Single storey rear extension on house, single storey garage extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Policy Weight
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 26 August 2020
by D. Szymanski, BSc (Hons) MA, MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 28th August 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/T3725/D/20/3254538
The Threshing Barn, Finwood Road, Rowington, CV35 7DL
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Ben Stott against the decision of Warwick District Council.
• The application Ref: W/20/0329 dated 26 February 2020, was refused by notice dated
21 May 2020.
• The development proposed is single storey rear extension on house, single storey
garage extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. The appeal site is located within the Green Belt. The Council has concluded
that the proposals would not constitute inappropriate development in the Green
Belt. This matter is not in dispute between the parties. Accordingly, I have
had regard to this in setting out the main issue below.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development upon the character
and appearance of the appeal site and the area.
Reasons
4. The appeal site comprises roughly half of a historic barn conversion, set within
a well vegetated plot which provides a pleasant rural setting to the historic
agricultural building. The existing cat slope roof projection to the barn has a
shallower sloping roof than the original dwelling. Its proportion of large glass
panes and stained wooden frames result in it being identifiable as a modern
addition that is not entirely in keeping with the original red brick building.
However, due to its depth and size it appears as a subservient addition to the
historic building.
5. By extending the depth of the extension from approximately 4.3m to 6.3m, the
shallower roof pitch would be significantly deeper than the steeper historic
pitch on that side of the building. It would result the modern addition no
longer being subservient or sympathetic to the scale and appearance of the
original building within the appeal site. Instead it would appear to be a
Appeal Decision APP/T3725/D/20/3254538
2
dominant element of the dwelling that significantly and detrimentally alters the
balance and appearance due to its combination of depth, design and materials.
6. It is suggested the previously approved extensions created a catslide roof that
might have been historically added to this style of barn. Even if this was the
case, the additional depth and halving the eaves height to approximately only
0.7m high, would appear incongruous in relation to the eaves height, form and
overall appearance of the main barn. The proximity to the site boundary would
exacerbate the dominating effect of the extension and it would result in the
dwelling feeling cramped within its currently rural and relatively spacious plot.
7. Presently the detached car port has the appearance of a modest and
subservient cart shed in keeping with the rural agricultural character of the
appeal site. This is because of its simple frame, open frontage, gable roof and
its limited width and depth. The proposed cross gable roof extension
significantly increases its size. The increase in size and further enclosing some
of the internal space, would significantly alter the scale, appearance and
character of the building.
8. The building would no longer appear as a simple and traditional re-purposed
agricultural building. The combination of the position of the cross gable roof,
increased scale, proximity to the barn, and enclosure of some sides, would
result in it appearing more modern, complex and contrived. This would not be
in keeping with the character or appearance of the historic barn. By adding to
the enclosure of the space around the dwelling, in combination with the other
proposed extension, the developments would feel cramped and they would
significantly urbanise the site and detrimentally erode the rural character of the
site.
9. The perimeter vegetation limits visibility of appeal site from the wider area.
However, I have no guarantees this would remain and there is not a means
before me of securing the long term retention of the vegetation.
10. Due to its brick pillars and gable roof the car port at Rookery Barn next door
appears as a re-used traditional agricultural building. It is also viewed in a
different context and is discernibly further from the main dwelling, increasing
its sense of separation and subservience. Therefore, it is significantly different
to the appeal proposal to and does not justify allowing this appeal.
11. The height and scale of the low eaves roofs on the other barns are not
quantifiable from the photographs provided. Neither is the location or the
circumstances that lead to their existence or approval, including development
plan policies and other material considerations. However, the materials and
vernacular of the buildings are not similar to the appeal site. The cat slope
roofs also appear to be further from the edge of their plot. Therefore, they are
not directly comparable to the appeal proposal. In Ref: W/19/0548 the eaves
appear considerably higher than the appeal proposal, so it does not represent a
direct comparison.
12. The appellant has provided several examples of conversions and/or additions to
rural buildings spanning around 39 years. Due to the nature of the different
locations, contexts, sites and proposals none appear to represent a direct
comparison to the appeal site and proposal. Due to their age and lack of
information, many are of limited relevance. Of the examples that post-date
Appeal Decision APP/T3725/D/20/3254538
3
the current development plan, the attached extensions at Kestrel Barn were to
a significantly different barn on a larger site.
13. The proposals at Holly Barn are for the insertion of various openings and
external alterations to the existing building and a heating tank. At Red Brick
Farm they relate to the conversion of existing buildings with associated
windows and doorways. At Falcon Barn the increased floorspace was gained by
a link extension between two buildings. These are all considerably different to
the proposals before me. I must consider this appeal on its own merits and
impacts, including site and building specific considerations.
14. The benefits of the new space to the occupiers in terms of health and lifestyle
are small benefits and attract little weight. The screening of alleged
unauthorised development attracts little weight, as if it is unauthorised, I
cannot be certain it will remain. Furthermore, the evidence does not
demonstrate that activities taking place at the equestrian centre result in
harmful living conditions, or that screening could not be achieved by other less
obtrusive means. These factors do not outweigh the harm I have found.
15. For the reasons set out above, the development would not be in keeping with,
and would be harmful to the character and appearance of the appeal site and
the area. Therefore, it would conflict with Policy BE1 of the Warwick District
Local Plan (2017) (the Local Plan). This requires development positively
contributes to the character and quality of its environment and surrounding
buildings, and respects and reinforces local architectural and historical
distinctiveness, including through appropriate form and materials,. The
development would also conflict with paragraph 127 of the Framework, which
requires development adds to the overall quality of the area and is sympathetic
to local character and history.
16. There would be some conflict with the design advice in the Council’s
Supplementary Planning Guidance for Agricultural Buildings and Conversion
(the SPD), which seeks to retain the integrity of the original building, the roof
profile and form, and the rural setting. Whilst the advice and principles have
contributed to the current form and character of the appeal site, as the
conversion has already taken place, the advice is of limited relevance. The
wording of Policy H14 of the Local Plan suggests criteria a) – c) and the related
explanatory text is only applicable in relation to disproportionate extensions.
As I have not found the extensions to be disproportionate Policy H14 is of
limited relevance.
Conclusion
17. The proposed development would be contrary to the development plan and the
National Planning Policy Framework as a whole, and there are no
considerations, including the policies of the Framework, which outweigh this
finding. Accordingly, for the reasons given, the appeal should not succeed.
Dan Szymanski
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.