Described on the planning application form as ‘Demolition of existing single storey side extension and erection of two storey side extension and single storey front extension with associated internal works. New access driveway and parking on site also proposed

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Extensions
Character & Appearance
Rural Impact

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 7 August 2020 by Christopher Miell MPlan MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 11th August 2020 Appeal Ref: APP/Y9507/D/20/3247932 6 The Green, Liss GU33 7AP • The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission. • The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Finch against the decision of South Downs National Park Authority. • The application Ref SDNP/19/04298/HOUS, dated 2 September 2019, was refused by notice dated 10 January 2020. • The development proposed is described on the planning application form as ‘Demolition of existing single storey side extension and erection of two storey side extension and single storey front extension with associated internal works. New access driveway and parking on site also proposed.’ Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Procedural Matters 2. The appellant submitted amended plans part way through the determination of the planning application. The amended plans propose a two-storey side extension to the north elevation of the host building and a new access driveway with on-site parking at the front of the site. The demolition of the existing single storey side extension and the erection of a single storey front extension do not form part of the amended proposal. The description of development given on the Council’s decision notice reflects the submission of the amended plans. For the avoidance of doubt, I have determined the appeal on the basis of the amended plans. 3. The appeal form states that the determining Local Planning Authority was East Hampshire District Council. However, the planning application was determined by the South Downs National Park Authority. In the interests of precision, I refer to the South Downs National Park Authority in my Decision and the banner heading above. Main Issue 4. The main issue is whether the proposal adheres to the Authority’s strategy for the extension of existing dwellings in the South Downs National Park and whether or not the proposal would lead to the loss of a small dwelling. Appeal Decision APP/Y9507/D/20/3247932 2 Reasons 5. The appeal property is a detached, two storey, three bedroom dwelling located on the corner of The Green and Station Road within the settlement of Liss. The surrounding area has a suburban character and the appeal site is situated within the South Downs National Park (the ‘SDNP’). 6. The proposal comprises of a two storey side extension and the construction of a new vehicular access on to The Green with on-site parking to the front of the host building. The proposed extension would be constructed from materials to match the host building. 7. Policy SD31 of the South Downs National Park Local Plan 2014-2033 (the ‘SDLP’) seeks to avoid the over-extension of existing dwellings within the SDNP. With respect to the size of extensions and the provision of annexes and outbuildings, criterion 1(a) of the policy states that proposals should not increase the gross internal area (GIA) of the existing dwelling by more than approximately 30%. Proposals which exceed the 30% size limit may be considered acceptable if they are required to accommodate exceptional family needs, such as those arising from disabled or older family members. To justify such a proposal, the application must be supported by robust evidence. 8. The supporting text to Policy SD31 explains that the purpose of the policy is two-fold. The first is to avoid the over extension of existing dwellings, which may have an adverse impact upon the character and appearance of both settlements and the countryside. The second is to maintain a mix of homes consistent with Policy SD27: Mix of Homes of the SDLP, which amongst other things seeks to protect the limited supply of small and medium-sized homes in the National Park. The supporting text to Policy SD27 explains that the Authority’s strategy has been informed by detailed modelling of housing market trends up until 2033, which concludes that the Authority should focus on delivering smaller family housing for younger households. 9. Paragraph 7.92 of the SDLP, part of the supporting text for Policy SD31, explains that the term ‘existing dwelling’ means the residential unit that existed on 18 December 2002 or, if built after that date, as originally built. Where outbuildings have been utilised for ancillary domestic purposes on 18 December 2002, and where the number of outbuildings would be rationalised to improve the appearance of the site, the GIA of the outbuildings may be considered in the assessment of any increase in floor area. 10. Policy SD31 does not explicitly define the term ‘small and medium-sized homes’, but the Council have drawn my attention to Paragraph 7.92 of the SDNP, which states that a ‘small dwelling’ is defined as having a total GIA of 120 square metres or less. 11. However, I note that Paragraph 7.92 of the SDLP relates to proposals which ‘include a net increase in the number of dwellings on the site’. This would not be the case in respect of the current proposal, which relates to the extension of an existing dwelling. Nevertheless, I recognise that the appellant has not disputed the Council’s methodology for determining what constitutes a small dwelling. Therefore, in the absence of any other definition, and having regard to the Council's approach, which aims to provide a consistent baseline to assess whether a proposal would result in the loss of a small dwelling, I am Appeal Decision APP/Y9507/D/20/3247932 3 satisfied that the Authority’s approach and their subsequent application of Policy SD31 is logical and fair. 12. Notwithstanding the above, I note that Policy SD27 of the SDLP seeks to deliver a high proportion of two and three-bedroom dwellings as part of standard occupancy housing developments, to meet the identified need for smaller family housing for younger households. 