Demolition of existing detached garage and erection of two storey side and single story rear extensions and front elevation canopy roof to ground floor
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 November 2020
by Gary Deane BSc (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 23 November 2020.
Appeal Ref: APP/G5180/D/20/3253745
49 Friar Road, Orpington BR5 2BW
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr J Taylor against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Bromley.
• The application Ref DC/20/00971/FULL6, dated 9 March 2020, was refused by notice
dated 6 May 2020.
• The development proposed is the demolition of existing detached garage and erection of
two storey side and single story rear extensions and front elevation canopy roof to
ground floor.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural matter
2. The description of development in the above heading is taken from the
application form. Part E of the planning appeal form, which was completed by
the appellant, indicates that the description of development has not changed
but a different wording has been entered. The description on the planning
appeal form refers to the proposal as the demolition of the existing garage and
construction of a part one and two storey side and rear extension with a new
front entrance and a front canopy roof extension. From my inspection of the
drawings, this revised description more accurately reflects the development
sought. I have assessed the proposal on that basis.
Main issues
3. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development firstly, on the
living conditions of the occupiers of 47 Friar Road with particular regard to
outlook, light, visual impact and sense of enclosure; and secondly, on the
character and appearance of the local area.
Reasons
Living conditions
4. The proposed development includes a 2-storey side extension along the depth
of the 2-storey main house, which is a semi-detached dwelling within a mainly
residential area. The flank wall of the new 2-storey addition would be close to
and parallel with the side boundary of the site. In this position, it would face
towards the side of 47 Friar Road, which is a single storey dwelling that stands
Appeal Decision APP/G5180/D/20/3253745
2
side-by-side with No 49. The new 2-storey sidewall facing the side of No 47
would extend along a major part of the existing flank wall to this bungalow. It
would also project well above the post and timber fence, which currently marks
the common boundary between these properties.
5. In the side elevation of No 47 there is an entrance door and a window from
which views of the new 2-storey sidewall would be direct and at close range
with the net curtain drawn to one side. That the finished building would occupy
an elevated position relative to No 47 due to the notable difference in ground
levels would accentuate its visual impact when seen from this adjacent
property. Having viewed the side of No 47 from the site, I have little doubt
that the new 2-storey sidewall, due to its length, height and close proximity to
the common boundary with the site, would unacceptably dominate the outlook
from the side window of No 47 whether or not it is regarded a primary or
secondary opening.
6. There would also be some loss of sunlight to the side of No 47 in the later part
of the day due to the overshadowing effect of the appeal dwelling with the new
built form in place. While the additional overshadowing would be modest given
the presence of the existing boundary fence, garage and house, it would still
accentuate the overly imposing presence of the new 2-storey sidewall, causing
it to overbear on the occupiers of No 47, especially when seen from their side
window. In addition, the new flank wall would have the effect of further
enclosing the space within the narrow corridor along the side of No 47. This
arrangement would unduly heighten a sense of enclosure for the occupiers of
No 47, which would be unneighbourly.
7. The appellant has drawn my attention to the close relationship between the
side elevations of 60 and 62 Friar Road located broadly opposite the site, which
I saw at the site visit. According to the appellant, the combined separation
distance between these neighbouring properties is only 1.95 metres and
neither achieves the minimum distance of 1 metre to their respective side
boundary required by the BLP. Few background details of the planning history
to these properties have been provided and so I cannot be certain that the
circumstances are the same or very similar to those before me. In any event,
it seems to me that additional harm cannot be justified simply because some
harm may already exist.
Character and appearance
8. The new 2-storey side extension would follow the main building and rooflines of
the main house at the front and use external materials to match those of the
existing building. According to the Council, the distance between the new
2-storey flank wall and the site’s side boundary would fall short of the
minimum 1-metre space required by Policy 8 of the Bromley Local Plan (BLP).
The supporting text to this policy explains that the gap is intended to ensure
that such development protects the high spatial standards and visual amenity
that characterise many residential areas.
9. By elongating the front elevation of No 49, the proposal would noticeably add
to the scale and mass of the host building that in turn would increase its
prominence in the local street scene. It would appear to loom over No 47
given the lower profile of this adjacent property. It would also disrupt the
balance between the appeal dwelling and its attached counterpart as a pair,
that are broadly similar in built form. That the new front canopy would stretch
Appeal Decision APP/G5180/D/20/3253745
3
across the front elevation of No 49 would exacerbate the sense of imbalance
when seen from the road because it would emphasise the increased width of
the completed dwelling. The awkward relationship between No 49 and the
attached dwelling would draw the eye from Friar Road on the immediate
approach to the site in both directions. As such, the proposal would be
obtrusive and introduce an unwelcome addition to the local area.
Conclusion on the main issues
10. On the main issues, I conclude that the proposed development would cause
significant harm to the living conditions of the occupiers of No 47 and have an
adverse effect on the character and appearance of the local area. Accordingly,
it is contrary to BLP Policies 6, 8 and 37 and the Council’s Supplementary
Planning Guidance No 2, Residential Design Guidance. These policies and
guidance aim to ensure that residential extensions achieve a high standard of
design, respect or maintain the space or gap between buildings where these
contribute to the character of the area and safeguard residential amenity.
Other matters
11. Once complete, the proposal would provide additional living accommodation,
which the appellant says, is much needed for his growing family. While I am
sympathetic to these personal circumstances, there is nothing before me to
indicate that these needs could only be met in the manner proposed.
12. The appellant notes that the Council failed to undertake a site visit before
reaching a decision although the timing of that event may well have coincided
with the restrictions on movement imposed by government due to the
pandemic. Had the Council carried out a more detailed desk top inspection or
requested photographs of Nos 60 and 62, the appellant feels that the outcome
would have been advantageous to him. However, the Officer’s report provides
a comprehensive account of the proposal and puts forward detailed objections
to the scheme that to my mind stand up well to close scrutiny. Having viewed
the site and its immediate surroundings, I share those concerns.
Conclusion
13. For the reasons set out above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Gary Deane
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.