Proposed side and rear extension and internal alterations
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
No strong technical themes detected.
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site Visit made on 7 September 2021
by G Pannell BSc (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 15 October 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/R3515/D/20/3254392
32 Broughton Road, IPSWICH, IP1 3QR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Ms S Ball against the decision of Ipswich Borough Council.
• The application Ref IP/19/00975, dated 23 October 2019, was refused by notice dated
31 March 2020.
• The development proposed is proposed side and rear extension and internal alterations.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
• whether the proposed development would preserve or enhance the
character and appearance of the Park Conservation Area, including its
effect on trees;
• the effect of the development on highway safety; and
• the effect of the proposed development on the living conditions of the
occupiers of 17 Warrington Road, in respect of overlooking.
Reasons
Character and appearance
3. The Park Conservation Area (CA) was developed on high ground as a wealthy
suburb and the area retains a strong framework of tree lined roads and large
villas set within generous mature gardens often partly hidden behind
elaborately detailed boundary walls. The focus of the area is Christchurch Park,
whose tree line terminates many of the views from the conservation area.
4. Broughton Road rises gently from south to north and comprises mainly late
Victorian detached and semi-detached houses on the west side, while the east
side has seen infill development (including the appeal site) at various times.
5. The CA is notable for large Victorian and Edwardian villas and inter-war
detached houses. Many have fine architectural features such as porches,
turrets, authentic contemporary conservatories and original timber joinery and
in my view the significance of the CA is largely drawn from the collective group
of high quality historic buildings.
Appeal Decision APP/R3515/D/20/3254392
2
6. The appeal site comprises a detached red brick two storey dwelling which is
later in date than the majority of development within this part of the CA. It was
constructed within the former rear gardens of 17 and 19 Warrington Road, and
vehicular access to properties within Warrington Road remain on either side of
the site. The Park Conservation Area Appraisal (CAA) makes reference to the
modern infill dwellings adjacent to the appeal site as failing to capture the spirit
of the prevailing architectural character.
7. The proposed two storey extension would be located to the side of the dwelling,
set back from the front wall of the host dwelling, with a lower roofline. In these
ways the proposal would be subservient to the host property. However, the
proposed single storey front extension would project beyond the front elevation
and introduce a gabled addition which leads to a cluttered appearance, which is
not in keeping with the original design of the dwelling. Overall, I find that the
proposed single storey front extension would not result in a sympathetic and
proportionate addition and would detract from the overall character and
appearance of the host dwelling.
8. The introduction of the front extension as proposed would alter the character of
the existing dwelling and result in an unbalanced appearance to the frontage. It
would be an incongruous addition, which would fail to preserve or enhance the
CA. Given its significance is derived from the collective group of high quality
historic buildings and the appeal site has been designed to echo some of the
architectural detailing which is found within those buildings, I consider that the
single storey front extension would result in limited harm to the significance of
the CA.
9. In addition, the development would result in the loss of part of the front
boundary wall and garden to provide an additional vehicular access. Elaborately
detailed boundary walls are noted as a feature of the CA. The boundary
treatment to the frontage of the site is a simple red brick wall which is
markedly different from other more elaborate examples which exist elsewhere
within the CA, however it does run parallel to the highway and provides a
continuity to the built environment and adds positively to the overall character
and appearance of the area. Therefore, a reduction to the extent of the
boundary treatment and the introduction of further areas of hardstanding, in
lieu of the front garden would erode, rather than preserve and enhance the CA,
resulting in modest harm to its significance.
10. The submitted tree report has identified that trees located outside of the appeal
site have the potential to impact the developments foundations and that there
is a risk to the trees roots from severance. The report does identify mitigation
measures that could be put in place to minimise the risks from the
development, including hand excavation and root pruning within the root
protection area and the need for arboricultural supervision during the
construction phase to monitor tree health and a tree protection condition. The
evidence before me indicates that if these mitigation measures were properly
adhered to during the construction of the dwelling then the risk to the trees
would be minimal.
Appeal Decision APP/R3515/D/20/3254392
3
11. Whilst the Council have suggested that the positioning of the extension close to
the trees would place additional pressure on those trees to be harmfully pruned
or removed in the future, given the trees are protected by virtue of their
location within the CA, the Council would have control over any future works
proposed to the trees.
