Householder application for proposed erection of a first- floor side extension with a Juliet balcony at rear elevation, single storey rear extension including insertion of 3 no. roof lights, plus insertion of 3 no. roof lights at rear elevation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 24 November 2020
by Eleni Randle BSc (hons) MSc FRICS FAAV MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 07 December 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/X0360/D/20/3257749
1 Waring Close, Earley, RG6 4JE
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs R & S Griffiths against the decision of Wokingham
Borough Council.
• The application Ref 201375 dated 8 June 2020, was refused by notice dated 29 July
2020.
• The development proposed is householder application for proposed erection of a first-
floor side extension with a Juliet balcony at rear elevation, single storey rear extension
including insertion of 3 no. roof lights, plus insertion of 3 no. roof lights at rear
elevation.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. I have utilised the Council’s description of the development as per the decision
notice as I feel it more concisely describes the development.
Main Issues
3. The main issue is the impact of the proposal upon the residential amenities of
no. 36 Ledran Close with particular regard for overlooking.
Reasons
4. There are several elements to the appeal proposal. The Council’s reason for
refusal is limited to the first-floor side extension with particular regard to the
Juliet balcony at the rear elevation. I find no reason to conclude differently to
the Council in relation to the other elements of the overall proposal. For this
reason, this appeal will focus solely upon the first-floor master bedroom
window as raised within the refusal.
5. The appeal site is a two-storey detached dwelling which stands in a cul-de-sac.
To the North is no. 36 Ledran Close (no. 36). The appeal site is forward of,
and is orientated at an angle with, no. 36 within an ad-hoc pattern of
development. The host dwelling stands in an irregular shaped, large, plot in
very close proximity to the Northern boundary along which there is an existing
laurel hedge. As it currently stands the element of the host property which is
closest to the Northern site boundary (and therefore no. 36) is a single storey
garage/kitchen which stands around 2 metres forward of the rest of the
existing original rear elevation. The existing fenestration in this single storey
Appeal Decision APP/X0360/D/20/3257749
2
element, a window and a door, are at ground floor level and thus lower than
the existing boundary fencing and hedge.
6. The proposed first-floor side extension would see the creation of
accommodation at first-floor level to create bedrooms. The proposed first-floor
master bedroom window (Juliet balcony) would be in very close proximity to
the shared boundary with no. 36. The proposed window would be much larger
than the existing first floor windows in the property which are set further away
from the boundary with the closest being within what is currently bedroom 3.
In addition to this the Juliet balcony would be 1.99 metres (according to plan
ref: FLU.1176.04 Rev C) further forward, towards no. 36, than the existing
windows in the rear elevation.
7. In summary the proposal would create a large window, at first-floor level,
much closer to the boundary with no. 36. I do not find this maintains a similar
separation distance to what is currently the case with the existing rear
elevation.
8. As part of my site visits I viewed the appeal site from no. 36’s garden. I note
that there is an established hedge along the boundary and that this does
provide some screening but there were still glimpsed views through the
vegetation between the properties. Despite some screening the first-floor
proposal with a large window, in such closer proximity to the boundary, would
still be notable for occupiers of no. 36.
9. I accept that overlooking may be limited to an extent by the existing hedge,
however, the proximity of the proposal discussed above I find leads to a
perceived sense of overlooking and loss of privacy for no. 36 which would be
detrimental to their residential amenity. It is acknowledged that the appeal
site and no. 36 are already within the 22 metres required by the Design SPD1
for back to back distances for overlooking. Despite this, as discussed above, I
find the proposals will bring a substantially larger window much closer to the
boundary at first-floor level than is currently the case with the existing dwelling
at the appeal site.
10. The separation distance from the proposal to the rear of no. 36 would be
around 9.3 metres which gives a sense of how close the proposal appears in
relation to the dwelling at no. 36 itself, and the garden. Taking into account
the individual characteristics of the property, and the site itself, I find that the
proposal would exacerbate the existing residential amenity inter-relationship
between the host dwelling and the neighbours.
11. I have considered the potential for the use of a condition relating to the
maintenance of the hedge along the boundary. The condition drafted does
require retaining the hedge at 4.6 metres, however, in the event of the hedge
dying, or reaching the end of its lifespan, I find it difficult to see how
replacement could be sourced at a similar size in such a manner that does not
see no. 36 affected negatively whilst it is replaced/grows back.
12. Similarly whilst height can be easily quantified/measured the mitigation that
the hedge is required to provide is reliant on sufficient thickness and quality of
the hedge to prevent views through between the properties. I do not find this
can be sufficiently defined, and controlled, within a condition to protect the
1 Wokingham Borough Council Borough Design Guide Supplementary Planning Document 2012
Appeal Decision APP/X0360/D/20/3257749
3
amenity of no. 36 as a result of the additional window as outlined above.
Overall, I do not find that a condition can overcome the issues which I have
found to make the development acceptable on this occasion.
13. The proposal would be contrary to CS2 Policy CP1 which requires proposals to
maintain the high quality of the environment and CS Policy CP3 which requires
proposals to be without detriment to the adjoining land users and their quality
of life.
14. I note the Council include LP3 Policy CC03 within their refusal reason, however,
based on the evidence before me I do not find the proposal would be in conflict
with this policy’s objectives which relate to Green Infrastructure, Trees and
Landscaping. In the case of this appeal I place very limited weight upon the
Design SPD in relation to back to back distances as the existing properties are
already below this and the guidance is not directly applicable to the site context
given the existing development pattern and orientation.
Other Matters
15. No. 36 Ledran Close raised an objection to the proposal but given the main
issue, I have dealt with the matters raised already within this decision letter.
The Town Council are also noted to have objected about the size of the
proposal and impact upon neighbouring properties. I have dealt with the
latter; however, the Council found no reason to refuse the proposal based on
size, character or similar. I have no evidence before me to conclude differently
on those particular matters.
Conclusion
16. For the reasons outlined above, and taking account all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Eleni Randle
INSPECTOR
2 Wokingham Borough Local Development Framework, Adopted Core Strategy Development Plan Document 2010
3 Wokingham Borough Development Plan Adopted Managing Development Delivery Local Plan 2014
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.