Construction of a second floor extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 27 November 2020
by Sian Griffiths BSc(Hons) DipTP MScRealEst MRTPI MRICS
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 18 December 2020.
Appeal Ref: APP/A5840/D/20/3259213
294 Commercial Way, London SE15 1QN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Ms Anum Shahab against the decision of the council of the
London Borough of Southwark.
• The application Ref 20/AP/1106, dated 16 April 2020, was refused by notice dated 26
June 2020.
• The development proposed is construction of a second floor extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. During the determination of the application, the council modified the
description of development to ensure that only the development requiring
planning permission was included. I have used this description of development
as a result.
3. The appellants and council both make reference to an appeal for a similar
development on another property within the same street (Ref
APP/A5840/D/17/3177100), I have therefore taken this into consideration in
my reasoning.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are
• the effect on the character and appearance of the host dwelling, and
• the effect on the setting of neighbouring listed buildings and that of the
Caroline Gardens Conservation Area.
Reasons
The effect on character and appearance
5. Commercial Way is a residential street with a mixed character of terraced
Georgian houses, detached dwellings, and modern apartment buildings. The
appeal site at No.294 is a largely detached, two storey house with a front
garden and generous rear garden.
6. The principal elevation is plain and similar to the historic terraces within the
street. It has a distinctive parapet wall covering the roof to the front which
Appeal Decision APP/A5840/D/20/3259213
2
echoes the line which begins in a nearby terrace and is, in my opinion, of
historic and visual significance.
7. Saved Policy 3.12 (Quality in Design) of the Southwark Local Plan (2004) (LP)
seeks development that is of a high quality both architecturally and in urban
design terms and saved Policy 3.13 (Urban Design) of the LP states that in
designing new developments, consideration must be given to key factors such
as local context and character.
8. Strategic Policy 12 'Design and Conservation' of the Core Strategy (2011) (CS)
seeks development that preserves or enhances Southwark’s historic
environment.
9. To the rear are multiple projecting elements of the dwelling, one butterfly roof
(two mono pitch projections that meet in the middle of the rear elevation),
together with a further mono pitch projection and ground floor flat roof which is
part of a contemporary extension.
10. The proposed second floor roof extension would result in a new bedroom and
‘green roof terrace’, which would sit behind the existing parapet wall to the
front of the dwelling. It would be visible from the front elevation, albeit this
would be limited.
11. At the rear, the extension would consist of a flat roofed box structure with
metal coping and timber cladding, with timber-framed windows. This would sit
above the butterfly roof. The further mono pitch projection at first floor level
and single storey ground floor extension would remain.
12. At the site visit, it appeared that the rear of the dwelling had largely retained
its original character. Whilst I am aware that such roof extensions and roof
terraces can be successfully integrated into historic buildings and their
surroundings, I consider the proposed changes to the rear elevation would
appear excessively dominant and would detract from the character of the host
dwelling. The addition to the front elevation would be less bulky and as a
result less harmful. Overall, however, I consider the proposed development
would offend saved policies 3.12 and 3.13 of the LP and Strategic Policy 12 of
the CS.
The effect on heritage assets
13. In turning to the effect on neighbouring designated heritage assets, the
neighbouring boundary for the Caroline Gardens Conservation Area (CA) runs
along the boundary to the rear garden of No.294. I note from the council’s
submissions that the appeal site is also within the setting of ‘a number of
Grade II listed buildings to the south’, although it is not clear from the council’s
submissions where these are located.
14. Paragraphs 193 and 194 of the National Planning Policy Framework
(Framework) require that any harm to the significance of a heritage asset
(through development of the asset itself or its harm resulting from
development within its setting) requires that great weight should be given to
its conservation, as well as a convincing justification for such development.
Further, at paragraph 196, development that leads to less than substantial
harm to the significance of a designated heritage asset, should be weighed
against the public benefits of the proposal.
Appeal Decision APP/A5840/D/20/3259213
3
15. The statutory duty in Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and
Conservation Areas) Act 1990 is a matter of considerable importance and
weight. Further, paragraph 196 of the Framework, states that where there is
less than substantial harm to the significance of a designated heritage asset,
this harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposals.
16. Saved Policy 3.18 (Setting of Listed Buildings, Conservation Areas and World
Heritage Sites Setting of Listed Buildings, Conservation Areas and World
Heritage Sites) of the LP states that permission will not be granted for
developments that would not preserve or enhance the immediate or wider
setting of a listed building; important views of a listed building; the setting of a
Conservation Area; Views into or out of a Conservation Area or important views
of or from a World Heritage Site.
17. The CA envelopes the Licensed Victuallers’ Almshouses (c.1827) and, according
to the Caroline Gardens Conservation Area Appraisal (undated), was one of the
first local examples of planned development. The terraced rows of dwellings
within the CA are attractive, uniform and distinctive and they frame areas of
green space between. The significance of the CA is clearly complemented by
the neighbouring Georgian dwellings, including that of the appeal site. I
therefore consider the appeal site makes a positive contribution to the setting
of the CA and the proposals would therefore undermine this by changing the
rear elevation (which addresses the CA) to the degree that it would introduce a
significant and incongruous extension that would be visible, albeit on a limited
basis. I therefore find there would be harm to the setting of the CA, contrary
to Saved Policy 3.18 of the LP and the relevant parts of the Framework.
Conclusions
18. For the reasons given, and having regard to all other material considerations,
the appeal is dismissed.
Sian Griffiths
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.