Front dormer and rear first floor extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
1
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 25 March 2021
by J Somers BSocSci (Planning) MA (HEC) MRTPI IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of Stat e
Decision date: 10 May 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/L2630/D/20/3264432
104 West End Costessey NR8 5AJ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr George Carrs against the decision of South Norfolk Council.
• The application Ref 2020/1747, dated 16 September 2020, was refused by notice dated
2 November 2020.
• The development proposed is a front dormer and rear first floor extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed insofar as it relates to the rear first floor extension.
2. The appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to the front dormer, and planning
permission is granted for a front dormer at 104 West End Costessey NR8 5AJ in
accordance with the terms of the application, Ref 2020/1747, dated 16
September 2020, so far as relevant to that part of the development hereby
permitted and subject to the following condition:
1) The proposed front dormer shall be constructed in accordance with approved
plan ‘Proposed Plans, Elevations & Block Plan,’ DRG No:PL01 Rev C, By Studio
35, Dated December 2019.
Preliminary Matters
3. Both of the extensions were in situ at the time of my site visit. I have therefore
made my decision on this basis.
Main Issue
4. The main issue is the effect of the first floor rear extension upon:
• The existing building and the character and appearance of the locality;
• The living conditions of the neighbouring occupier, with particular attention
to the scale, appearance and position in relation to the neighbour.
Reasons
Character and appearance
5. The appeal site contains a semi-detached dwelling which appears to have been
constructed in the mid-late twentieth century alongside detached bungalows
and two storey dwellings. The appeal building is relatively modest in size with a
steep pitched and gabled roof and accommodation within the roof space, brick
walls and maintains setbacks to side boundaries with a large rear garden. The
dwellings along West End Road form a linear development that are modest in
Appeal Decision: APP/L2630/D/20/3264432
2
scale with domestic sized alterations and extensions which are proportionate to
the existing dwellings. Visual gaps are located between buildings to the fields
and River Wensum beyond which together with vegetated setbacks gives an
open, leafy and spacious feel in and around the dwellings. As the appeal site
forms half of a pair of semi-detached dwellings, there is also an inherent
relationship and comparable forms from the appeal site to the neighbouring
semi-detached dwelling. Along with the modest designs, massing and materials
of the dwellings, these elements contribute positively to the local character and
distinctiveness of the locality.
6. The first floor rear extension has the form of an enlarged box dormer which
extends the entire width of the roof plane and from the pitch of the rear roof
plane, however extends above a single storey rear extension also to ‘effectively
square off’ the rear of the building. The proposed extension is very large and
excessively so, in that the extension is not subservient, but the massing and
visual bulk of the extension dominates the existing roof form and has an
awkward and discordant juxtaposition with the existing design of the dwelling.
The extension is unlike anything around and would not embrace the positive
qualities of local distinctiveness which are found within the locality. The size of
the extension is also very prevalent within the street scene and further
demonstrates its inappropriateness. Whilst I agree with the applicant that the
appeal building is of modern provenance and of limited architectural interest;
the scheme still needs to be of an appropriate addition which reflects
development plan policies regarding design, massing and responding to the
local context and the character and appearance of the local area.
7. I note discussion in the applicant’s Statement of Case (SoC) with regards to an
application for a two storey rear extension with flat roof at 114 West End,
which is a detached Grade II listed building. I am not convinced that the two
schemes are alike, given that the extension to 114 West End is proportionate in
depth, bulk and massing to the original detached dwelling, unlike the appeal
site which is semi-detached and the extension is disproportionate to the
particular design of the dwelling. That said, the scheme at No.114 does not add
any weight to the consideration of the appeal proposal.
8. In conclusion on this matter, the proposed scheme would increase the size of
the existing dwelling in a way which would not reflect the local character and
appearance of the locality. The extension is excessive when compared to the
modest proportions of the existing dwelling and is discordant to the modest
sized dwellings within this context, resulting in an awkward juxtaposition that
results in an inappropriately designed scheme.
