Application for minor amendment to planning permission 2017/211, for alteration to roof shape, removal of roof lights and repositioning of fenestration” (retrospective)
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Rural Impact
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site Visit made on 14 September 2021
by L Douglas BSc (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 7th October 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/M3645/D/20/3249163
Poets Corner, Pikes Lane, Crowhurst RH7 6LX
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Nigel Bryant against the decision of Tandridge District
Council.
• The application Ref TA/2019/2157, dated 6 December 2019, was refused by notice
dated 9 March 2020.
• The development is “Application for minor amendment to planning permission
2017/211, for alteration to roof shape, removal of roof lights and repositioning of
fenestration” (retrospective).
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The appeal relates to an outbuilding which has already been constructed other
than in accordance with an earlier planning permission granted by the Council
(Ref 2017/211, ‘the Approved Scheme’). There is an extant enforcement notice
relating to the outbuilding which was upheld and varied at appeal1. The
proposal relates to an amended outbuilding design, which is therefore different
to the Approved Scheme and that considered by the previous Inspector.
3. The appellant has advised that the scheme shown in the submitted plans
associated with this appeal has now been carried out; specifically, the roof
ridge and slopes have been lowered and roof lights have been removed
(compared to that considered by the previous Inspector). For clarity the
outbuilding also differs from the Approved Scheme in respect of its excavated
ground floor level, overall height and form, internal layout including the
provision of a first-floor level, a shower-room and a kitchen, and a different
fenestration layout.
4. The appellant’s appeal statement confirms the development the subject of this
appeal has been completed, and the appeal is therefore made retrospectively. I
have added the text ‘(retrospective)’ to the description of development in the
banner heading above.
Main Issues
5. Taking the above into account, the main issues are: (i) whether the outbuilding
is inappropriate development in the Green Belt having regard to the
1 APP/M3645/C/19/3223645
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/20/3249163
2
Framework2 and any relevant development plan policies; (ii) the effect of the
outbuilding on the openness of the Green Belt; (iii) the effect of the outbuilding
on the character and appearance of the area; and (iv) if the outbuilding does
constitute inappropriate development, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness and any other harm is clearly outweighed by other
considerations so as to amount to the very special circumstances necessary to
allow the appeal.
Reasons
6. The appeal site is located within the Green Belt and is occupied by a bungalow
with a large garden, double garage, and swimming pool. The outbuilding is
located adjacent to the swimming pool, at a lower level than the garage and
bungalow.
Whether the outbuilding is inappropriate development in the Green Belt
7. Paragraph 147 of the Framework explains that inappropriate development is,
by definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in
very special circumstances. Paragraph 149 of the Framework states that the
construction of new buildings within the Green Belt should be regarded as
inappropriate development, other than where specific exceptions apply. None
of the exceptions referred to by the Framework expressly apply to the
outbuilding. Policies DP10 and DP13 of the Council’s Local Plan3 reflect the
Framework in these regards.
8. Policy DP14 of the Council’s Local Plan states planning permission will be
granted for new ancillary domestic buildings in the curtilage of dwellings
located within the Green Belt where they meet four criteria. The policy’s
supporting text explains that compliance with these four criteria would
constitute the very special circumstances referred to by the Framework, which
I shall return to later.
9. As the outbuilding comprises the erection of a new building within the Green
Belt and does not meet any of the exceptions referred to by Paragraph 149 of
the Framework or Policies DP10 and DP13, I have assessed it on the basis that
it constitutes inappropriate development in the Green Belt.
Openness
10. Paragraph 137 of the Framework states: “the fundamental aim of Green Belt
policy is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open; the
essential characteristics of Green Belts are their openness and their
permanence”. Paragraph 138 then identifies five purposes Green Belts serve,
including, amongst other things, to assist in safeguarding the countryside from
encroachment. Openness is therefore an essential characteristic of the Green
Belt, which has spatial and visual aspects.
11. Although the appeal site is largely enclosed by tall fencing and planting, there
are views into the site from Pikes Lane and the neighbouring dwellings at The
Oast House and Pikes Farm. I noted views of the outbuilding from Pikes Lane to
the north and along Willow Drive to the south. In all these views, as well as
from within the appeal site, the outbuilding is a dominant feature, of significant
2 The National Planning Policy Framework (2021)
3 Tandridge Local Plan Part 2: Detailed Policies 2014 – 2029 (2014)
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/20/3249163
3
mass in comparison to all other buildings within the appeal site, including the
bungalow. It appears as a two-storey building, and has a substantial internal
useable floor area. The outbuilding therefore reduces the openness of the
Green Belt visually and spatially.
