Construction of a hard-standing area for off street parking, supporting side walls and store

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 15 March 2021 by M Seaton DipTP MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government Decision date: 30 March 2021 Appeal Ref: APP/X4725/D/21/3266247 27 Brookfield Avenue, Castleford, WF10 4BJ • The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission. • The appeal is made by Mr David Prince against the decision of City of Wakefield Metropolitan District Council. • The application Ref 20/01334/FUL, dated 7 July 2020, was refused by notice dated 15 December 2020. • The development is the construction of a hard-standing area for off street parking, supporting side walls and store. Procedural Matter 1. The description of development as set out on the planning application forms did not include reference to the supporting side walls and store, and the appellant maintains that the Council unilaterally changed the description without the agreement of the appellant. However, it is quite clear that to facilitate the provision of the hardstanding it is necessary to provide supporting side walls. Furthermore, the area under the hardstanding would appear to provide access to what is described as a store by virtue of the doors set within the northern end elevation. 2. Whilst I acknowledge the appellant’s point, I do not find the change of description to be inaccurate but merely a more detailed reflection of precisely what has been proposed and constructed. I also note that it is consistent with the re-wording of the enforcement notice undertaken by the Inspector in the decisions under appeal references APP/X4725/C/20/3250101 & APP/X4725/C/20/3250102 dated 9 October 2020, which has been reported in the Council’s Delegated Report. I have therefore adopted the varied description of development. Decision 3. The appeal is dismissed. Main Issue 4. The Council’s submissions clearly focus on the impact of the development on both the living conditions of neighbouring occupiers and the character and appearance of the original dwelling and surrounding area, with harm found in both instances. I note that the terms and wording of the reason for refusal focus on the impact on residential amenity, but on a fair reading of the Council’s Delegated Report, it is clear that the Council’s concerns encompass visual impact of the development on the locality as well. Appeal Decision APP/X4725/D/21/3266247 2 5. The main issues are therefore, i) the effect of the development on the character and appearance of the original dwelling and the area; and ii) whether the development safeguards the living conditions of neighbouring occupiers, having regard to outlook. Reasons Background 6. The appeal site is occupied by a two-storey semi-detached dwelling set on the southern side of Brookfield Avenue, a residential street. The entire appeal site slopes up towards its southern end, with a significant increase in levels within the rear garden between the dwelling and the rear boundary, which is defined by a part wall and fence. Beyond the site to the south is the verge and carriageway of Close Road, a further residential street. 7. Further to the refusal of planning permission following the dismissed appeal (Ref: APP/X4725/W/19/3238719) dated January 2020, for the construction of a hard-standing area for storage of vehicle to rear of property and changes to rear boundary, the appellant has indicated the current appeal scheme to incorporate revisions to the proposals. 8. It is indicated the concrete surface of the hardstanding is to be reduced in length to 4.75m, with coping stones to be utilised to delineate the boundary between the hardstanding, and the remaining roof of the shed/store which is to be covered in felt to waterproof it. A line of coping stones was observed to have been placed across the hardstanding at the time of my visit albeit that the works to the roof of the store had not taken place. The hardstanding was in use for the parking of a modest-sized 3-wheeled vehicle. 9. The appellant has contended that the sections of hardstanding under 300mm above the ground level would not require planning permission, and therefore should be regarded as permitted development. However, I would concur with the Council’s assessment and reference to the October 2020 appeal decisions that the current hardstanding and store are indivisible and form part of the same planning operation. On the basis of this definition, the provision of a raised platform for the use as proposed would not be permitted in accordance with Class E.1(h), Part 1, Schedule 2 of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015, and the definition of raised as set out in the Interpretation of Part 1. 10. Irrespective of the above conclusion, no evidence has been adduced that any aspect of the development has been formally established as permitted development, and in order for this to be the case this is a matter which would need to be addressed through an appropriate application. For this reason, no valid fall-back position has been placed before me. Character and appearance 11. The structure occupies a prominent position towards the highest part of the garden. Even allowing for its visibility through the gaps between existing properties on Brookfield Avenue, I am satisfied that it does not appear as an obtrusive feature in the context of other existing terraces and garden buildings located in neighbouring curtilages on Brookfield Avenue in similar positions. However, despite considering the reduced length of the hardstanding for vehicular parking, it is the continued use of the hardstanding for vehicular Appeal Decision APP/X4725/D/21/3266247 3 parking in combination with the structure which results in the incongruity of the proposal within the appeal site and area. 12. I note that the hardstanding has been used in the past for the parking of a caravan, as has been illustrated from the photographic submissions of interested parties. However, irrespective of whether this was to be the case again in the future or it was to be used by a small vehicle such as was in situ at the time of my visit or any other vehicle, the prominence and exposed position of the hardstanding when in use results in an incongruous visual impact within an elevated position in the rear garden, which would be uncharacteristic of the area. In this regard, I also see no reason to depart from the conclusions of the Inspector from the January 2020 appeal that it would not be possible to satisfactorily screen the use of the hardstanding without creating further visual harm by virtue of any mitigative measures. 