12. Therefore, I conclude that the risk from the development to the long term
health and viability of the trees is adequately mitigated and the development
would therefore accord with Policy DM10 of the Ipswich Borough Council Local
Plan, Core Strategy and Policies Development Plan Document Review (LP)
which seeks to protect and ensure the care of trees and ensure that details of
protective measures are put in place during the development process.
13. Paragraph 199 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)
advises that when considering the impact of development on the significance of
designated heritage assets, great weight should be given to their conservation.
Given that the proposal would be of a relatively small scale, I find the harm to
the setting of the Conservation Area to be less than substantial in this instance
but nevertheless of considerable importance and weight.
14. Under such circumstances, paragraph 202 of the Framework advises that this
harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal. In this
case, the proposed development would lead to some benefits during the
construction phase, which would support the local economy. However, these
benefits would be modest and therefore, there is no public benefit sufficient to
outweigh the harm.
15. I conclude that the development proposed would fail to preserve or enhance
the character or appearance of the Park Conservation Area and fail to accord
with Policies DM5, DM8 and DM12 of the LP, which together seek to ensure
development is well designed, in keeping with the immediate street scene and
protects and enhances the special character and distinctiveness of Ipswich and
its Conservation Areas.
Highway Safety
16. As part of the appeal the appellant has indicated they would consider stopping
up the existing access. I have not considered this as part of this appeal as I
consider that this change would materially alter the nature of the application
and would prejudice the interests of interested parties.1
17. The proposed garage is located approximately 5.5m from the highway, which is
insufficient distance to prevent vehicles obstructing the footway when entering
the site. Given the restricted depth of the area in front of the garage there
would be a high probability that anything other than the smallest of vehicles
would be likely to overhang the pavement, when entering the site to access the
garage.
18. The obstacle that a stationary vehicle would provide may result in pedestrians
having to step into the carriageway, particularly if they were pushing a pram or
wheelchair, which could result in conflict with vehicles using the road. The
1 Annex M of the Procedural Guide Appeals – England advises that the appeal process should not be used to
evolve a scheme and it is important that what is considered by the Inspector is essentially what was considered by
the local planning authority, and on which interested people’s views were sought.
Appeal Decision APP/R3515/D/20/3254392
4
proposal would therefore be likely to be harmful to highway safety, including
the safety of pedestrians.
19. Whilst it has been put to me that the area is only lightly trafficked, with low
traffic speeds, there is insufficient evidence before me to demonstrate that this
is the case. However, even if I were to accept this was the case it would not
overcome my concerns that even a momentary conflict between vehicles and
pedestrians would be detrimental to highway safety. There is no evidence to
suggest that such circumstances could be avoided by the appeal proposal.
20. It has been put to me that the garage doors could be remotely controlled to
limit the time that vehicles were waiting on the highway, or by the installation
of the roller shutters, which it is alleged, could be secured by a suitably worded
condition. However, no details of either of these suggestions have been
provided. Moreover, a scheme that includes the provision of roller shutter doors
would, to my mind, fundamentally alter the nature of the scheme and so would
necessitate a separate planning application.
21. I conclude that the proposal would result in harm to highway safety, in conflict
with Policies DM5 and DM18 of the LP. These require parking to be fully
integrated in the design of the scheme and to ensure a safe and attractive
environment. The proposal would also conflict with guidance in the National
Planning Policy Framework which seeks to ensure that safe and suitable access
to the site can be achieved for all users.
Living Conditions
22. The proposed two storey rear extension would extend beyond the rear
elevation of the existing dwelling and would include two first floor windows
serving bedrooms. These windows would face towards the rear garden of 17
Warrington Road.
23. I consider that having regard to the separation distance between 32 Broughton
Road and 17 Warrington Road, and the current level of mutual overlooking of
the rear amenity areas from the existing first floor windows, the development
would not cause an unacceptable loss of privacy in comparison to the existing
situation, despite the increased depth of the extension.
24. I conclude that the proposal would not harm the living conditions of the
adjoining residents of 17 Warrington Road, with regard to privacy in
accordance with policy DM12 of the LP which requires extensions to dwellings
to not detract from the amenity of neighbouring residents.
Conclusion
1. For the reasons given above, the proposal would therefore conflict with the
development plan and there are no other considerations, including the
Framework, that outweigh this conflict. Therefore, I conclude that the appeal
should be dismissed.
G Pannell
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.