Erection of a two storey rear extension, alteration to existing openings and erection of a canopy to the front elevation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Extensions
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 6 July 2020
by D Hartley BA (Hons) MTP MBA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 8 July 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/B3438/D/20/3251032
White Chimneys, Devils Lane, Longsdon ST9 9QR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs M Fludgate against the decision of Staffordshire
Moorlands District Council.
• The application Ref SMD/2020/0025, dated 14 January 2020, was refused by notice
dated 3 April 2020.
• The development proposed is the erection of a two storey rear extension, alteration to
existing openings and erection of a canopy to the front elevation.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for the erection of a
two storey rear extension, alteration to existing openings and erection of a
canopy to the front elevation at White Chimneys, Devils Lane, Longsdon ST9
9QR, in accordance with the terms of the application Ref SMD/2020/0025,
dated 14 January 2020, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans: Drawing No PL31 (Site location plan) and
Drawing No PL 34A (Alternative Proposed Plans and Elevations).
3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the
development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing
building.
Main Issue
2. There is no dispute between the parties that the proposal would be acceptable
in terms of design and that it would not cause harm from a living conditions
point of view. I have no reason to disagree.
3. The appeal site is in the Green Belt and so the main issues are:
• Whether or not the proposal would be inappropriate development in the
Green Belt; and
• if the proposal is inappropriate development in the Green Belt, whether the
harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly
outweighed by other considerations so as to amount to the very special
circumstances necessary to justify development.
Appeal Decision APP/B3438/D/20/3251032
2
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
4. The Government attaches great importance to Green Belts. The fundamental
aim of Green Belt policy is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land
permanently open; the essential characteristics of Green Belts are their
openness and their permanence. Paragraph 145 of the National Planning Policy
Framework (the Framework) states that a local planning authority should
regard the construction of new buildings as inappropriate in the Green Belt.
However, one exception to this relates to “the extension or alteration of a
building provided that it does not result in disproportionate additions over and
above the size of the original building”.
5. The Framework does not define what is disproportionate. Furthermore, I have
not been provided with any development plan policy which provides any such
definition. It is therefore necessary that I reach of a view on this matter using
my own planning judgement.
6. There is dispute between the parties in terms of the size of the proposed
development relative the size of the original building. The appellants say that
the Council’s claimed 60% increase in size assessment is not correct on the
basis that its calculations do not take into account the lean-to off the eastern
elevation or a further projection off the northern elevation. They claim that
when these parts of the dwelling are taken into account, the proposal would
increase the footprint of the original building by 48% and by 53% when the
ground floor and first floor areas are combined.
7. Even accounting for the appellant’s calculations, I consider that the proposed
development would result in disproportionate additions over and above the size
of the original building. Consequently, I conclude that when the proposal is
considered as a whole, it would amount to inappropriate development in the
Green Belt. To this extent, it would not accord with Policy SS6c of the adopted
Staffordshire Moorlands Core Strategy Development Plan Document 2014 (CS)
or meet any of the exceptions in paragraph 145 of the Framework.
8. Paragraph 143 of the Framework states that inappropriate development is, by
definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very
special circumstances. I deal with this matter below.
Other considerations and whether very special circumstances
9. The appellants make the claim that when the proposal is considered against an
extant prior approval permission for a single storey eight metre rear extension1
to the dwelling (i.e. development with a footprint of about 60.0 square metres
compared to the appeal proposal of about 32.3 square metres), there would in
fact be no significant difference in terms of the effect of the proposal on the
openness of the Green Belt or harm caused in respect of the purposes of the
Green Belt.
10. I have been able to consider the aforementioned extant planning permission
plans with the appeal proposal. Whilst the two developments would not be
identical, in particular one would be two storey and one would be single storey,
overall, and taking into account the relative differences in terms of the extent
1 Ref HNT/2019/0009
Appeal Decision APP/B3438/D/20/3251032
3
of the rear projections, there would in fact be very little difference between the
two proposals in terms of the resultant effect on the openness of the Green
Belt in spatial terms. Furthermore, the proposal would result in a dwelling
which in relative terms would be more compact within its plot when compared
to the dwelling with the permitted eight metre projecting single storey rear
extension. In reaching these on balance views, I have taken into account the
size of the proposed canopy to the front elevation of the dwelling.
11. I do acknowledge that the appellant has applied for a different form of
development to that which has been allowed as part of the prior approval
application. Nonetheless, I am persuaded that the appellants would very likely
seek to construct the prior approval development in the event that this appeal
was not allowed. Indeed, I do not see why the appellants’ appeal
accommodation requirements could not be met by reconfiguring the existing
dwelling internally in conjunction with the erection of the consented single
storey rear extension.
12. In this case, I afford very substantial weight, as a fallback position, to the
existence of the extant planning permission for the single storey extension. In
reaching this view, I am satisfied that this development could not be built out
in addition to the appeal development. The positive weight that I attribute to
the fallback position would, to a limited extent, be compounded by the fact that
the two storey extension, with its pitched roof and header/cill detailing, would
result in a dwelling which compared to the construction of the alternative single
storey rear extension, with its long flat roof, would be more sympathetic to the
design and appearance of existing dwelling. In addition, I do not doubt that
there would be some thermal efficiency benefits as a result of the removal of
the existing two storey rear extension and as a result of increased natural light
penetration into the resultant dwelling.
13. In this case and on balance, I find that the substantial weight to be given to
the Green Belt harm arising from the proposal would be clearly outweighed by
the other identified considerations sufficient to demonstrate very special
circumstances. Given this overall finding, the proposal would not conflict with
Green Belt policy in the Framework; policy SS6c of the CS or with policy SS10
of the emerging Staffordshire Moorlands Local Plan.
Conditions
14. Planning permission is granted subject to the standard three year time limit
condition. It is also necessary that the development shall be carried out in
accordance with the approved plans, for the avoidance of doubt and in the
interests of certainty. In the interests of good design, it is necessary to impose
a condition requiring the use of matching materials.
Conclusion
15. For the reasons outlined above, I conclude that the appeal should therefore be
allowed.
D Hartley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.