Two storey extension including new roof and internal re- modelling and three-storey side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Trees & Landscape
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 23 July 2020
by S J Papworth DipArch(Glos) RIBA
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 7 August 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/U1430/D/20/3254638
The Sutton Point, The Suttons, Camber, Rye TN31 7RS
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Colin Smith against the decision of Rother District Council.
• The application Ref RR/2019/1390/P, dated 5 June 2019, was refused by the Council by
notice dated 9 April 2020.
• The development proposed is two storey extension including new roof and internal re-
modelling and three-storey side extension.
Decision
1. I allow the appeal and grant planning permission for two storey extension
including new roof and internal re-modelling and three-storey side extension at
The Sutton Point, The Suttons, Camber, Rye TN31 7RS in accordance with the
terms of the application Reference RR/2019/1390/P, dated 5 June 2019, and
subject to conditions 1) to 6) of the attached schedule.
Main Issues
2. These are;
• The effect of the proposals on the character and appearance of the Lydd
Road and The Suttons area of Camber.
• The effect of the proposals on the living conditions of the occupiers of the
dwelling with particular regard to outdoor amenity space.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
3. Policy OSS4 of the Rother Local Plan Core Strategy sets out general
development considerations and requires at iii) that development respects and
does not detract from the character and appearance of the locality. A high
design quality is sought in Policy EN3 with development required to contribute
positively to the character of the site and surroundings including taking
opportunities to improve areas of poor visual character or with poor townscape
qualities, and robust design solutions are to be tested against, among other
criteria, e) the landscape setting of buildings and settlements.
4. The Rother Development and Site Allocations Local Plan contains Policy DHG9
which is specific to extensions and alterations and criteria ii), iii) and vi) refer
to respecting and responding positively to the features of the dwelling, not
detracting from the character and appearance of the wider street-scene, and
Appeal Decision APP/U1430/D/20/3254638
2
extensions are to be visually subservient to the building including its roof form.
The natural and built landscape character of the area is to be maintained under
Policy DEN1.
5. Paragraph 124 of the 2019 National Planning Policy Framework states that
good design is a key aspect of sustainable development, creates better places
in which to live and work and helps make development acceptable to
communities, while paragraphs 127 and 130 set out further design
requirements including that poor design should be refused permission.
6. The proposal is an extension but is so thoroughgoing in terms of the use of new
cladding materials and additional elements as to appear more as a replacement
dwelling. It is based on the same part of the tapering site as the present
house, with a full width extension to the rear and significant changes to the
roof-scape.
7. The Council’s first Reason for Refusal refers to the site as the gateway to the
village, and that analysis is correct. Approaching along the road from the east
there is limited built form; a car park to the left behind the sea wall, and to the
right, at a lower level is a caravan and camping field. The design of the
amenity buildings associated with that use is however conspicuous.
8. The present house on the appeal site is a significant, and again conspicuous
feature, but it is not attractive and only serves to introduce a varied but
unprepossessing streetscape of chalets and other buildings along the main
road. Diversion along The Suttons however reveals a more attractive variety
backing onto the sands, including the beach house referred to in the appellant’s
Statement and by the same local architects; winner of ‘small house of the year’
in the 2019 British Homes Awards.
9. The site is within the development boundary defined in the recently adopted
Local Plan and the planning history refers to various previously approved
schemes for redevelopment and extension on the site, although it is less clear
which were carried out. The extent of the present house and its limited
contribution to the character and appearance of the area, particularly given the
importance of the site’s location as a gateway, was clear to see at the site
inspection, as was the somewhat dilapidated condition. The dominance of the
garage and its poor-quality roofing materials detracts significantly from the
approaches to the village and from views along the sea wall and The Suttons.
10. The proposed remodelling would remove the garage and would replace the
unattractive brick, weatherboard and concrete tile finish with new timber
cladding, render and zinc panelling, the latter extending over parts of the newly
formed roof profiles. That change together with the altered and enlarged
massing of the elements would significantly improve the presentation of the
building. Whilst the elevation drawings show the extent of additional height
and massing, the effect over the open approach to the site and village would be
of an acceptable addition and the computer-generated image at 00919-PL-360
indicates acceptable change that would enhance the character and appearance
of the area.
11. Connected with this effect, the third reason for refusal alleged harm through
the raising of the boundary wall along Lydd Road. The appellant makes clear
that the extent of change is more limited than indicated on the computer-
generated image and relates more directly to the building as a backdrop, the
Appeal Decision APP/U1430/D/20/3254638
3
raising being sought in order to protect the occupiers from traffic noise and
fumes. A landscaping condition could require more detail on this item along
with proposals for the front of this prominent site, which would lead to an
improvement over the present arrangement.
