Removal of existing part flat part pitched roof and replace with pitched and hipped roof with raised ridge including dormer windows to front and rear creating habitable accommodation on the second floor
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 October 2020
by R.Jones BA(Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 29 October 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/P1940/D/20/3252408
5 Pembroke Road, Moor Park HA6 2HP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Carter against the decision of Three Rivers District
Council.
• The application Ref 19/2405/FUL, dated 11 December 2019, was refused by notice
dated 24 February 2020.
• The development proposed is described as ‘removal of existing part flat part pitched
roof and replace with pitched and hipped roof with raised ridge including dormer
windows to front and rear creating habitable accommodation on the second floor.’
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the host property and the Moor Park Conservation Area.
Reasons
3. No.5 Pembroke Road (No.5) is within the Moor Park Conservation Area (CA). I
am therefore required to pay special attention to the desirability of preserving
or enhancing the CA, in accordance with the statutory duty as set out in
Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act
1990. Paragraph 193 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the
Framework) states that great weight should be given to the conservation of
designated heritage assets.
4. The Moor Park Conservation Area Appraisal (adopted 2006) (CAA) identifies
that the character and appearance of the area derives from spacious and
verdant low-density development. The houses originally built between the
1920s and 1950s are sited within spacious plots with open gardens and tree
lined roads. I saw from my site visit that Pembroke Road is typical of the
character of the CA, with substantial houses, of different styles, set on large
plots.
5. No.5 is a large two-storey detached house, with a central hipped roof behind a
parapet and two flat roofed wings which project slightly forward of the main
building line. In respect of buildings which make a positive contribution to the
CA, the CAA at paragraph 2.7 states “These buildings will be examples of
Appeal Decision APP/P1940/D/20/3252408
2
relatively unaltered buildings where their style, detailing and building materials
are characteristic of the conservation area. Occasionally, more “individual”
buildings of particular style or materials would also be considered to make a
positive contribution.” The parties do not agree as to exactly when the house
was built, but it is agreed that it pre-dates the late 1950s when the original
Estate Company was wound up. The flat roofed wings are thought to be later
additions and predate the CAA which states “flat roofs reflect a form not in
keeping with the traditional design of houses in Moor Park”. Although not
unaltered, in itself, No.5 is an “individual” building and the roof is a significant
part of its architectural interest. I agree with the Council’s Conservation Officer
that it is ‘characterful and distinctive,’ and I find it makes a positive
contribution to the character and appearance of the street scene and CA.
6. The proposed development would replace the existing roof with a duo pitched
and hipped roof structure. The CAA considers roof forms should be duo pitched
and I saw from my site visit that the style of houses on Pembroke Road
includes examples of hipped and pitched roof forms. However, whilst designed
to be simple in form, the new roof would extend the full width of the house, at
around 0.9m higher than the ridge of the existing central section. This scale
and mass would all but subsume the original roof form including the parapet
detailing. Extending over the flat roofed wings, the mass of the roof would be
closer to the road than existing, excessively prominent in the street scene,
even in the context of the large neighbouring houses. Detailing, such as the
dental course brickwork below the fascia, would not mitigate my concerns
regarding scale and massing.
7. Whilst not an original feature, the centrally located chimney, rather than
appearing unnecessarily large and incongruous, is an important part of the
composition of the house, providing a strong symmetry to the house. The
symmetry would be retained but, in combination with the roof, the removal of
the chimney would result in the individual interest of the house, which makes a
positive contribution to the CA, being lost.
8. Three modest dormers are proposed to the front roof slope, below the ridge
level and set in either end of the proposed roof. The windows would be a
similar size or smaller than those principal windows at first floor. The design,
location of the dormers and the even spacing between the projecting wings and
the dormers means they would appear appropriately proportioned and
subordinate to the roof. In isolation, I find the dormers acceptable. The Council
raise no issue with the proposed rear dormers and I have no reason to
conclude otherwise.
9. The appellant has drawn my attention to local examples of large houses with
different room forms and dormer windows. Despite the architectural variety
within the area, I do not consider that these examples are directly comparable
to the appeal scheme nor would they represent a compelling reason to find
favour of a scheme that would cause the harm I have identified in this
instance.
10. In relation to designated heritage assets, the Framework indicates that where
there would be harm that is less than substantial, as in this case, it must be
weighed against the public benefits of the proposal. Although less than
substantial harm would arise in this case, considerable importance and weight
must still be attached to it. This is necessary in order to reflect the statutory
Appeal Decision APP/P1940/D/20/3252408
3
duty of paying special consideration to the desirability of preserving or
enhancing the character and appearance of Conservation Areas. In this case
there is no evidence of any significant public benefit to outweigh the harm I
identify.
11. I therefore find that the proposed development would fail to preserve or
enhance the character and appearance of the Moor Park Conservation Area.
Consequently, the development would be contrary to Policies CP1 and CP12 of
the Three Rivers District Council Core Strategy (2011) (CS) and Policies DM1
and DM3 and Appendix 2 of the Development Management Policies LDD (2013)
(DMP). CS Policy CP1 provides an overarching approach to sustainable
development, including the promotion of high-quality design that respects local
distinctiveness. It would not provide the high standard of design sought by
Policy CP12, which expects proposals to respect the distinctiveness of the
surrounding area, including in respect of character, scale, height and massing.
12. DMP Policy DM1 applies the design criteria of Appendix 2 to ensure that
development does not lead to a gradual deterioration in built environment
quality. DMP Policy DM3 addresses the historic built environment. Amongst
other things, it confirms that permission will only be granted if development is
of a design and scale that preserves or enhances the character and appearance
of the area.
13. Finally, the proposals would conflict with the Framework in so far as it requires
development to be sympathetic to local character and to sustain and enhance
the significance of heritage assets.
Conclusions
14. For the reasons given above, and having regard to all other matters raised, the
appeal should be dismissed.
R. Jones
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.