Appeal Against Conditions
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Heritage & Conservation
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 23 September 2020
by Diane Cragg DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 04 November 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/N1025/D/20/3256045
The Old Post Office, Derby Road, Risley, Derbyshire DE72 3SS
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73 of the Town and
Country Planning Act 1990 for the development of land without complying with
conditions subject to which a previous planning permission was granted.
• The appeal is made by Mr Andrew Counsell against the decision of Erewash Borough
Council.
• The application Ref ERE/0320/0070, dated 23 March 2020, was refused by notice dated
17 June 2020.
• The application sought planning permission for a single storey extension without
complying with a condition attached to planning permission Ref ERE/0819/0010, dated
24 October 2019.
• The condition in dispute is No 6 which states that: Notwithstanding the provisions of
Class E, Parts 1 and 2 of Schedule 2, Article 3 of the Town and Country Planning
(General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 (as amended) (or any Order
revoking and re-enacting that Order) no incidental building, structure or enclosure shall
be erected without the prior grant of planning permission .
• The reason given for the condition is: to enable the local planning authority to retain
control over future extensions, alterations and the erection of outbuildings to protect
the openness of the Green Belt and the character of the Conservation Area.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for a single storey
extension at The Old Post Office, Derby Road, Risley, Derbyshire DE72 3SS in
accordance with the application ERE/0320/0070 dated 23th March 2020 without
complying with condition No 6 previously imposed on the planning permission
ref ERE/0819/0010 dated 24 October 2019 but otherwise subject to the
following conditions:
1. The development shall be begun before the expiration of three years from
the 24 October 2019.
2. The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans/details: Site location Plan; Block Plan
TC/1911/BP and Plans and elevations: TC/1911/2.
3. The development hereby approved shall be carried out using the materials
specified in the approved plans and details.
4. The method of foundation construction for the proposed extension shall be
undertaken in accordance with the agent’s email date 1 October 2019.
Appeal Decision APP/N1025/D/20/3256045
2
5. Prior to the extension hereby approved being brought into use the existing
outbuilding/garage shall be demolished in its entirety.
Application for costs
2. An application for costs was made by Mr Andrew Counsell against Erewash
Borough Council. This application is the subject of a separate Decision.
Background and Main Issue
3. The Old Post Office is a detached house in a semi-rural location within Risley
Conservation Area. The appeal site is accessed via an unmade road which
incorporates a public footpath and is adjacent to listed buildings. It is within the
Green Belt.
4. The planning permission granted for a single storey extension to the property
included condition 6 removing permitted development rights under Schedule 2,
Part 1, Class E of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted
Development) (England) Order 2015 ( the GPDO). The condition and the
reason for its imposition are as set out in the banner heading. The reason
refers to the protection of the openness of the Green Belt and the character of
the Conservation Area.
5. The Council does not refer specifically to the Conservation Area in its reason for
refusal. However, there are third-party comments in this respect. Further, the
duty under Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation
Areas) Act 1990 (the Act) requires that I pay special attention to the
desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of the area.
6. Therefore, having regard to the above and the submitted evidence, the main
issue is whether the removal of Class E permitted development rights is
reasonable and necessary to protect the openness of the Green Belt and the
character and appearance of the Risley Conservation Area.
Reasons
Green Belt
7. The Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) and the National Planning Policy
Framework (the Framework) advise that conditions restricting future permitted
development rights should only be used when there is a clear justification for
doing so. Although such conditions are not precluded, their scope needs to be
precisely defined. However, what may be ‘a clear justification’ is not explained
and therefore it is necessarily a matter of planning judgement.
8. Policy GB4 of the Erewash Borough Local Plan Saved Policies 2005 (amended
2014) (Local Plan) permits extensions and alterations to dwellings in the Green
Belt provided that the proposal does not result in disproportionate additions
over and above the size of the original dwelling. This is consistent with the
approach in Paragraph 145 of the Framework which regards the construction of
new buildings as inappropriate in the Green Belt, subject to a number of listed
exceptions including Paragraph 145 c) ‘the extension or alteration of a building
provided that it does not result in disproportionate additions over and above
the size of the original building’.
9. The Council considered that the approved single storey extension, when taken
cumulatively with previous extensions and with the removal of the existing
Appeal Decision APP/N1025/D/20/3256045
3
outbuilding, would result in a volume increase to the house of 49% over the
size of the original building. The Council concluded that as the extension would
be below a 50% volume increase, when taking into account the removal of the
outbuilding, the development would not be a disproportionate extension and
therefore ‘not inappropriate’ development within the Green Belt. Condition 5
secures the removal of the existing outbuilding. Development in compliance
with Policy GB4 of the Local Plan and paragraph 145 c) is not subject to the
consideration of the effect of the development on openness.
10. The construction of future buildings under Class E permitted development
would need to satisfy the criteria within the GPDO. Class E limits the total area
of ground around a house that can be covered by development permitted under
Class E to 50% of the total area of the curtilage, excluding the original house.
The calculation of the 50% limit covers all buildings, including any existing or
proposed new extensions to the original house under Class A of the GPDO or
that have been granted planning permission, as well as existing and proposed
outbuildings, whether part of the original building or not.
11. The GPDO does not treat the Green Belt as one of the defined areas where
permitted development rights should be limited. Accordingly, there is no basis
in national policy for an assumption that the exercise of the permitted
development rights under Class E would, in principle, be harmful to the Green
Belt.
12. Although the Council considers that it would be perverse to grant permission
that requires the demolition of an outbuilding to then allow further such
buildings to be constructed; the Council has not identified any specific harm to
openness. As neither development under Part 6 of the GPDO or development
that is ‘not inappropriate’ are individually subject to the consideration of the
effects on openness, and I have no evidence to suggest that harm to openness
would occur when taking the size of the approved extension cumulatively with
rights under Class E, no clear justification has been made for the removal of
permitted development rights on the basis of the impact on the openness of
the Green Belt.
13. Further, the Council concluded that the proposed extension would replace an
existing outbuilding which is both large and bland and although the new
extension would be more visible it would be set back in the plot and screened
by a proposed wall. Removing the existing building and replacing it with a
modern designed extension, the Council considered, would enhance the
Conservation Area. Following my site visit I see no reason to disagree with this
conclusion even when considering the duty under the Act.
14. There is no evidence that the approved extension in combination with
development that is permitted under Class E of the GPDO would detract from
the character or appearance of the Conservation Area. Thus, the location of the
development within the Conservation Area does not justify the removal of
Permitted Development rights under Class E of the GPDO.
15. Therefore, overall, I conclude that removal of Class E permitted development
rights is not reasonable and necessary to protect the openness of the Green
Belt or the character and appearance of the Risley Conservation Area. I find no
conflict with Policy GB4 of the Local Plan or the Framework.
Appeal Decision APP/N1025/D/20/3256045
4
Other Matters
16. I note that there are concerns that it is the appellant’s intention to construct
another dwelling within the curtilage of the property. I also note the Parish
Council’s concerns about the extent of the garden. However, these are not
matters for me to consider here.
Conditions
17. The PPG makes clear that decision notices for the grant of planning permission
under section 73 should also repeat the relevant conditions from the original
planning permission, unless they have already been discharged.
18. In accordance with Section 73(5) of the Act, I have amended the standard
commencement condition to ensure it does not have the effect of extending the
time within which a development must be started.
19. An approved plans condition is necessary in the interests of clarity and
certainty and to be certain that the agreed materials are used. The method of
the construction of the foundation is required to protect adjacent listed
buildings. A condition requiring the existing outbuilding to be removed is
required to ensure the development complies with the approach to the erection
of extensions in the Green Belt accords with the Framework and development
plan policies.
Conclusion
20. For the reasons given above I conclude that condition 6 should be removed and
the appeal should be allowed.
Diane Cragg
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.