12. In addition to the award-winning dwelling on The Suttons, the appellant has
drawn attention to other more contemporary interventions within the various
traditional pitched roofed dwellings in the village, and these were identified at
the unaccompanied site visit. Whilst in the main either less conspicuous or
comprising a larger more unified development, such as at the corner of Lydd
Road and Old Lydd Road, these do indicate the value of good quality
architecture.
13. To conclude, the present building does not contribute to the character and
appearance of the area and its condition is detrimental, although that could be
improved. The proposed remodelling would introduce a fitting entry to the
village, albeit not matching nearby building styles, and would represent a high
quality of design as sought in the Framework and Policy EN3. Whilst the
thoroughgoing nature of the extension does not suit testing against parts of
Policy DHG9, the effect would not be harmful, and the proposal would satisfy
the aims of that policy and Policy DEN1 in its effect on the character and
appearance of the area.
Living Conditions
14. Policy OSS4 i) requires development to meet the needs of future occupiers
including providing appropriate amenities, and Policies DHG7 i) and DHG9 iv)
require regard to be had to private amenity space of 10m length normally
being required, and extensions leaving sufficient private space for the
occupiers.
15. Possibly as a result of previous additions, but more clearly resulting from the
shape of the site and the proximity of Lydd Road and The Suttons, the obvious
amenity area to the rear of the building seen at the site inspection is small and
badly overlooked from the higher viewpoint of The Suttons. To the front, the
large double garage takes up useful space, and that remaining is close to the
main road with only a low wall between. However, there is ready access to the
expanse of the sands without the need to cross a main road.
16. The proposed extension across the rear of the dwelling, replacing a one-third
width addition, would remove the limited space presently available, but the
removal of the garage would free-up space to the sunnier front area, and as
stated previously, a landscaping scheme as offered by the appellant as a
condition would ensure an improvement to this area in any event. The addition
of the balcony off the living room would provide additional good-quality space
that is not available at present and its siting would limit the adverse effects of
being on a main road.
17. With improvements secured by condition, the remodelled house would provide
an appropriate level of amenity as sought in Policy OSS4 i) and having due
regard to the nearby sands, the proposal would not be contrary to Policies
DHG7 i) and DHG9 iv); the 10m dimension ‘normally’ sought is not
prescriptive.
Appeal Decision APP/U1430/D/20/3254638
4
Conditions
18. The Council has completed the Householder Questionnaire to accept the
standard time condition and that listing the drawings, for the avoidance of
doubt and in the interests of proper planning, and these are required. It would
not however be appropriate to seek materials that match those of such poor
quality as are in place on the existing building, and neither are they proposed.
It would be appropriate to seek samples of materials in view of the prominence
of the site.
19. As set out previously, a landscaping scheme should be sought for approval in
order to ensure the quality of the development and to control its effect on the
character and appearance of the area and the provision of amenity space. For
the same reason, it is proposed to require the demolition of the garage, as it
sits on a footprint that could allow retention, and this Decision is based in part
on the benefit of it being removed.
20. The appellant draws attention to a discrepancy between the drawings, in that
00919-PL-226_A shows 3 dotted rectangles indicating rooflights on the north
facing roof slope, whereas they are not shown on drawing 00919-PL-351_A.
This Decision is based on the latter drawing without the rooflights and a
condition should make that clear.
Conclusions
21. The amount of amenity space is appropriate to the location and the remodelling
brought about as part of the scheme of extension would enhance the approach
to the village and accord with Development Plan and national policies
previously cited. As stated in the Officer’s Report, there would be further
benefits through improvements to the flood resilience of the dwelling, which is
stated to currently have ground-floor bedroom accommodation. For the
reasons given above I conclude that the appeal should be allowed.
S J Papworth
INSPECTOR
Appeal Decision APP/U1430/D/20/3254638
5
Schedule of Conditions
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans; 00919-PL-50_A, 225, 226_A, 227_A,
350_A, 351_A, 360 and 361.
3) No work shall be carried out to install new external finishes until samples
and specification of those finishes have been submitted to and approved
in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The development shall be
constructed using only the approved external finishes.
4) The extension hereby approved shall not be constructed above slab level
until there has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local
Planning Authority a scheme of hard and soft landscaping and boundary
treatment and to include a programme for implementation. Any trees or
shrubs removed, dying, being seriously damaged or diseased within 5
years of planting shall be replaced in the next planting season with trees
or shrubs of similar size and species unless otherwise agreed in writing
by the Local Planning Authority. Any hard landscaping as may be
approved which provides amenity space or car parking spaces shall be
available for use before first occupation of the extension and shall be
retained for those uses thereafter.
5) The extension hereby approved shall not be constructed above slab level
until the existing garage has been demolished and permanently removed
from the site.
6) Notwithstanding the details shown on drawing 00919-PL-226_A, no
rooflights are to be installed on the north facing roof-slope, whether or
not permitted under the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted
Development) (England) Order 2015.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.