Part single storey front extension, single storey rear infill extension Decision
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 December 2020
by M Shrigley BSc (Hons) MPlan MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 17th December 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/T5150/D/20/3259549
30 Northwick Circle, Harrow HA3 0EE
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr R Patani against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Brent.
• The application Ref 20/1773, dated 17 June 2020, was refused by notice dated
20 August 2020.
• The development proposed is a part single storey front extension, single storey rear
infill extension
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. I note that the draft London Plan is at the intend to publish stage and carries
significant weight. However, I am directed by parties to the policies within the
appeal documents and the Council’s Decision Notice as those most relevant to
the appeal.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposed extensions on the special character
and appearance of the Northwick Circle Conservation Area (CA) including any
impacts to trees within it.
Reasons
4. The appeal property is located within the Northwick Circle CA which is
dominated by well detailed 1920 and 1930’s housing situated around a central
circular shaped road layout. The appeal property is a large detached dwelling
within a row of properties positioned around the central circle. There is
variation of housing footprints and designs along the road. Individual
architectural features of properties coupled with generous levels of trees and
garden greenery are key components of the special character and appearance
of the CA, significantly contributing to its attractiveness.
5. I am cognisant of my legal duty under Section 72(1) of the Town and Country
Planning Listed Building and Conservation Area Act 1990 to pay special
attention to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or
appearance of a conservation area. In that regard public vistas toward the
appeal property are particularly important to the outcome of the appeal. This is
Appeal Decision APP/T5150/D/20/3259549
2
because even a small unsympathetic addition would have a considerable
impact on the front elevation of the dwelling and its setting within the CA.
6. The Brent Council Northwick Circle Conservation Area Appraisal highlights the
architectural detailing of properties within the CA as part of its overall heritage
value. The special character and appearance of the CA is based on the
distinctive varying designs of individual dwellings and their setting within the
street scene.
7. The proposed front extension would fill in a deliberate set-back in the dwelling’s
front elevation. The change would lead to a more uniform elevation and would
not respect the well-executed architectural detailing of the dwelling where
elevational set backs and footprint variety is a key part of local distinctiveness
in the street scene. I also note that the Council’s Conservation Officer
requested specific plan revisions to ensure better visual integration allowing for
a set back prior to the Council making its decision.
8. The front extension would detract from the appearance of the dwelling and
would diminish the degree of variation in property elevations which makes the
area so unique. The change would be harmful to the appearance of the
dwelling and harmful to the CA.
9. Moreover, the single storey rear extension would occupy the space between
two existing extensions leading to the loss of the ground floor component of an
original two storey central bay window feature. In doing so the rear extension
would also detract from the original design detailing of the dwelling. It would
unsympathetically increase the bulk of the rear elevation considered against
adjoining extensions. I accept being located at the rear the change would be
less prominent than the proposed change to the front elevation where CA views
are more important. Nevertheless, vantages from adjoining properties as well
as the appellant’s garden also form views within the CA and therefore have a
bearing on its overall quality. I therefore find that the change to the rear
elevation would also be harmful.
10. The appellant’s submitted Aboricultural Impact Assessment confirms that the
front extension would result in the loss of a small tree from the front garden.
Given its small scale it does not add significantly to the important views within
the Conservation Area where substantial garden greenery would still remain. I
therefore find that particular change would not have a significant impact on the
character and appearance of the locality.
11. The overall harm I have identified from the extensions would impact on a
localised part of the CA when considered as a whole. Thus, the harm would be
less than substantial within the meaning of Paragraph 196 of the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework). In accordance with the
Framework this subsequently leads me to weigh up the public benefits of the
proposal. However, there are none which have been raised and I have no
evidence of any. The benefits here would be attached to the private interests of
the Appellant. Neverthless the Framework directs me to give great weight to
harm arising to the conservation of a heritage asset.
12. I appreciate that the appellant refers to other examples of nearby extended
dwellings but those relate to other properties with different design detailing and
therefore the resultant impact is not directly comparable to the appeal scheme
before me. I also acknowledge that the use of matching windows, doors and
Appeal Decision APP/T5150/D/20/3259549
3
materials can be utilised for the extensions but that would not overcome the
harm identified.
13. I therefore conclude that the development would have a harmful impact on the
special character and appearance of the Northwick Circle CA. The development
would be contrary to Policy DMP1 and DMP7 of the London Borough of Brent
Local Plan Development Management Policies (2016) which aim to provide high
levels of amenity which complements the locality; and to protect heritage
assets from incremental harm. It would conflict with guidance in the Northwick
Circle Character Appraisal (2006) which aims to minimise damage arising from
unsympathetic extensions in order to protect the heritage asset from
incremental damage. It would also conflict with the provisions of Section 72(1)
of the Town and Country Planning Listed Building and Conservation Area Act
1990.
Other Matters
14. The Council’s delegated report confirms there is an Article 4 Direction affecting
the CA. The appellant also acknowledges permitted development rights have
been removed from the property. As a result, there is no fall-back position for
other development which may be theoretically possible for me to consider.
Moreover, the justifications referenced to other nearby dormer development
are not comparable to the appeal proposal and I have already acknowledged
there are different degrees of prominence in the CA between the front and rear
elevation of the property. Therefore, references to how the Council has justified
other development carries no significant weight to my decision. I have
determined the appeal on its own merits in any event.
15. I acknowledge that the appellant refers to supporting homeowners with
meeting additional family space needs, that there is no harm to neighbouring
living conditions; and that the property is in a location close to a good range of
services. I have carefully considered those points, but the harm to the CA
would be long lasting. As result I find they are not convincing reasons to set
aside harm to the CA and carry limited weight. The points do not outweigh the
harm to the CA I have identified in the main issue of the case.
Conclusion
16. For the reasons given above the appeal is dismissed.
M Shrigley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.