with its immediate setting
and rural backcloth. I find that the proposed carport would be visually modest
and far less intrusive than the existing garage. As such it would have a
positive impact on the street scene and the wider setting of the appeal
property, including the very limited glimpses from the RCA and Town Hill
House.
10. For these reasons the proposed development would respect, reinforce and be
readily assimilated into its surroundings and would preserve the scenic and
landscape beauty of the AONB. Further, it would preserve the character and
appearance of the RCA and Town Hill House, having a neutral impact on their
significance.
11. The colour, tone and finish of the standing seam zinc, timber cladding and steel
carport supports can all be secured through the imposition of a condition.
Similarly, the retention and protection of the hedge along the western
boundary of the site and the mitigation measures set out in the ecological
appraisal by Mountfield Ecology can be secured through the imposition of
conditions. This is necessary to ensure the protection of bats and their
supporting habitat and to secure opportunities for enhancement of the nature
Appeal Decision APP/C1435/D/21/3266652
5
conservation value of the site in line with national planning policy. Neither the
Councill nor the applicant have raised any concerns regarding the need for and
wording of these conditions.
12. The Councill has suggested the imposition of conditions relating to the
adherence to the approved drawings and the erection of a 1.8 metre high fence
along the northern side of the proposed carport and adherence to the approved
drawings. This is to protect the living conditions of the occupiers of ‘Salforda’
and in the interests of certainty. Whilst the suggested approved drawings
condition is clearly necessary, I do not consider that the proposed fence
condition is necessary. This is because the proposed structure is purely a
carport and there is already a tall fence along the front boundary to ‘Salforda’.
13. I conclude that the proposal would change and materially improve the
character and appearance of the host building and would respect the character
and appearance its immediate and wider surroundings. It would preserve the
character and appearance of the RCA and would not detract from its
significance. Accordingly, the proposal would comply with CS Policies WCS14,
SPO1 and SPO13, LP Policies GD1, EN1, EN6, EN27 & HG10 and sections 2, 12,
15 and 16 of the Framework.
Elizabeth Lawrence
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.