Hip to gable loft conversion and new porch
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 23 June 2020 by G Sibley MPLAN MRTPI
Decision by Chris Preston BA (Hons) BPl MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 8 July 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/P4605/D/20/3247878
27 Holte Drive, Sutton Coldfield B75 6PR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Martyn Guest against the decision of Birmingham City
Council.
• The application Ref: 2019/10458/PA, dated 18 December 2019, was refused by notice
dated 13 February 2020.
• The development proposed is described on the application form as a hip to gable loft
conversion and new porch.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal Procedure
2. The site visit was undertaken by an Appeal Planning Officer whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard
before deciding the appeal.
Main Issues
3. The effect of the proposed development upon the character and appearance of
the host dwelling and the street scene.
Reasons for the Recommendation
4. Holte Drive is an attractive cul-de-sac of detached houses which is made up
predominantly of two distinct styles of dwellings that share some similar
characteristics. One of those house types is a two-storey detached dwelling
with a gable roof that has a front facing catslide with a first-floor bay window
as well as a pitched roof above a front bay window column. The second is a two
storey detached dwelling with a hipped side facing catslide roof and a two-
storey front bay window column that has a flat roof.
5. No.27 is one of the latter house types and sits towards the head of the cul-de-
sac in a run of four properties of the same design. That is mirrored by a run of
four identical properties on the opposite side of the turning head of the cul-de-
sac which indicates the carefully planned layout of the estate. The two types of
dwellings are a similar height and the roofs of the dwellings are generally
uncluttered and very few dwellings within the street scene have sky lights.
6. The roof profiles are an essential characteristic in the design of the properties
along with the two storey bay windows with hanging tiles to the front and the
Appeal Decision APP/P4605/D/20/3247878
2
harmonious use of building materials. There are other dwellings on Holte Drive
that are designed differently but the two styles described above are the
dominant style of dwellings within the street scene. The dwellings are set
behind front gardens and off-street parking which contributes to the open,
pleasant, suburban appearance of the street scene.
7. The proposed development would include a hip to gable roof extension, as well
as a pitched roof over the front bay window column and three sky lights. A
dormer window is proposed on the rear roof slope as well as a single storey
extension to the existing front porch. The proposed hip to gable roof extension
would substantially change the appearance of the host dwelling and would be
contrary to the advice set out in the of the Extending Your Home
Supplementary Planning Document (Adopted 2007) (SPD) which notes that the
new roof of an extension should match that on the existing building.
8. Whilst there are other houses with gable ends in the street, they are of a
particular design, with long, sweeping cat-slide roofs which help to break up
the mass of the building, such roofs being typical of dwellings within the cul-
de-sac as a whole. In contrast, the roof of the proposed scheme would be of
uniform height and depth. The increased mass of the gable ends would appear
bulky and would contrast awkwardly with the hipped roofs of the properties at
either side of the appeal site. The change in design would also disrupt the
symmetry at the head of the cul-de-sac, on account of the contrast with the
run of properties on the opposite side of the road.
9. In addition, the proposed roof extension would make the roof considerably
taller than the surrounding dwellings, this would make the dwelling appear
unduly dominant within the street scene. Whilst there is a single sky light
already installed within the roof the introduction of two additional sky lights
would make the roof appear cluttered which would detract from the uncluttered
appearance of the roof of the host dwelling. When combined with the taller roof
this would make the dwelling appear overly prominent within the street scene.
10. The window on the first floor is in the centre of the front elevation but because
the of the catslide roof the window appears to be in an appropriate location and
this is mirrored in the other dwellings designed like No.27. The proposed hip to
gable roof extension would remove the catslide roof and consequently the
window would appear off centre which would unbalance the appearance of the
dwelling. Overall, the dwelling would not match either of the two dominant
styles of dwellings within the street. As such, when combined with the other
proposed changes to the dwelling, the dwelling would appear incongruous
within the street scene.
11. There are a number of dwellings that have porches and No.27 itself has a
single storey porch. The proposed extension would add a pitched roof over the
door and would be a relatively minor change to the appearance of the dwelling
and would appear congruous with the host dwelling. The proposed dormer
window would be on the rear roof slope and as such would not be visible from
the street scene. Whilst it would appear relatively large and would dominate
that roof slope, it would not be visible from the roadside and for this reason it
would have a very limited detrimental effect upon the appearance of the host
dwelling and the street scene. The pitched roof over the front bay window
column would be similar in appearance as those used on other dwellings in the
street scene and it would be an appropriate addition to the dwelling.
Appeal Decision APP/P4605/D/20/3247878
3
12. Therefore, the scale of the proposed extension combined with the cluttered
appearance of the roof would cause harm to the character and appearance of
the host dwelling and the street scene. Consequently, the proposed
development would be contrary to policy PG3 of the Birmingham Plan 2031
(adopted 2017) which notes that development should reinforce or create a
positive sense of place and local distinctiveness, with design that responds to
site conditions and the local area context. The proposal would also be contrary
to saved paragraph 3.14-D of the Birmingham Unitary Development Plan 2005
(adopted 1993) which requires development to have regard towards the impact
upon the local character of an area and would be contrary to the guidance set
out in the SPD. The proposal would also be contrary to the National Planning
Policy Framework which notes that permission should be refused for
development of poor design that fails to take advantage of the opportunities
available for improving the character and quality of an area.
13. The appellant contends that the design of the proposed scheme would be more
suitable that an alternative that may be considered under permitted
development. However, no drawings showing any alternative in that respect
have been provided and, consequently, I can give little weight to the suggested
fall-back position.
Conclusion and Recommendation
14. As set out above, I find that the hip to gable extension would cause harm to
the character and appearance of the dwelling and the street scene. Whilst
some elements of the scheme individually would not cause harm, including the
front porch, the addition to the bay window and the rear dormer, the scheme
appears to have been planned and put forward as a whole and it has not been
suggested that a split decision should be issued with some elements allowed
and others dismissed. Some of the alterations may be dependent on other
reconfigurations within the property which would not be possible unless
permission was granted for the whole scheme. Therefore, I have not
recommended that a split decision is appropriate.
15. For the reasons given above and having had regard to all other matters raised,
I recommend that the appeal should be dismissed.
G Sibley
APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER
Inspector’s Decision
16. I have considered all the submitted evidence and the Appeal Planning Officer’s
report, and, on that basis, I agree that the appeal should be dismissed.
Chris Preston
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.