Erection of a first floor side extension and two storey side extension following demolition of existing garages
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 27 July 2020
by Robin Buchanan BA(Hons), MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 25 November 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/A3655/D/20/3252419
Dovers, Barrs Lane, Knaphill, Surrey GU21 2JN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Robin Barrett against the decision of Woking
Borough Council.
• The application Ref PLAN/2019/1266, dated 28 December 2019, was refused by notice
dated 20 April 2020.
• The development proposed is the erection of a first floor side extension and two storey
side extension following demolition of existing garages.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The appeal site is in the Green Belt and the main issues are:
• Whether the proposed development would be inappropriate development in
the Green Belt for the purposes of the National Planning Policy Framework
(the Framework) and relevant Development Plan policies;
• Its effect on the openness of the Green Belt; and
• If it is inappropriate development, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, would be clearly outweighed by
other considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances
necessary to justify it.
Reasons
Whether Inappropriate Development in the Green Belt
3. The Framework states that inappropriate development is harmful to the Green
Belt and should not be approved except in very special circumstances.
Furthermore, the construction of new buildings should be regarded as
inappropriate development in the Green Belt subject to certain exceptions,
including the extension or alteration of a building provided that it does not
result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the ‘original
building’.
4. The Council has calculated building volume, floor area and footprint for the
original dwelling on the appeal site, the existing dwelling and the dwelling that
would result from the appeal proposal (the appeal dwelling). It has also
Appeal Decision APP/A3655/D/20/3252419
2
calculated the respective percentage change in these three measures between
the original dwelling and the appeal dwelling, and has compared (in percentage
increase terms) the original dwelling to a dwelling that would result if a
previous planning permission1 were to be implemented (the permitted
dwelling).
5. I do not have any other details of the permitted dwelling in evidence before
me, including approved plans. However, I note that the appellant does not
dispute the Council’s calculations and, on the evidence that is before me, I
have no reason to come to a different view in this regard. I also note that in
the supporting text to Policy DM13 of the Woking Development Management
Policies Development Plan Document, October 2016 (the DPD), the Council’s
expectation is that to be acceptable (ie not disproportionate) development
proposals ‘will be within the range 20-40% above the original volume of the
building’.
6. In this regard, the size of the permitted dwelling would result in an increase of
57.1% in building volume compared to the size of the original dwelling.
However, the appeal dwelling would be a 74.6% increase compared to the
original dwelling. In relation to the size of the permitted dwelling, the appeal
dwelling would therefore already be a significant increase; but in relation to the
original dwelling it would be approaching twice as much building volume than
the Council’s upper figure and, consequently, it would be a substantial increase
in size.
7. The appellant suggests that the permitted dwelling, in combination with
development that is alleged to be lawful by virtue of a certificate of lawfulness
of proposed use or development,2 would result in a dwelling that was either
similar or smaller in volume (and footprint) to the appeal dwelling. I note that
the Council’s officer report documents two applications for certificates of lawful
development for side and rear extensions,3 but at the time of the report these
were ‘not yet determined’. The appellant has provided diagrams which purport
to show the effect of this combined development, but I do not have the details
of either lawful use application or any decisions by the Council before me in
evidence in this current appeal, including any approved plans. I am therefore
unable to make any reasonable comparison or reach any finding as to whether
a ‘fall-back’ exists in this regard, as the appellant otherwise contends.
8. Accordingly, the appeal proposal would result in additions to the original
dwelling (building) that would be disproportionate in size. No other potential
exceptions, as cited in Framework paragraphs 145 and 146, have been put to
me to suggest that the appeal proposal might, for other reasons, not be
inappropriate development in the Green Belt. Consequently, the proposed
development would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt and it
would not accord with Policy CS6 of the Woking Core strategy, October 2012
(the CS) or DPD Policy DM13. These policies include strict controls over
inappropriate development in the Green Belt. It would also conflict with
Framework paragraphs 143 and 145(c).
1 Council’s reference PLAN/2019/0767.
2 Appellant’s reference 2019_1268.
3 Council’s references PLAN/2019/1267 and PLAN/2019/1268.
Appeal Decision APP/A3655/D/20/3252419
3
Openness of the Green Belt
9. The Framework states that the fundamental aim of the Green Belt is to prevent
urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open. In addition, one of the
essential characteristics of Green Belts is their openness.
