Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework, 2019 (the Framework) and any relevant development plan policies;
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Policy Weight
Rural Impact
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site Visit made on 13 October 2020
by K A Taylor MSC URP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 12 November 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/R0660/D/20/3257621
Brown Owl Cottage, Golborne Lane, High Legh, Knutsford, WA16 0RD
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Drs Taylor against the decision of Cheshire East Council.
The application Ref 20/1987M, dated 12 May 2020, was refused by notice dated
9 July 2020.
The development proposed is the construction of a first-floor side/rear and two-
storey side extension with glazed link (amendment to 19/5403M).
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
• Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green
Belt having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework, 2019 (the
Framework) and any relevant development plan policies;
• The effect of the proposal on the openness of the Green Belt; and
• Would the harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, be
clearly outweighed by other considerations so as to amount to the very
special circumstances required to justify the proposal.
Reasons
Inappropriate Development in the Green Belt
3. The Framework sets out the Government’s planning policies for England and is
an important material consideration in all planning decisions. Paragraph 145 of
the Framework sets out that the construction of new buildings in the Green Belt
should be regarded as inappropriate development, unless it meets one or more
of a list of exceptions. This includes that the extension or alteration of a
building does not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of
the original building. Paragraph 143 states that inappropriate development is,
by definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in
very special circumstances.
4. Policy PG3 of the Cheshire East Local Plan, Local Plan Strategy 2010-2030,
2017 (CELP), deals with the Green Belt, its designation, which aims to keep
land permanently open or largely developed and planning permission will not
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/20/3257621
2
be granted for inappropriate development except in very special circumstances.
It is therefore consistent with the approach and aims of the Framework.
5. Saved Policy GC12 of the Macclesfield Borough Local Plan, 2004 (Saved 2007),
(MBLP) sets out the Council’s approach to alterations and extensions to existing
houses in the countryside, including the Green Belt and that proposals may be
granted for up to 30% of the original floor space. The policy has exceptions
which includes criterion (3) - the extension is to provide a conservatory or
domestic building in the curtilage and the proposal would not adversely affect
the character and appearance of the countryside.
6. The appeal site is a detached property and is located within an area of
countryside designated being within the Green Belt. The proposed development
would involve the demolition of an existing link extension connecting the
garage to create a first-floor side/rear and two-storey extension, incorporating
a new linked glazed passageway to the existing garage. The proposals and
minor external/internal alterations would increase the rooms both at ground
floor and first floor considerably to the dwelling.
7. The Framework does not define the term ‘disproportionate’ and whilst I
acknowledge that the scheme has been amended from an extant planning
approval1, the footprint and bulk of the property would still be significantly
increased by the proposed extensions, due to the glazed passageway linking
both the original, extensions and existing garage together. Therefore, it does
not appear to be comparable; whereas the extant permission provided a
physical detachment between the garage/outbuilding from the dwellinghouse,
reducing its overall bulk and existing net floor space, the proposals do not.
8. Furthermore, the Council advise, in total the proposed extensions including
historic additions would be an increase of floor space some 89% above the
original dwelling. This is not disputed by the appellant, and as such there is no
reason to disagree. Therefore, in that regard, the proposals would not be of a
limited scale or a proportionate addition when comparing to the original
building and would be at odds with the 30% set out in Policy GC12.
9. The appellant argues that the proposals would satisfy criterion (3) of Policy
GC12, with the glazed link being a conservatory. I am not persuaded by this
argument, the plans and evidence indicate that this would be a passageway, a
gap consisting of a fully glazed structure linking the existing house and
extensions with the garage. The functionality would be as a passageway, used
for that purpose of linking the entities of the property together with the
outbuilding/garage, unlike that of the functionality and typical use of a
conservatory. Therefore, the proposal would not meet the exception criteria at
(3).
10. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the proposed development would
be inappropriate development in the Green Belt as a result of a
disproportionate addition over and above the size of the original building. It
would be contrary to Saved Policy GC12 of the MBLP and Policy PG3 of the
CELP as identified above, and the Framework.
1 19/5403M, dated 17 January 2020
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/20/3257621
3
Openness
11. As set out in paragraph 133 of the Framework, the fundamental aim of Green
Belt policy is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open.
The essential characteristics thereof being their openness and permanence.
The physical presence of built forms may affect openness, which can also have
a visual element. In that, the bulk of the building would be increased by
additional built development, the glazed link would reduce the open space
between the property and outbuildings. The proposals would be visible from
along Golbourne lane and would reduce openness noticeably. In view of the
above points, I conclude that the proposed development would have an
appreciable impact on the openness of the Green Belt.
Other Considerations
12. The appellants evidence relies heavily on the comparisons between the
proposed development and the extant permission. They contend, that by virtue
of the granted planning permission, a ‘fallback’ position exists whereby if the
appeal scheme does not progress the alternative scheme, for extensions to the
dwelling, could be developed, equating to very special circumstances to justify
the proposed development within the Green Belt.
13. Therefore, I consider there is a genuine ‘fallback’ scheme, and there is a
greater than a theoretical possibility that the development might take place.
However, from the evidence before me, the ‘fallback’ would be less harmful
than the appeal scheme. I accept that the ‘fallback’ scheme, is identical in part
but the design of what is proposed has now changed with the inclusion of a
glazed passageway linking the dwelling to the garage. Resulting in the overall
bulk, mass and floor space being increased, having a greater adverse effect on
the Green Belt. As such, the ‘fallback’ consideration does not justify the harm I
have found the proposed development would have, and I attach little weight to
the fallback position.
14. Although the proposed development would not cause any harm to the living
conditions of neighbouring properties, character and appearance of the host
dwelling and highway safety, the absence of harm in these respects weighs
neutrally and does not amount to a consideration in support of the appeal.
15. I understand other developments have been granted planning permission by
the Council in the area, ‘Newton’. I have been provided with limited details,
although there may be some similarities. However, it does appear from the
evidence that the glazed link referred to was part of an existing conservatory
extension, unlike the proposals before me for a new glazed link passageway to
fill a gap. In any event, the appeal is necessarily determined on its individual
merits on the basis of the evidence before me.
Conclusion
16. The appeal scheme is inappropriate development in the Green Belt. This is
harmful by definition. The proposal would lead to an appreciable loss of
openness to the Green Belt which gives rise to additional harm. In each case,
these harms render the appeal scheme contrary to the aims of both the policies
of the development plan, as I have identified them, and the relevant sections of
the Framework.
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/20/3257621
4
17. Against this, the other considerations that have been advanced are not
sufficient, either individually or cumulatively, to clearly outweigh the harm to
the Green Belt. Consequently, the very special circumstances necessary to
justify the development do not exist.
18. The proposed development would be contrary to the development plan and the
Framework, taken as a whole. There are no other material considerations that
would indicate that the proposed development should be determined other than
in accordance with the development plan. For the reasons set out above, and
having regard to all other matters raised, I conclude that the appeal should be
dismissed.
K A Taylor
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.