2.5 storey side extension, not exceeding the roof height of highest pitch roof at 12 Redmoor Close. Extension is within 1 meter from the boundary. With single storey front bay protrusion, with flat roof extending across to provide a canopy for the porch, in keeping with the art deco design style for our property
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 July 2020
by Martin Small, BA (Hons), BPl, DipCM, MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 13th July 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/D1780/D/20/3251853
14 Redmoor Close, Southampton, SO19 4DH
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Simon Dackham against the decision of Southampton City
Council.
• The application Ref: 20/00071/FUL dated 16 January 2020, was refused by notice dated
13 March 2020.
• The development proposed is described as ‘2.5 storey side extension, not exceeding the
roof height of highest pitch roof at 12 Redmoor Close. Extension is within 1 meter from
the boundary. With single storey front bay protrusion, with flat roof extending across to
provide a canopy for the porch, in keeping with the art deco design style for our
property’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of the host dwelling and on the street scene of Redmoor Close.
Reasons
Background
3. Planning permission was granted in 2014 for an ‘extension to porch and two
storey side extension’ at the appeal property. However, this has not been
implemented. The proposal before me differs from the approved scheme in
that it would be higher, incorporating an internal mezzanine floor.
Character and appearance
4. Redmoor Close is a cul-de-sac that rises from the entrance to a ‘bulb’ at the
end. The road accommodates a variety of detached and semi-detached 2-
storey dwellings and detached bungalows. The appeal property is one of six
semi-detached dwellings at the head of the cul-de-sac originally constructed in
a ‘moderne’ style. However, the original designs of some of these dwellings
have been changed by the addition of pitched roofs in place of the original flat
roofs and other alterations, although the appeal property retains its original flat
roof and moderne style.
5. The proposed extension would be to the side of the property and set back from
the front elevation, close to the side boundary but designed to retain a gap
Appeal Decision APP/D1780/D/20/3251853
2
between the side elevation of the extension and that boundary. It would have
the same footprint as the approved extension but would project above the
existing roof of the appeal property. The proposals also include the addition of
a shallow bay and the provision of a flat canopy over this window and front
door to the front elevation at ground floor level.
6. The increased height of the proposed extension, although no higher than the
ridge line of the partner dwelling to the appeal property, No. 12 Redmoor
Close, would result in its being more dominant than the approved scheme and
not subservient to the host property. Whilst I appreciate that the proposed
extension is intended to be in keeping with the architectural style of the appeal
property, it would not reflect the simple plain form of the host dwelling.
7. Moreover, the proposed extension would be more prominent than the approved
extension from Redmoor Close where the top of the extension would be visible
whereas the approved extension would be obscured by the existing dwelling.
Although it would be seen against a background of vegetation and a dwelling at
a higher level than the appeal property, the top of the proposed extension
would still be a noticeable feature, at odds with the roof forms of other
properties in the Close.
8. Furthermore, although the architectural composition of the six moderne
dwellings has been altered by the changes to some of the properties, the group
does retain sufficient coherence for the proposed extension to be at odds with
this group. The existing extension to No. 13 Redmoor Close does not project
above the roof of the main dwelling and so is materially different to the
proposal before me. These alterations to the other properties do not,
therefore, justify the proposed development.
9. I therefore conclude that although the proposed bay and canopy would be
acceptable, the increased height of the proposed side extension would be
harmful to the character and appearance of the appeal property and to the
street scene of Redmoor Close. The proposal therefore conflicts with saved
Policies SDP7 and SDP9 of the City of Southampton Local Plan Review (as
amended 2015) which, in combination, seek to protect the character and
appearance of an area and require proposals to respect their surroundings in
scale, massing and visual impact.
10. The proposal would not fully accord with Policy CS13 of the Local Development
Framework Core Strategy Development Plan Document (as amended 2015) as
although it would respond to the architectural vernacular, it would not respond
positively and integrate with its local surroundings and character. The
proposed development would also not fully accord with the guidance set out in
the Council’s Residential Design Guide that extensions should be subordinate to
and not dominate the appearance of the original dwelling. Nor would it fully
accord with paragraph 127 c) of the National Planning Policy Framework which
sets out that planning decisions should ensure that developments are
sympathetic to local character.
Other Matters
11. Whilst I sympathise with the appellant’s desire to provide additional
accommodation for his family, I have borne in mind that the development
would remain long after the personal circumstances have ceased to be
material. Therefore, this consideration does not outweigh the harm to the
Appeal Decision APP/D1780/D/20/3251853
3
character and appearance of the host dwelling and to the street scene that I
have identified.
12. The appellant has provided examples of other dwellings of similar style in
Southampton, which I observed during my site visit, and elsewhere which
incorporate a ‘tower’ as part of an asymmetrical design. However, whilst these
demonstrate that a tower feature is not necessarily incongruous with the
moderne style, these examples appear to be primarily more substantial,
individual, detached dwellings rather than part of a group of properties
originally of the same design, and thus differ from the appeal property and its
context. Accordingly, I do not consider that they justify the proposal before
me which, in any event, I have to determine on its own merits.
Conclusion
13. For the reasons given above, and having regard to the other matters raised,
the appeal is dismissed.
Martin Small
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.