10. In principle, I accept that the nature of the proposed development and use is
compatible with its location in the Green Belt. However, the appeal site is on
gently sloping land. I saw at my site visit that the reasonably limited extent of
the existing dwelling, particularly built form at first floor level, and its
separation from other nearby dwellings is therefore noticeable in public views
from the upper and lower sides of Barrs Lane, as it passes the appeal site at
the front, and also as it returns to pass the appeal site further to the rear.
Though the appeal proposal is modest in size relative to the extent of the wider
Green Belt, it would nonetheless result in significant enlargement of the scale
and massing of the existing dwelling, especially at first floor level, and thereby
reduce spatial and visual openness of the Green Belt, albeit to a very small
extent.
11. Accordingly, the appeal proposal would not preserve the openness of the Green
Belt. It would not accord with CS Policy CS6 or DPD Policy DM13. It would also
conflict with Framework paragraph 133.
Other Considerations
12. The Framework states that very special circumstances will not exist unless the
potential harm to the Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness and any other
harm resulting from the proposal is clearly outweighed by other considerations.
13. The appeal proposal would result in a slightly smaller building footprint than
the existing dwelling and the new roof would allow more solar panels to be
installed to reduce electricity use by other means. Furthermore, some of the
development would be within the main (largest) part of the garden and as a
result further away from some nearby dwellings. Nonetheless, considering the
reasonably limited nature of the proposed development, these would be limited
benefits of the appeal proposal.
14. The Council did not object to the appeal proposal for its effect on the living
conditions of occupiers of nearby dwellings. While I appreciate that some
interested parties objected for reasons of alleged overlooking and loss of
privacy, in light of my site visit I have no reason to disagree with the Council’s
conclusions on these matters, as set out in the officer report. However, the
absence of harm in this regard is a neutral factor in my decision. Thus, taken
together, the other considerations in this case attract little weight.
Other Matters
15. Some interested parties refer to the effect of the appeal proposal on the setting
of the Lower Knaphill Conservation Area (the CA). In this regard, I note that
the Council did not object to the proposed development. At the junction of
Barrs Lane and Littlewick Road I saw that the most significant elements in this
part of the CA are the older traditional buildings, including some with a rural
appearance, brick walls, trees and grassed open spaces.
16. The appeal site and the existing dwelling is significantly more distant from this
junction and, as a result, recede into the rising land behind and the adjacent
Appeal Decision APP/A3655/D/20/3252419
4
landscape setting of trees in and around this part of Barrs Lane. While the
proposed development would be visible, it would nonetheless therefore be seen
only to a limited extent and as a result would not form an important or
appreciable part of the vista from the junction. Furthermore, the design of the
appeal proposal would not be incompatible with the overall appearance and
form of the existing dwelling. Accordingly, the appeal proposal would not cause
harm to the significance of the CA or its setting at this point and would
therefore preserve the overall character and appearance of the CA. This is also
a neutral factor.
Green Belt Balance
17. The proposed development would be inappropriate development and would
lead to a very small loss of openness to the Green Belt. As the other
considerations in this case attract little weight, they would be insufficient to
clearly outweigh the harm to the Green Belt due to inappropriateness and loss
of openness, so the very special circumstances necessary to justify the
proposed development do not exist. The proposed development would not
accord with CS Policy CS6 or DPD Policy DM13. It would also conflict with
Framework paragraph 144.
Thames Basin Heaths Special Protection Area (the SPA)
18. The Council’s officer report refers to a ‘Thames Basin Heaths SPA Zone B
(400m-5km)’ but contains no further explanation of this matter, and there is
no relevant reason for refusal in the Council’s decision. The evidence before me
in this appeal does not therefore indicate whether the appeal proposal needs to
mitigate any impact of the proposed development to avoid adverse effect on
the integrity of the SPA. I am therefore unable to reach a view in this matter.
However, having regard to the main issues above, I intend to dismiss this
appeal and so I do not need to consider this matter any further.
Conclusion
19. For the reasons given, the appeal does not succeed.
Robin Buchanan
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.