Single storey extension to existing dwelling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 29 September 2020
by Mr W Johnson BA(Hons) DipTP DipUDR MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 27 October 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/K0235/D/20/3256940
Courtyard Barn, The Drive, Church Lane, Oakley, Bedford MK43 7ST
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr George Powell against the decision of Bedford Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 19/02677/FUL, dated 2 December 2019, was refused by notice
dated 19 May 2020.
• The development proposed is described as: ‘Single storey extension to existing
dwelling’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. For clarity and precision, I have inserted ‘Bedford’ to the address in the banner
heading above as it is listed on the appeal form.
3. Whilst not cited on the Council’s decision notice, the appellant has cited the
Oakley Neighbourhood Plan 2020 (ONP) in his submission, quoting ONP Policies
DH1 and DH2. Both parties have had the opportunity to provide comments in
respect of this matter and I have taken the responses received into account in
the determination of this appeal.
4. There has been reference to a previous appeal decision1 in relation to the Costs
application. Therefore, I have had regard to this previous decision in the
determination of this appeal and will not prejudice any party in taking this
approach. However, as it was issued prior to the first version of the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) 2012, I find it to have little
implication surrounding a non-designated heritage asset. I have dealt with the
appeal on this basis.
Application for Costs
5. An application for costs was made by Mr George Powell against Bedford
Borough Council. This application is the subject of a separate Decision.
Main Issues
6. The main issues of this appeal are:
i. whether the proposal would affect the character, appearance and
significance of a non-designated heritage asset; and,
1 APP/W0205/A/08/2070965
Appeal Decision APP/K0235/D/20/3256940
2
ii. the effect on the setting of ‘The Mallows’ (TM), which is Grade II listed.
Reasons
7. The appeal property is a modest dwelling dating back to the 19th Century,
accessed via a shared driveway from ‘The Drive’, which is a private road. It is
located in the open countryside, but close to the village of Oakley. Adjacent to
the dwelling is a parking area for a number of cars, a detached garage and a
series of stables formerly of ‘Oakley House’2 (OH). Directly to the west of the
site is TM3, which is a 18th Century listed cottage and once formed part of
former OH stables. The listing confirms that it was included for group value. It
is common ground between the main parties that the host dwelling is not
individually listed or curtilage listed. On the evidence before me, I have little
reason to disagree with the main parties on these issues. Although, I do note
that part of the western flank wall to the host dwelling forms part of the
historic shared boundary wall with TM.
8. The host dwelling is mostly constructed from brick with a Flemish bond,
corbelled brick eaves and a slate roof with 2no. roof lights on the front
elevation and 1no. roof light on the rear elevation. The host dwelling has a
single forward facing aspect with no other windows or openings on any of its
other elevations, apart from the roof light on the rear roof slope. The front
elevation of the host dwelling comprises timber boarding with a window and a
door sited close to the western boundary wall that partially forms the side
elevation of the host dwelling. The remainder of the front elevation comprises a
series of full-length glazing panels/door.
9. The Council has identified the host dwelling as a non-designated heritage asset
and its significance, through its historical association to TM and OH. In support
of this the Council has provided the consultation responses from its
Conservation and Historic Buildings Officer4. The National Planning Policy
Framework5 (the Framework) requires that local planning authorities should
identify and assess the particular significance of any heritage asset that may be
affected by a proposal (including by development affecting the setting of a
heritage asset) taking account of the available evidence and any necessary
expertise.
10. Furthermore, although the Framework and Planning Practice Guidance (PPG)
advises that it is important that all non-designated heritage assets are clearly
identified as such, the PPG also advises that the local planning authorities may
also identify non-designated heritage assets as part of the decision-making
process on planning applications6. In light of the above reasons and
irrespective of the host dwelling not being identified on a Council Local List7, in
accordance with the Framework and the PPG, for the reasons that follow, I find
the host dwelling has a degree of significance meriting consideration in this
decision.