13. The Authority state that the existing dwelling has a GIA of 97.69 square metres. However, this is disputed by the appellant who argues that the GIA of the existing dwelling is 104.7 square metres. Despite this dispute, both calculations are below 120 square metres or less. 14. Having regard to Policies SD27 and SD31 of the SDLP, as a matter of fact and degree, based on the evidence before me, I consider that the appeal property is a ‘small dwelling’ with three bedrooms, which would likely meet the identified need for smaller family housing for younger households. 15. The appellant explains that if the GIA of an existing garage to the rear of the appeal property is counted as part of the existing dwelling, then the GIA of the existing dwelling would exceed 120 square metres and the appeal property would no longer meet the definition of a small dwelling. However, no substantive evidence has been put forward by the appellant to demonstrate that the outbuilding had been utilised for ancillary domestic purposes on 18 December 2002. Therefore, I am not persuaded that the existing garage formed part of the GIA of the existing dwelling on 18 December 2002. 16. The Authority have calculated that the proposal would increase the GIA of the existing dwelling by approximately 49%. Even if I were to accept the appellant’s higher floorspace calculation of the existing dwelling of 104.7 square metres, the proposal would still greatly exceed the approximate 30% limit for extensions to existing dwellings imposed by Policy SD31 and would increase the number of bedrooms at the dwelling from three to four1. As such, the proposal would result in the loss of a small dwelling within the SDNP. 17. The appellant explains that they have a growing family and that it would be not be feasible for them to move elsewhere. However, no substantive evidence has been put forward to demonstrate that suitable alternative housing in the local area is not available to buy or rent. In addition, I note that the supporting text to Policy SD31 sets out that ‘exceptional family needs’ are typically those arising from disabled or older family members, which does not form part of the appellant’s case. Whilst I understand the appellant’s circumstances, based on the evidence before me, I conclude that exceptional circumstances have not been demonstrated in this case. 18. The appellant contends that the host building could be further extended using permitted development rights and that such works would provide a comparable amount of floorspace in relation to the proposed development. However, no substantive evidence, such as a certificate pursuant to Section 192 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, has been provided to demonstrate that the appellant would genuinely pursue this option if the appeal failed. Therefore, I have afforded this matter limited weight. 1 I recognise that the proposed floorplans (dwg no: P1919.05.REV:A) show three bedrooms and a study on the first floor. However, I see no reason why the ‘study’ could not be used as a bedroom. Indeed, the room is shown as a bedroom on the existing floorplan s (dwg no: P1919.03). Appeal Decision APP/Y9507/D/20/3247932 4 19. I recognise that the Authority concluded that the design of the proposed extension would safeguard the local distinctiveness of the area and the rural character of the SDNP. Nevertheless, these matters do not overcome or outweigh the very weighty conflict with Policy SD31 which seeks to limit the extension of existing properties in order to protect the limited supply of small and medium-sized homes within the SDNP. 20. In conclusion, the proposal would result in the loss of an existing three- bedroom small dwelling for which there is an identified need. Consequently, the proposal would be at odds with the Authority’s strategy for the extension of existing dwellings, which aims to protect the limited supply of small and medium-sized homes within the SDNP by avoiding the over-extension of existing dwellings. As such, the proposal would not accord with Policies SD27 and SD31 of the SDLP. Other Matters 21. The appellant explains that biodiversity improvements would be delivered as part of the proposed development, which would include the installation of bat boxes, bug boxes and wildflowers. In addition, he states that the proposed development has been designed to reduce the energy demands of the appeal property, which would reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Such benefits would not be significant enough to overcome or outweigh my conclusions on the main issue. Conclusion 22. For the reasons given above, and having regard to all other matters raised, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed. Christopher Miell INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →