Loft conversion to main house and pool house, with dormers and roof lights. Infill single storey extension linking main house and pool house
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 June 2020
by Graham Chamberlain BA (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 8th June 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/C1570/D/20/3246169
Kevandra House, The Village, Latchmore Bank, Little Hallingbury, Essex
CM22 7PX
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Michael Lowe against the decision of Uttlesford District
Council.
• The application Ref UTT/19/2283/HHF, dated 10 September 2019, was refused by
notice dated 14 November 2019.
• The development proposed is described as ‘Loft conversion to main house and pool
house, with dormers and roof lights. Infill single storey extension linking main house
and pool house.’
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. Works have commenced on some parts of the proposal and they appear well
advanced. In particular, the dormer roof extension to the main dwelling and
the roof extension to the outbuilding, which includes the insertion of two
dormer windows in the northern roof slope and a hip to gable enlargement. No
obvious works have started on the three dormer windows proposed in the
southern roof slope of the outbuilding facing Hatch Green or the replacement of
the conservatory with a larger garden room type structure.
Main Issue
3. The main issue in this appeal is the effect of the proposed development on the
character and appearance of the host property and area.
Reasons
4. The appeal property is a large detached dwelling linked to an extensive
outbuilding by a conservatory. It is set back from the A1060 and positioned
between Silver Birch and Falcon House. There is a public footpath on the far
side of a hedge that runs along the northern side of Latchmore Bank, a small
track that provides access to the appeal site and the other two properties
previously mentioned. Positioned to the south of the appeal site is Hatch
Green, a small housing estate of semi-detached and terraced properties
arranged in a cul-de-sac. The properties in the vicinity of the appeal site are a
mixture of different sizes and designs but they are generally well proportioned
and devoid of excessive, bulky or overly large roof extensions.
Appeal Decision APP/C1570/D/20/3246169
2
5. The dormer window in the rear roof slope of the main dwelling is a bulky and
tall insertion that awkwardly dominates the roof scape of the building. This is
the case even though it does not span the entire width of the roof or exceed
the ridge height and is set above the eaves line. The dummy pitch does little
to disguise the flat roofed form, which appears discordant relative to the shape
of the existing roof. The size and form of the dormer window noticeably jars
with the host property to the extent that its appearance is unbalanced and
harmed. The presence of a large and stark dormer window sets the appeal
property incongruously apart from the surrounding buildings.
6. The impact of the dormer is reduced to a moderate extent due to the use of a
finishing material that complements the roof tiles. Nevertheless, the addition is
in an elevated position and is therefore prominent in views from the public
footpath to the north of the appeal site through gaps in the hedge.
Consequently, this element of the appeal scheme harms the character and
appearance of the area. That said, the roof lights to the front are not unduly
prominent from surrounding vantage points because they are set flush with the
roof and therefore, they do not harm the character and appearance of the area.
7. The three dormer windows proposed to face the properties in Hatch Green
would similarly be large, bulky and tall and thus dominate the roof scape of the
outbuilding. They would be visible from the gap in the street scene between 21
and 22 Hatch Green even though the southern boundary of the appeal site is
marked, in part, by mature trees. In addition, the incongruous proportions and
bulky form of these dormers would also be visible from the rear gardens and
elevations of several properties in Hatch Green. As such, the dormers would
harm the character and appearance of the area.
8. In coming to the findings above, I have carefully considered the Council’s
Supplementary Planning Document ‘Home Extensions’ (2005) and the advice
therein that dominant extensions are unlikely to be compatible with the host
property and its proportions and design. The guidance in the SPD adds weight
to my conclusion that aspects of the appeal scheme harm the character and
appearance of the host property and its environs or would do so.
9. The two dormers inserted into the northern roof slope of the outbuilding are
awkwardly proportioned and oversized relative to the roof plane. They also jar
with the more pleasing size and form of the dormers in the east and west roof
slopes. However, the new dormers are primarily visible from the internal
courtyard and rear garden of the appeal property, with only glimpsed views
possible from the public footpath. This would also be the case with the
proposed garden room extension. Thus, these aspects of the appeal scheme
do not, and would not, harm the character and appearance of the area.
10. The hip to gable extensions to the outbuilding jar with the hipped form of the
existing roof and has resulted in the western elevation presenting large areas
of unarticulated brick work. However, this is not a harmful alteration in this
instance because gable ended roofs are commonplace in the local area and the
eastern and western elevations of the outbuilding are not prominent in public
views or from multiple properties.
11. I therefore conclude that the appeal scheme as a whole would harm the
character and appearance of the host property and area. This would be at
odds with Policies S3, GEN 2 and H8 of the Uttlesford Local Plan 2005 (LP),
Appeal Decision APP/C1570/D/20/3246169
3
which seek to secure development that is compatible with its surroundings and
extensions that respect the scale and design of the original building.
Other Matters
12. The policies of the LP listed above are old, but they are broadly consistent with
Paragraph 127 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the ‘Framework’),
which seeks to secure developments that are visually attractive and
sympathetic to local character. As such, the conflict with Policies S3, GEN 2
and H8 carries significant weight. The proposal would not be using airspace
above the building to create a new home so the guidance in Paragraph 118 of
the Framework regarding this point is not directly relevant to the appeal
scheme. In any event, the appeal scheme as a whole is not well designed and
does not comply with local design policies.
13. Planning permission was granted under application UTT/1845/03/FUL for
extensions to the appeal property. This permission has since lapsed without
being implemented. As such, it does not represent a fall-back position and is
therefore a material consideration of very limited weight. The evidence before
me does not demonstrate the harmful elements of the proposal are essential in
order to provide a fully accessible annex in the outbuilding.
14. The dormer extensions at Orchard End and Crabhayne referred to by the
appellant do not appear to have the same proportions as the dormers
advanced in the appeal scheme and they do not dominate the roof plane in the
same way as the appeal scheme does (would). As such, they do not justify the
harm I have identified.
15. Various concerns have been raised by interested parties including reservations
regarding the effect on the living conditions of neighbours. That said, I note
that the Council has not included this as a reason for refusal and I am satisfied,
based on the evidence before me, that the extensions are (or would be)
sufficiently distant from neighbouring houses, including being set back from
shared boundaries, to ensure the appeal scheme has not (and would not)
resulted in the occupiers of neighbouring properties being subject to a harmful
loss of light, outlook or privacy.
Conclusion
16. The proposed development would be contrary to the development plan and
there are no other considerations which outweigh this finding. Accordingly, for
the reasons given, the appeal should not succeed.
Graham Chamberlain
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.