13. The appellant has drawn my attention to circumstances whereby properties in Close Road have been able to benefit from vehicular access to the rear from Brookfield Avenue. However, whilst such occurrences essentially present the reverse of the appeal scheme, I do not see the circumstances to be directly comparable given that any parking would be located towards the lowest point of the site and therefore lack the adverse visual impact of the appeal scheme. 14. For these reasons, I conclude that despite the alterations from the previous scheme, the development continues to have an adverse effect on the character and appearance of the dwelling and the area. The proposal would therefore conflict with Policies D9 and D10 of the Wakefield Development Policies 2009 (the Wakefield DP), and the guidance set out in the Wakefield District Residential Design Guide Supplementary Planning Document Part 2: Guidance for Householders 2018 (RDG), in this regard. These policies and guidance seek to ensure that development is of a high quality of design appropriate to their location in terms of design, scale, massing, materials and colour and protect and enhance local character and distinctiveness, and is not discordant with the style of the original dwelling or result in significant harm to the character of the area. Living conditions 15. I have already acknowledged that the appeal scheme has reduced the extent of the hardstanding which could be utilised for the parking of vehicles, with the 2.6m closest to the dwelling to be completed solely as a roof atop the store. However, from my observations, the reduction would not make sufficient improvement to the impact on residential amenity from the use of the hardstanding, having regard to outlook. For users of the neighbouring garden of No. 25 Brookfield Avenue, I agree that the elevated position adjacent to the boundary which any vehicle using the hardstanding would occupy, would appear as a substantial and incongruous feature within this elevated part of the appeal site, and would loom over the lower parts of the neighbouring private garden in particular, to the detriment of the amenity of users. I accept that this would continue to result in an adverse impact on outlook. 16. I have noted the Council’s assessment of the impact of the proposals on the privacy of neighbouring occupiers, and that they have been reached in conjunction with the conclusions of the Inspector for the January 2020 appeal. From my observations of the contours and levels of the appeal site and adjoining gardens, and how adjoining gardens are used particularly towards Appeal Decision APP/X4725/D/21/3266247 4 their highest points, I would agree with the conclusion that a degree of mutual overlooking is inevitable between adjoining gardens and towards neighbouring properties. I do not find that the development results in any significant departure from the existing privacy inter-relationships viewed between adjoining sites. 17. I therefore find that the development does not safeguard the living conditions of neighbouring occupiers, having regard to outlook. The scheme does not accord with Policies D9 and D10 of the Wakefield DP, and the guidance within the RDG, which seek to protect the residential amenity of neighbouring occupiers from significant detrimental impact and harm. Other Matters 18. The appellant has expressed concerns over the Council’s approach to decision- making. In this regard, the Council must assess each case on its own planning merits, and this must be done so in accordance with the development plan unless material considerations indicate otherwise, as required by Section 38(6) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004. As I have concluded in my reasoning, the Council has clearly met this threshold in respect of the development plan but was dutybound to consider the current scheme in conjunction with the previous appeal decisions as valid material considerations. 19. With regards delays to the determination of the planning application, I do not find that determination of the planning application further to receipt of the results of the enforcement appeal to be unreasonable, particularly given that all options for a decision would have been available to the Inspector. However, I am also mindful that in any event it would have been within the gift of the appellant to have appealed against the failure of the Council to reach a decision within the statutory timeframe, which would have been the available sanction in this circumstance, albeit that ultimately this option was not taken up. 20. I have also noted the contention of the appellant that the Council has failed to act impartially and has been inconsistent with previous decisions. However, there is no compelling evidence of impartiality and as I have already addressed, the Council’s submissions are well-reasoned and clearly linked to the policies of the development plan. 21. With regards consistency, I have noted the references to previous decision- making for a dwelling on Lansdowne Avenue and the rejection of a parking area accessed from the rear at No. 11 Brookfield Avenue. However, I am not persuaded that the circumstances of a dwelling on Lansdowne Avenue could be said to be directly comparable, and even allowing for the absence of any specific details of the parking area that was proposed at No. 11, I do not find the omission of a reason for refusal on similar grounds to the appeal scheme to set a precedent for how the appeal scheme should be determined. 22. The appellant has also raised the provision of the parking space as a benefit given that it would alleviate parking demand on Brookfield Avenue, which is used by a variety of size of vehicles in connection with the Care Home. However, there is no evidence of highway safety concerns related to parking on Brookfield Avenue, and I did not observe that the characteristics of on-street parking at the time of my visit provided any particular support for the provision as a benefit. I have not therefore attached any significant weight to this contention. Appeal Decision APP/X4725/D/21/3266247 5 23. I have also had regard to the various other issues which have been raised by interested parties including concerns over the structural stability of the development, drainage from the structure, and highway safety issues related to traffic and manoeuvring on Close Road. However, whilst I am mindful of the absence of objections from the Council on these matters, because of my conclusions on the main issues there has not been any need for me to consider them in any detail. Conclusion 24. For the reasons set out above, the proposal would conflict with the development plan as a whole and there are no other considerations, including the provisions of the Framework, which outweigh this finding. Therefore, for the reasons given, the appeal should not succeed. Martin Seaton INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →