First floor side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 16 September 2020
by Beverley Wilders BA (Hons) PgDurp MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 01 October 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/Q1825/D/20/3255214
21 Crumpfields Lane, Redditch B97 5PN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Phil Thomas against the decision of Redditch Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 19/01410/FUL, dated 25 Oct 2019, was refused by notice dated
8 May 2020.
• The development proposed is first floor side extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the
occupiers of the adjacent property having particular regard to outlook and light.
Reasons
3. The appeal site comprises a part two storey, part single storey detached
dwelling located within a ribbon of residential development. The dwelling
extends across almost the full width of the plot. The two storey part of the
host dwelling is set away from the common side boundary with the adjacent
property at 23 Crumpfields Lane with the nearest part of the dwelling to No 23
comprising the side gable of the single storey pitched roof element together
with the side wall of a small flat roofed utility room. At this point of the site,
the common side boundary between the two properties is marked by a solid
timber fence.
4. The side gable of No 23 is set away from the common side boundary and faces
towards the side elevation of the host dwelling. It contains a number of
windows including ground floor kitchen and dining room windows and two first
floor bedroom windows. All of these rooms with the exception of one of the
bedrooms also contains another window in the rear elevation, albeit in the case
of the kitchen, the rear facing window is smaller.
5. The proposal is to construct a first floor above the single storey pitched roof
element near to No 23. The eaves and ridge height of the extension would
match that of the two storey part of the host dwelling. The relative position of
the two properties means that the outlook from the side facing kitchen window
of No 23 is already severely restricted and this would be restricted yet further
Appeal Decision APP/Q1825/D/20/3255214
2
by the proposal. The additional bulk of the proposed extension would have an
overbearing effect on the outlook from the side facing kitchen window and this
reduced outlook would not be mitigated by the presence of a rear facing
window in the kitchen as this window is much smaller. To a lesser degree, the
extension would also result in a material loss of outlook to the first floor
bedroom positioned nearest to the front of No 23, given that the window
affected is the only window serving this bedroom. Although there would also
be some impact on the outlook from the ground floor dining room and other
first floor bedroom, this impact would not be materially harmful given the
position of these rooms relative to the proposed extension and having regard
to the fact that they have other large windows not affected by the proposal.
6. The scale, height and additional bulk of the extension positioned very close to
side facing windows at No 23 means that it would be likely to result in a
material loss of daylight to the ground floor kitchen window and some loss of
daylight to other side facing windows, albeit not to the extent that it would be
likely to be materially harmful. The appellant acknowledges that the existing
host dwelling breaches Building Research Establishment (BRE) guidance in
respect of daylight in terms of the 25 degree angle test when applied to the
kitchen window. Though under such circumstances the BRE guidance states
that calculating the vertical sky component (VSC) can provide a more detailed
assessment, no such assessment of the VSC has been carried out be appellant.
Whilst I note that it appears that the opportunity was not provided to submit
an assessment during the course of the application, one could have been
submitted with the appeal. In the absence of this and having regard to what I
saw at my visit including the presence of items on the kitchen windowsill, I
consider it likely that the proposal would result in an unacceptable loss of
daylight to the ground floor, side facing kitchen window.
7. The position of the host dwelling to the north of the side elevation of No 23
means that there would not be any significant overshadowing and this is shown
on the submitted shadow analysis drawings.
8. My attention has been drawn by the appellant to the fact that planning
permission was granted in December 2017 for a first floor side extension
similar to the proposal, but narrower, meaning that it would be further away
from No 23 (Ref 17/01234/FUL). Notwithstanding this, the proposed extension
would be larger and nearer to No 23 than the previously approved extension
and I consider that the additional impact on the outlook from and the light
received by No 23 would be materially harmful. Although I note the presence
of the boundary fence and landscaping, neither of these significantly affect
outlook from No 23 or mean that the loss of outlook resulting from the
extension would not be significant. What may or may not be done to the
layout of No 23 in the future is not a matter for me and whilst the existing
layout of No 23 could be considered to be unusual, I must nevertheless have
regard to it.
9. I have also been referred to a development approved by the Council at
17 Crumpfields Lane and its relationship with a neighbouring property (Ref
2015/0178/FUL). I have been provided with copies of documentation in
relation to the proposal. Although I have had regard to the documentation, it
is not clear what the exact relationship between the properties is and whether
any of the affected windows referred to are the sole or main windows to the
rooms in question. The photograph of the dining room at No 17 shows a large
Appeal Decision APP/Q1825/D/20/3255214
3
patio door/window and what appears to be another window on the other side of
the room. The proposals and sites do not therefore appear to be directly
comparable and in any event, I must determine the proposal before me on its
own merits.
10. The Council did not raise any concerns in respect of the effect of the proposal
on any other nearby properties and I see no reason to disagree with its findings
on this issue having regard to the scale and position of the extension.
11. Taking the above matters into consideration, I conclude that the proposal
would have a significant adverse effect on the living conditions of the occupiers
of 23 Crumpfields Lane having particular regard to outlook and daylight. It is
therefore contrary to policies 39 and 40 of the Borough of Redditch Local Plan
No.4 adopted January 2017 and to relevant guidance contained within the
Borough of Redditch High Quality Design SPD adopted June 2019. These
policies and this guidance seek, amongst other things, to ensure that
development is well designed and that it incorporates relevant guidance within
SPDs including that consideration is given to the impact on neighbouring
properties and protection of neighbouring amenity.
Other Matters
12. In reaching my decision I note and have had regard to the fact that the
appellant has a growing family and that he is seeking to provide what he
considers to be much needed and affordable family accommodation. The
appellant does not consider that the previously approved extension meets his
needs. However, whilst I am sympathetic to his needs, there is no evidence to
suggest that the proposal is the only solution available and that the required
accommodation could not be provided in a way less harmful to the living
conditions of nearby occupiers. Finally, I note that the extension would be
constructed from matching materials and that the Council raises no objections
to its design which would result in a more symmetrical appearance to the host
dwelling. However, any benefits of the proposal would not outweigh the harm
to living conditions that I have identified.
Conclusion
13. For the above reasons and having regard to all matters raised, I conclude that
the appeal should be dismissed.
Beverley Wilders
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.