Part two-storey and part single-storey side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Rural Impact
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site Visit made on 14 June 2021
by Robin Buchanan BA (Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 02 July 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/X1545/D/20/3264089
52A, Queenborough Road, Southminster, CM0 7AD
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Oliver Cole against the decision of Maldon District Council.
• The application Ref HOUSE/MAL/20/00799, dated 6 August 2020, was refused by notice
dated 1 October 2020.
• The development proposed is a part two-storey and part single-storey side extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for a part two-storey
and part single-storey side extension at 52A, Queenborough Road,
Southminster, CM0 7AD in accordance with the terms of the application,
Ref HOUSE/MAL/20/00799, dated 6 August 2020, and the plans submitted with
it, subject to the conditions set out in the attached schedule.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the development on the character and
appearance of the host building and the wider area.
Reasons
3. The host building is a detached single-storey bungalow. One half is an original
annexe outbuilding to No 52 Queenborough Road with a taller gabled roof. It
has been enlarged by an attached double garage with a lower hipped roof,
since converted to additional living accommodation. It is located behind nearby
rows of two-storey houses fronting Queenborough Road and Sheepcote Lane,
next to some detached garage outbuildings, facing countryside to the north and
west. This low key, loose knit arrangement and juxtaposition of built form at
the rear of development on this edge of Southminster, and its relationship to
the spacious open countryside, is locally distinctive.
4. The appeal proposal would redevelop the hipped part of the bungalow with a
taller extension attached to the original annexe, including rooms in the roof
with dormer windows front and back and a narrow ‘lean-to’ roof at the rear. It
would also enlarge the footprint of this part of the bungalow at the front, side
and rear. The development would therefore reverse the existing arrangement
of built form on the appeal site — from the appearance of a primary original
annexe with a subservient converted garage, to a primary chalet bungalow,
with the appearance of a cottage, and a subservient side wing. This step-up in
built form would be a reasonably large addition and moderately increase the
visual and spatial presence of a dwelling on the appeal site.
Appeal Decision APP/X1545/D/20/3264089
2
5. However, the increased scale, height and bulk of the appeal proposal would not
be excessive in height to ridge considering the slightly lowered ground level of
this part of the appeal site, or in relation to the original annexe. It would also
have a reasonably shallow roof pitch with a low eaves level, limiting the extent
of vertical elevation. This part of the building would not be significantly taller or
wider than the converted garage or the original annexe, and a gabled roof form
would complement the original annexe roof. Furthermore, despite two storeys
of internal accommodation the dormer windows would be relatively small and
well-proportioned in the roof slopes.
6. Externally, the development would not therefore appear disproportionate in
relation to the original annexe and the resulting building would remain
ostensibly single storey in overall scale, massing and appearance. In my
judgement, it would not ‘dominate’ or ‘dwarf’ the existing dwelling, as the
Council suggests. Moreover, the proposed external materials would reflect
those in the existing building and as a result would remain sympathetic to the
original annexe. The development would not therefore be a significant variance
from that which exists on the appeal site, would be substantially less extensive
in height, scale and massing to nearby houses and be broadly in keeping with
the size and pattern of single storey garage buildings near the appeal site.
7. While the appeal site is, by definition for planning policy purposes, outside of
the defined settlement boundary of Southminster, in the countryside, it is
nonetheless developed with a dwelling and, with its garden, plainly has a
domestic character and appearance. On the approach to the appeal site from
the access drive, and as would be seen from part of a more distant public
footpath, the development would have an immediate facing aspect to the
countryside. However, it would be observed in the context of a nearby
commercial site on one side, against a backdrop of trees and houses behind
and next to some reasonably large domestic outbuildings on the other side.
8. Moreover, it is near houses that are within the defined settlement boundary.
Although the appeal site is to the rear of these, in my judgement, visually and
spatially the proposed development would have more affinity with, and be part
of, the built-up area of Southminster, albeit on the edge, rather than with the
open countryside beyond. It would not therefore be overly prominent or
conspicuous or unduly erode spaciousness in relation to this rural setting or
cause harm to the character or appearance of the countryside. In addition,
most of the nearby houses along Queenborough Road and Sheepcote Lane are
reasonably closely spaced or their gardens contain intervening fences, trees,
hedges or outbuildings, including in the wider gaps next to Southminster
Library. As a result, the development would be observed in glimpsed views
over some distance, including in relation to the countryside beyond, and there
would therefore be no significant visual intrusion in this regard.
9. Consequently, I find that the development would not harm the character and
appearance of the host building or the wider area. It would accord with Policies
S1, S8, D1 and H4 of the Maldon District Local Development Plan, July 2017
(LDP). Amongst other things, these policies support alterations, extensions or
additions to buildings, including in the countryside, and aim to conserve local
context and distinctiveness and the natural and historic environments,
including the intrinsic character and beauty of the countryside in terms of
design, architecture, materials, height, size, scale, form, massing, proportion,
landscape and townscape setting, layout and orientation.
Appeal Decision APP/X1545/D/20/3264089
3
10. It would also be consistent with the National Planning Policy Framework
(Framework) paragraphs 124, 127(a), (b), (c) and (d), 170(b) and 193 which
seek to create high quality buildings and places that add to the overall quality
of the area and ensure development is visually attractive as a result of good
architecture and layout, sympathetic to local character, including the
surrounding built environment and landscape setting and maintains a strong
sense of place and protects the natural, historic and local environments,
including the countryside.
Other Matters
11. No 52 Queenborough Road1 is a Grade II listed building (LB) and a designated
heritage asset. Accordingly, great weight should be given to its conservation2.
The significance of the LB derives from its vernacular form and materials as an
early 17th-century timber framed and rendered former farmhouse, including
large original dormer windows at the front, and its immediate setting which
includes the end of its rear garden and the appeal site.
12. The development would not be prominent in key views of the LB and a
significant extent of residential development already surrounds it, including the
appeal site. While the appeal proposal would increase built form on the appeal
site, this would not be by a significant amount and it would therefore have a
neutral effect on the special architectural and historic interest of the LB and its
setting. Consequently, it would not detract from the way that the significance
of the LB is currently experienced. Accordingly, there would be no harm to, or
loss of, the significance of this designated heritage asset or its setting3 and the
appeal proposal would therefore preserve the LB and its setting.4 I note that
the Council did not object to the appeal proposal in this regard.
Conditions
13. The Council has suggested some conditions5. I have considered these and
where necessary I have modified the wording in the interests of clarity and in
light of the tests and advice in Framework paragraph 55 and in Planning
Practice Guidance
6. I have included the compulsory standard time limit
condition to ensure that the development must be begun not later than the
expiration of the specified period. I agree with the Council that a condition is
necessary to specify the approved plans and external materials. This will
ensure certainty in the interests of the character and appearance of the host
building and the wider area.
Conclusion
14. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal succeeds.
Robin Buchanan
INSPECTOR
1 Also referred to as ‘Spratt’s Farmhouse’
2 Framework paragraph 193
3 Framework paragraph 194
4 Section 66(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990
5 Council’s appeal questionnaire
6 Paragraph ID: 21a-003-20190723
Appeal Decision APP/X1545/D/20/3264089
4
Schedule of Conditions
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years from
the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans:
• 1:1250 Location plan
• 1:500 Block and roof plan
• OC 01 Existing elevations and floorplan
• OC 02B Proposed elevations and floorplans
including details of external materials as also contained in Section 5 of the
planning application form, dated 6 August 2020.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.