11. The Framework8 says that the effect of an application on the significance of a
non-designated heritage asset should be taken into account in determining the
2 Grade II* Listed on 7 May 1952
3 Grade Ii Listed on 7 May 1952
4 Memo dated 27 January 2020 and 30 March 2020
5 Paragraph 190
6 Paragraph: 040 Reference ID: 18a-040-20190723
7 Appendix 6 - Historic Environment Record
8 Paragraph 197
Appeal Decision APP/K0235/D/20/3256940
3
application. In weighing applications that directly or indirectly affect
non-designated heritage assets, a balanced judgement will be required having
regard to the scale of any harm or loss and the significance of the heritage
asset. The host dwelling is directly adjacent to TM and within the original
grounds of OH, with a very simple form. I also find the host dwelling to have
similar characteristics to the other outbuildings in proximity to the site, thus
retaining the historic interest and relevance to its wider surroundings. I
consider that the significance of the host dwelling derives from the character
and appearance of the building and its historic association with TM and OH.
12. The proposed extension would create a dwelling with a combined floor space of
160m2. However, when compared to the host dwelling the proposed
development would be notable. I do not consider the principle of a
contemporary extension to the host dwelling to necessarily be harmful,
although I do have concerns surrounding the proposed development in this
instance, particularly surrounding the amount of development proposed. I find
that the proposed development would significantly reduce the important sense
of space around the host dwelling and despite the linked design, it would
dominate its original shape and form. The resultant appearance of the
proposed development would be unsympathetic and distinctly at odds with the
host dwelling, thus forming an incongruous feature.
13. Whilst acknowledging the proposed development would include features, such
as following the line of the eastern boundary of the site, a lower roof height
when compared against the host dwelling, construction materials comprising
patinated zinc roof with structural steel facias painted slate grey, dark stained
vertical timber boarding on its elevations and a notable amount of glazing.
Whilst the proposed development would be Biophilic in its design, I am not
convinced that the structure would not represent a strident feature with
proportions out of keeping with the prevailing character of the host dwelling.
14. I accept that views of the site from areas within the public realm are limited,
the visual misgivings of a detached double garage adjacent to the site access
and the overall plot size of the site. However, I find these matters are of little
consequence to provide sufficient mitigation against the adverse effect of the
proposed development identified in this instance. Additionally, whilst not
physically attached, I still find that the proposed development falls within the
setting of TM due to its proximity from within the site.
15. I have a statutory duty under Section 66 (1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings
and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 (the Act) which requires me to have special
regard to the desirability of preserving or enhancing a listed building or its
setting or any features of special architectural or historic interest which it
possesses. I consider the proposal fails to accord with this duty. Additionally,
the proposed development would not conserve the heritage assets in a manner
appropriate to their significance in line with the Framework. I find that the
proposed development would result in “less than substantial” harm to the
setting of TM for the purposes of the Framework9. The proposed development
would result in some limited economic and social benefits. However, as public
benefits, these would not outweigh the less than substantial harm to the
setting of TM.
9 Paragraph 196
Appeal Decision APP/K0235/D/20/3256940
4
16. For the reasons given above, I therefore conclude that the proposed
development would have a harmful effect on the character, appearance and
significance of a non-designated heritage asset and the setting of TM.
Consequently, the proposed development would fail to accord with the
heritage, design, character and appearance aims of Policies 28S, 29, 30, 41S
and 66 of the Council’s Allocations and Designations Local Plan 2013, ONP
Policies DH1 and DH2 and guidance contained within E1, E2 and E3 of the
Council’s Residential Extensions, New Dwellings and Small Infill Developments
2000. Additionally, the proposed development would not conserve the heritage
assets in a manner appropriate to their significance in line with the Framework.
17. Section 16 of the Act has been cited on the Council’s decision notice. However,
this section of the Act relates to listed building consent and therefore I find it is
not directly applicable to the case before me.
Other Matters
18. I have also had regard to various other matters raised by the appellant,
including his need to develop the host dwelling due to its existing size, the
removal of permitted development rights on the property, his desire to work
from home and the proposed eco credentials resulting in a low carbon
footprint, but on the evidence before me these are not reasons to grant
permission in the face of the harm identified.
19. I have also had regard to concerns raised by the appellant about the way that
the Council handled the application, but this does not affect the planning merits
of the case. I have considered this appeal proposal on its own merits and
concluded that it would cause harm for the reasons set out above.
Planning Balance and Conclusion
20. Whilst I accept the absence of other harm arising from the proposed
development and the social and economic benefits that would occur from the
appellant homeworking and the construction phase of the development,
amongst other things, these factors, for the reasons described, do not
outweigh my assessment of the main issues.
21. Given my findings above, the proposed development would conflict with part of
the environmental objective set out in paragraph 8 of the Framework. Thus,
the proposal does not constitute sustainable development.
