Extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Trees & Landscape
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 13 October 2020
by Elaine Benson BA (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
An Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 23/12/2020
Appeal Ref: APP/A1910/D/20/3254895
6 Long Chaulden, Hemel Hempstead, HP1 2HT
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Ayat Noorbakhsh against the decision of Dacorum Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 20/00332/FHA, dated 18 March 2020, was refused by notice dated
11 May 2020.
• The development proposed is an extension.
Preliminary Matter
1. In its decision notice the Council described the proposed development as ‘two
storey side extension and single storey rear extension’. However, the appeal
property (No 6) is an end of a terrace house which stands at the corner of Long
Chaulden and Chaulden Terrace. Unlike its neighbours, No 6’s front door opens
onto Long Chaulden. It would be more appropriate to describe the development
as ‘part two storey part single storey side extension’ as the appellant has done
in the appeal submissions. It is clear from the Council’s officer report that the
application was considered on this basis. I shall do the same.
Decision
2. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
3. The effect of the proposed extension on the character and appearance of the
surrounding area in respect of its impact, if any, on neighbouring street trees.
Reasons
4. It is proposed to erect a single storey side extension which would project
forward of the end elevation facing Long Chaulden. A first-floor element would
be erected over the central part of the extension. The planning application was
amended a number of times. Based upon the final drawings, the Council raised
no objections to the design of the extension and found no adverse impact on
neighbouring properties. There are no reasons to disagree and this appeal
decision therefore focusses on the main issue identified above, using the same
drawings as the Council.
5. The grass verge alongside No 6 contains 4 mature, Council-owned street trees.
The trees are highly visible and can be seen for some distance along the road
which rises towards the west. They are very important to the character and
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/20/3254895
2
appearance of the locality. The trees are not protected by a tree preservation
order. However, this does not diminish their importance. As they are under
public ownership, the trees are in any event protected.
6. To address any potential impact on the trees during the construction of the
extension, an Arboricultural Impact Assessment (AIA) was submitted. Its Tree
Survey Schedule states that the Category of Retention for tree T1 (Apple) is C2
and for the 3 Fastigiate Hornbeams is B3. Tree T1 is suppressed by the closely
neighbouring T2 and its crown is asymmetrical. Nonetheless, the physiological
and structural condition of all of the trees is described as good, being in healthy
condition with no significant problems. These conclusions have not been
disputed by the Council and there are no reasons to disagree.
7. The AIA indicates that the footings of the extension would encroach into the
root protection areas (RPAs) of the 2 trees nearest the building, T1 and T2.
However, the AIA assumes that there are no roots beneath an intervening brick
outbuilding, the upper parts of which had been demolished at the time of my
site visit. On this basis the AIA states that there would be an encroachment of
less than 4% into the RPA of T1 and 3% into the RPA of T2, indicating that the
overall degree of root pruning would cause very little harm, if any, to these
trees. Any encroachment into the more distant RPAs of trees T3 and T4, could
be mitigated by tree protection fencing. Pruning of the northern side of trees
T1 and T2 would also be required during construction.
8. No physical investigations have been carried out to identify the extent of the
tree roots and the presence or depth of any outbuilding foundations. In the
absence of this definitive evidence I am unable to conclude with any certainty
the extent of and impact that root pruning would have on the trees. These
details would enable it to be determined whether specific foundation
construction techniques could be used to protect the roots of the affected trees.
9. I have considered whether such details could be required by condition.
However, there is a risk of an unimplementable planning permission which
would clearly be unreasonable. Furthermore, the additional work in
investigating these matters would be at a cost, as could carrying out any
necessary works during the construction of the extension. Under these
circumstances it would be unreasonable to require further details by condition.
10. Following the construction of the extension, the AIA indicates that repeated
pruning of the northern side of trees T1 and T2 would be required to maintain
clearance over the extension, supporting the Council’s concerns about
increased future pressure for pruning. At the time of my site visit the trees had
recently been pruned, at the appellant’s request, and were at their smallest.
Their future growth should be taken into account.
11. The proposed extension would bring the property closer to the trees. In my
experience the number and position of new windows that would be under the
influence of the trees would in themselves lead to future pressure for pruning
or removing the trees. Such works could adversely affect their appearance and
longevity, thereby harming local character. Whilst a revised window
arrangement might address these concerns to some degree, such changes
could not be required by condition as the use of the rooms would be
fundamentally affected.
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/20/3254895
3
12. For the reasons set out I conclude that the proposal conflicts with the aims of
saved Policy 99 of the Dacorum Local Plan and Policies CS11 and CS12 of the
Core Strategy. The policies require consideration of any intentions for the
future management of trees. In summary and of relevance to this appeal they
seek to retain important trees, or replace them if their loss is justified, to
protect quality streetscapes. There would also be conflict with the general aims
of the National Planning Policy Framework to support and improve
neighbourhood character and quality.
13. I have considered all other matters raised. There is no evidence that the
‘Appeal Precedents’ referred to by the appellant have any bearing on the
proposal before me which has been determined on its own individual and
specific considerations.
14. In conclusion, based on the evidence available, the proposed extension would
have an unacceptable impact on the health and longevity of the adjacent street
trees. The loss of or damage to these trees would severely harm the character
and appearance of the surrounding area. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed.
Elaine Benson
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.