Character and Appearance
12. The appeal site and its surrounding area are characterised by their rural
setting. The appeal site is more open, with buildings of a smaller scale than the
neighbouring properties to the north and northeast, which are occupied by
large dwellings of historic appearance. The appeal site is separated from the
cluster of modern houses further away to the south by a thick band of trees.
The appeal site therefore forms part of a grouping of dwellings located within
the open countryside, which is distinctly rural and sparsely developed in
character and appearance.
13. On account of its overall size and form, including its excavated position, and its
appearance as a dominant building in comparison to the bungalow, the
outbuilding is an uncharacteristic feature. It harms the open and spacious rural
character and appearance of the area contrary to Policy DP7 of the Council’s
Local Plan and Policy CSP18 of the Council’s Core Strategy4. These policies
require, amongst other things, development to integrate effectively with its
surroundings and respect local distinctiveness, context and character without
resulting in unacceptable intensification by reason of scale or form.
Other Considerations
14. Policy DP14 of the Council’s Local Plan identifies very special circumstances
under which ancillary domestic buildings in the Green Belt may be permitted.
In summary, to accord with all these exceptions, development must: (1) not
constitute a dominant feature and not be excessive in size compared to the
dwelling they serve; (2) not detract from the rural character or appearance of
the locality; (3) not replace any existing garage that has been converted; and
(4) not be used for any purpose which is not incidental to the enjoyment of the
dwelling.
15. It is clear that the outbuilding complies with exception criterion (3), but in my
reasoning above I have found that it does not accord with exception criteria (1)
and (2). The outbuilding is of substantial scale, two storey and physically
separate from the bungalow, containing a shower-room and kitchen. Although
many internal alterations may not comprise development requiring planning
permission, these features all make the outbuilding capable of being occupied
independently of the bungalow. On this basis, the outbuilding cannot
reasonably be said to accord with criterion (4). That is notwithstanding that the
appellant makes no reference to its use other than as an ‘outbuilding’.
16. The Approved Scheme has not been implemented, but I note the appellant’s
claim that the outbuilding is no higher than that previously approved, when
measured from the ground level adjacent to the garage. This may be the case,
but as set out above, it is appropriate to assess the effect of the outbuilding on
the openness of the Green Belt spatially and visually. The ground floor level
and part of the land surrounding the outbuilding have been excavated and the
outbuilding is therefore notably taller than the Approved Scheme when
4 Tandridge District Core Strategy (2008)
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/20/3249163
4
measured from the excavated ground floor level. This provides substantially
more space within the outbuilding compared to the Approved Scheme, which is
clear in views within the appeal site where the full proportions and excavated
ground floor level of the outbuilding can be seen.
17. The excavation of the ground floor level of the outbuilding has therefore
resulted in development which is larger than the Approved Scheme, in both a
spatial and a visual sense. The outbuilding constructed also fails to accord with
three of the four necessary exception criteria referred to by Policy DP14. The
Approved Scheme acts as a fallback position, and its effect in terms of
character and appearance would be similar when viewed from outside the
appeal site. However, I assign only moderate weight to this consideration
against the harm the outbuilding causes to the Green Belt by reason of its
inappropriateness and the loss of openness, which result from its significant
increase in size, compared to the Approved Scheme.
18. An extension at Pikes Farm has also been referred to, which includes rooflights
and where the appellant claims no conditions were attached prohibiting internal
excavations or additional internal floors being installed. I have not been
presented with the full details and reasoning which resulted in that
development being granted planning permission. I do not consider the
possibility that such works may be lawful or may be carried out in that case to
affect my reasoning or findings on the Main Issues in this appeal.
Conclusion
19. I have found the outbuilding constitutes inappropriate development within the
Green Belt as defined by the Framework. The Framework states that
inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful to the Green Belt and
should not be approved except in very special circumstances. I have also
identified harm caused to the openness of the Green Belt and the character and
appearance of the area. I attach substantial weight to the harm caused to the
Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness and loss of openness. I attach less,
but still significant, weight to the harm caused to the character and appearance
of the area.
20. The Approved Scheme acts as a fallback position, but this does not clearly
outweigh all of the harm identified, and neither do any other considerations. I
have not found any very special circumstances that justify the outbuilding.
There are no material considerations that indicate the application should be
determined other than in accordance with the development plan, and for the
reasons given above, I therefore conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
L Douglas
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.