22. Taking all matters into consideration, I conclude that the appeal should be
dismissed.
W Johnson
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 29 September 2020
by Mr W Johnson BA(Hons) DipTP DipUDR MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 27 October 2020
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/K0235/D/20/3256940
Courtyard Barn, The Drive, Church Lane, Oakley, Bedford MK43 7ST
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Mr George Powell for a partial award of costs against
Bedford Borough Council.
• The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for a single storey extension
to existing dwelling.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is refused.
Procedural Matter
2. For clarity and precision, I have inserted ‘Bedford’ to the address in the banner
heading above as it is listed on the appeal form.
Reasons
3. Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) advises that, irrespective of the outcome of
the appeal, costs may only be awarded against a party who has behaved
unreasonably and thereby caused the party applying for costs to incur
unnecessary expense in the appeal process. Patently this is a two-stage test.
The PPG also makes it clear that costs cannot be claimed for the period during
the determination of the planning application although all parties are expected
to behave reasonably throughout the planning process.
4. Although costs can only be awarded in relation to unnecessary or wasted
expense at the appeal or other proceeding, behaviour and actions at the time
of the planning application can be taken into account in determining whether or
not costs should be awarded. An award of costs may either be procedural,
relating to the appeal process, or substantive, relating to the planning merits of
the appeal. Paragraph 049 of the PPG cites various examples of unreasonable
behaviour by local planning authorities. The applicant’s application for costs is
based on the alleged unreasonable behaviour of the Council and wasted
expense, for substantive reasons, as considered below.
5. There are a number of elements that the applicant brings to their claim on
substantive grounds, in particular a failure to produce evidence to substantiate
the reason for refusal on appeal and vague, generalised or inaccurate
assertions about a proposal’s impact which are unsupported by any objective
analysis. Additionally, the applicant asserts that the provision of information
shown by the Council to be manifestly inaccurate or untrue.
6. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) requires that local
Costs Decision APP/K0235/D/20/3256940
2
planning authorities identify and assess the particular significance of any
heritage asset that may be affected by a proposal (including by development
affecting the setting of a heritage asset) taking account of the available
evidence and any necessary expertise. Furthermore, although the Framework
and PPG advise that it is important that all non-designated heritage assets are
clearly identified as such, the PPG1 also advises that the local planning
authorities may also identify non-designated heritage assets as part of the
decision-making process on planning applications.
7. In this case, having regard to the Council’s Delegated Report, it is clear that
the appeal property was identified as a non-designated heritage asset.
Furthermore, the Council’s first reason for refusal also clearly explains what the
Council considers to be the harm arising from the proposed development in
respect of the non-designated heritage asset and also refers to Policy 41S of
the Council’s Allocations and Designations Local Plan 2013, which specifically
relates to heritage assets. Whilst the applicant also argues that the appeal
property is not a non-designated heritage asset, I find this is a matter of
planning judgement for the decision maker. Also, the fact that a property is
identified as a non-designated heritage asset does not necessarily prevent its
development.
8. In light of the above reasons and irrespective of the appeal property not being
identified on a Local List, it is clear that the Council identified the appeal
property as a non-designated heritage asset. Additionally, it is clear that
consultation comments from the Council’s Conservation and Historic Buildings
Officer were taken into consideration in the assessment of the planning
application. Therefore, in accordance with the Framework and the PPG, the
appeal property has a degree of significance meriting consideration in the
planning application process. I also note that the Council have previously
identified the appeal property as a non-designated heritage asset in
determining another planning application2 at this site in 2015, which the
applicant acknowledges in his Revised Heritage Statement dated 16 February
2020. However, the references towards an appeal decision3 are less relevant,
due to it being issued before the first version of the Framework in 2012.
9. It will be seen from my decision that overall, I agree with the Council’s
observations and its refusal, and the decision was a matter of judgement based
on the evidence before the Council. From the evidence before me, and in the
absence of any additional information to the contrary, it follows that I am
satisfied that the Council adequately substantiated its reason for refusal. In this
case the appeal could not have been avoided.
10. Therefore, unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary or wasted expense
as described in the PPG has not been demonstrated. As such, an award of costs
is not justified.
W Johnson
INSPECTOR
1 Paragraph: 040 Reference ID: 18a-040-20190723
2 Paragraph 2.19 in Officer Report for 15/00445/FUL
3 APP/W0205/A/08/2070965
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.