9. Consequently, the scheme would not reinforce the qualities of local character
and distinctiveness and would be harmful to the character and appearance of
the existing building and the locality. This would be contrary to South Norfolk
Local Plan Development Management Policies Document 2015 (DMP) Policy
DM1.4(d, i) (which seeks to make a positive contribution to local character and
distinctiveness); Policy DM3.4(a) (which seeks to incorporate good quality
design which maintains or enhances the character and appearance of the
building, street scene and surroundings); and Policy DM3.8(4,a) (which seeks
that scale, height, massing, form and appearance of development is designed
with a satisfactory relationship of structures, spaces and routes within the site
and a successful integration into the surroundings).
Appeal Decision: APP/L2630/D/20/3264432
3
Living Conditions
10. The Council perceives the main harm from the rear first floor extension towards
the neighbours at No.106 West End which represents the neighbouring
component of the semi-detached dwelling. No.106 West End has a small paved
area to the rear of the dwelling which then extends to the greater garden area.
The ground floor extension of the appeal site adjoins the boundary of the
neighbouring paved area, whilst the first floor rear addition creates a two
storey wall to the paved garden area of the neighbour. Given that this is the
formal paved component of the neighbour’s rear garden, the two storey blank
wall along the side of the paved space does present a poor, oppressive and
overbearing experience to users of this area.
11. At first floor level the wall of the rear first floor extension to the appeal site
extends along the party wall boundary, with this wall being approximately 12
centimetres from the neighbouring dormer window according to the Planning
Officer’s Report. The applicant’s SoC contains an internal photo of the bedroom
of the neighbouring property in order to illustrate the illumination of the room.
However it is noted that the room is also lit by artificial lighting so the full
effect of the extension on light levels to the neighbouring room cannot be
appreciated from this photograph. Whilst there is also reference to the British
Research Establishment Guidance on daylight and sunlight there are no
calculations of daylight levels to support the scheme. However, the reason for
refusal shows that the Council is more concerned that the extension presents
an ‘overbearing and oppressive’ environment for the neighbouring residents
which has considerations additional to purely a loss of light. What is clear by
the photograph in the applicant’s SoC and from my site visit is the poor level of
outlook which would be experienced from the neighbouring property. Whilst
direct views to the rear garden towards the north would be possible, the
neighbouring dormer window at first floor level would have a blank wall in very
close proximity which does present a poor and restricted outlook from this first
floor window.
12. I appreciate that the neighbouring residents have commented that they accept
the current conditions and do not feel aggrieved by the extension. However,
this is not to say that future neighbours will be of the same opinion, and that
the acceptance of the scheme by neighbours does not equate to compliance
with the development plan. I also note that there is a desire from the
neighbours to erect a similar extension to the appeal site in order to reinstate
some of the symmetry between the semi-detached dwellings. However, this is
not a matter before me and any future extensions would need to be considered
under the provisions of the development plan at that time.
13. In conclusion on this matter, and considering the above as a whole, the
distance and location of the extension to the neighbouring private paved area
and the window at first floor level presents an oppressive and overbearing
experience which would be an unreasonable level of amenity to the
neighbouring property at No.106. Consequently the first floor rear extension is
contrary to LP Policy DM3.4(b) (which seeks that residential extensions do not
have unacceptable impact on the amenities of neighbouring occupiers); and
DM3.13((1) b) 9which seeks that development has maintains a reasonable
standard of amenity in terms of loss of day light, overshadowing and
overbearing impact.
Appeal Decision: APP/L2630/D/20/3264432
4
Other Matters
14. The proposal includes a front dormer window. Whilst overly elongated, it is
modest in size and generally proportionate to the form and composition of the
appeal building. I therefore find no harm in respect of this element of the
proposal and I note the Council raised no objection in this regard either. The
appellant requests that a split decision be considered. As the front dormer and
first floor rear extension are both physically and functionally severable I
consider a split decision would be a logical outcome. That said, the front
dormer window is compliant with LP Policies DM3.4 and DM3.13.
Conclusion and Conditions
15. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should succeed in
relation to the front dormer. However, in relation to the first floor rear
extension the appeal should be dismissed.
16. In respect of the front dormer, as the development is retrospective, there is no
need for the standard time limit condition. The condition regarding the dormer
having been constructed in accordance with the approved plan is necessary as
this provides certainty to the scheme which has been approved.
J Somers
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.