Minor alterations to existing ground floor extension, including raising of the rear parapet and the replacement of doors, windows and roof lights. Construction of a rear dormer window as part of a loft conversion including the installation of conservation rooflight in the flank roofslope
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 22 September 2020 by Hannah Ellison BSc (Hons) MSc MRTPI
Decision by Joanna Gilbert MA (Hons) MTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 19 October 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/V5570/D/20/3254354
5 Canonbury Park South, Islington, London N1 2JR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Holmes against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Islington.
• The application Ref P2020/0473/FUL, dated 13 February 2020, was refused by notice
dated 3 April 2020.
• The development proposed is described as ‘Minor alterations to existing ground floor
extension, including raising of the rear parapet and the replacement of doors, windows
and roof lights. Construction of a rear dormer window as part of a loft conversion
including the installation of conservation rooflight in the flank roofslope.’
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal Procedure
2. The site visit was undertaken by an Appeal Planning Officer whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard
before deciding the appeal.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is whether the proposal would preserve or enhance the
character or appearance of the Canonbury Conservation Area (CCA).
Reasons
4. The appeal property at 5 Canonbury Park South is a two-storey, brick, semi-
detached dwelling located within the CCA, where an Article 4 (2) direction
removes certain permitted development rights. The CCA’s significance is largely
derived from eighteenth and early nineteenth century properties. However,
there are examples of later developments, such as the appeal dwelling and the
surrounding pairs of semi-detached properties of similar character and
appearance, which contribute positively to the significance of the CCA.
5. The appeal dwelling is primarily seen in context with its villa pair at No 7 and
the three adjacent pairs of semi-detached dwellings at Nos 1 – 3, and Nos 9 -
15. Both Nos 5 and 7 have existing rooflights in the rear roofslopes, while No 5
has also been extended at ground floor level. There are some differences in
design and fenestration with Nos 3 and 13 having front gables which are
repeated on other properties on Canonbury Park North. However, it is the
Appeal Decision APP/V5570/D/20/3254354
2
symmetry in the hipped roof form and largely unaltered front, side and rear
rooflines which remain generally consistent. It is this prominent characteristic
which makes a positive contribution to the villa pair at Nos 5 - 7, the
immediate street scene and the wider area, as glimpses of the rear roofs of
properties on Canonbury Park South can be seen from Canonbury Park North.
6. Paragraph 5.150 of the Islington Urban Design Guide Supplementary Planning
Document (January 2017) (the SPD) advises that within conservation areas,
the roofline is often an important feature contributing to the character of an
area and therefore proposals for roof extensions anywhere along an unaltered
roofline within a conservation area will not generally be acceptable. Islington’s
Conservation Area Design Guidelines, A supplement to the UDP, Revised
version (January 2002) (the CADG) also advises at paragraph 8.14 that within
the CCA, new or enlarged dormer windows or rooflights on the front or side
slopes of exposed pitched roofs will not be permitted.
7. The appeal proposal would include the introduction of a rooflight to the flank
roofslope and dormer to the rear roofslope of No 5. Due to its scale and
positioning, the proposed dormer would be a dominant addition to the host
dwelling and would create a displeasing imbalance to the symmetry of the main
roofs of the villa pair. Despite existing planting and mature trees, it would be
visible from public viewpoints in gaps between buildings on Canonbury Park
North and across private gardens. Although the proposed materials and
fenestration design would be sympathetic and would match the existing first
floor window, the proposed dormer would appear as a discordant feature in the
street scene that would fail to reflect the characteristics of the CCA.
8. Irrespective of its low-profile conservation design and colour, the proposed
rooflight to the flank roofslope would be prominent on the approach to the site
from the south west. It would therefore represent an incongruous addition to
the host dwelling and its villa pair and would appear at odds with the largely
unaltered side rooflines of the surrounding pairs of semi-detached properties.
9. There have been two previous approvals for a rear dormer and a rooflight at No
5, which pre-date current policy and guidance and were not carried out.
Similarly, while other properties, including No 3, have existing rooflights and
dormer extensions I have not been provided with the full details of their
approvals and cannot therefore be certain that they were approved in a similar
policy context to the proposal before me. I therefore consider that the previous
approvals at No 5 and the existing rooflights and dormers to other properties
would not justify the proposal before me. Furthermore, while the Council and
appellant have referred to the possibility of the proposed dormer coalescing
with any similar dormer at No 7, no such proposal is before me. Additionally,
the lack of harm with regard to the living conditions of neighbouring occupiers
does not alter my findings with regard to the main issue in this appeal.
10. In terms of the approach set out in the National Planning Policy Framework
(the Framework), the proposal would cause less than substantial harm to the
CCA’s significance as a designated heritage asset. The Framework is clear that
irrespective of the level of harm, great weight should be given to the asset’s
conservation and, where a development proposal would lead to less than
substantial harm, this harm should be weighed against the public benefits of
the proposal including, where appropriate, securing its optimum viable use.
Appeal Decision APP/V5570/D/20/3254354
3
11. It is suggested that the proposal would ensure the continued use of the
building, but there is no compelling evidence before me to suggest that the
existing use of the property cannot be sustained without the proposed
development. As such, the enlargement of the dwelling would provide a private
benefit. Therefore, on this basis, there are no demonstrable public benefits that
would outweigh the identified harm to the significance of the CCA.
12. Taking all the above into consideration, the proposal would neither preserve
nor enhance the character or appearance of the CCA. Consequently, it would
conflict with Policies 7.4, 7.6 and 7.8 of the London Plan (March 2016), Policy
CS9 of Islington’s Core Strategy (February 2011), Policies DM2.1 and DM2.3 of
Islington’s Local Plan: Development Policies (June 2013) and the Framework
which collectively seek, amongst other things, to ensure developments
complement local character and distinctiveness and conserve or enhance the
significance of the historic environment. The proposal would also conflict with
the guidance within the SPD and CADG as noted above. The appellant has
referred to the draft London Plan (Intend to Publish) version (December 2019).
As this is not yet adopted and no specific policies have been provided, I have
not addressed this Plan in detail.
Conclusion and Recommendation
13. For the reasons given above and having regard to all other matters raised, I
recommend that the appeal is dismissed.
Hannah Ellison
Appeal Planning Officer
Inspector’s Decision
14. I have considered all the submitted evidence and the Appeal Planning Officer’s
report and on that basis the appeal is dismissed.
Joanna Gilbert
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.