Described as, “Retrospective Planning Application submission for the rear patio carried out during the works of the approved front and rear extension and internal reorganisation of 51 Yarnell’s Hill (application No
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 23 June 2020 by Alex O’Doherty LLB(Hons) MSc
Decision by R C Kirby BA (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 19 August 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/V3120/D/19/3243832
51 Yarnells Hill, Oxford OX2 9BE
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Alden against the decision of Vale of White Horse District
Council.
• The application Ref P19/V0184/HH, dated 17 January 2019, was refused by notice
dated 23 October 2019.
• The development proposed is described as, “Retrospective Planning Application
submission for the rear patio carried out during the works of the approved front and
rear extension and internal reorganisation of 51 Yarnell’s Hill (application No.
P17/V2719/HH).”
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed insofar as it relates to the raised level of the strip of
ground situated between the patio and the site's northern boundary which was
carried out during the works of the approved front and rear extension
(application No. P17/V2719/HH), and the proposed erection of a timber fence
on the northern boundary at a height of 1.8 metres from the rising ground
level.
2. The appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to the rear patio, and the
amendments to the rear extension approved by planning permission
P17/V2719/HH, and the insertion of a first floor, en-suite window in the rear
elevation of the dwelling, and planning permission is granted for the rear patio,
and the amendments to the rear extension approved by planning permission
P17/V2719/HH, and the insertion of a first floor, en-suite window in the rear
elevation of the dwelling at 51 Yarnells Hill, Oxford OX2 9BE in accordance with
the terms of the application, Ref P19/V0184/HH, dated 17 January 2019, and
subject to the following conditions:
1) Insofar as it relates to the matters approved by this decision, the development
hereby permitted has been carried out in accordance with the details shown on
the following drawing: P.1358 085 Rev F – DECISION.
2) The first floor obscure glazed window hereby permitted shall remain obscure
glazed and top hung at all times.
3) The green screen shown on drawing P.1358 085 Rev F – DECISION shall not be
cut down, uprooted, destroyed, pruned, cut or damaged in any manner without
the prior written approval of the local planning authority.
4) If the green screen shown on drawing P.1358 085 Rev F – DECISION is cut
down, uprooted or destroyed or dies another green screen shall be planted at
Appeal Decision APP/V3120/D/19/3243832
2
the same place and that green screen shall be of such size and species and
shall be planted, in accordance with condition 3, at such time as may be
specified in writing by the local planning authority.
Appeal Procedure
3. The site visit was undertaken by an Appeal Planning Officer whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard
before deciding the appeal.
Procedural Matters
4. The application form describes the proposal as stated in the banner heading
above. However, the appeal form describes the proposal as, “Retrospective
planning application submission for the rear patio and raised level of the strip
of ground situated between the patio and the site's northern boundary which
was carried out during the works of the approved front and rear extension
(application No. P17/V2719/HH). Proposed erection of a timber fence on the
northern boundary at a height of 1.8 metres from the rising ground level”. The
Council’s decision notice also refers to, “amendments to the rear extension
approved by planning permission P17/V2719/HH, and the insertion of a first
floor, en-suite window in the rear elevation of the dwelling”.
5. The description given in the appeal form, combined with the text referred to
from the Council’s decision notice, more accurately describes the proposal.
However, as ‘retrospective’ is not an act of development, this text has been
removed. The appeal has been considered on the basis of this revised
description. For the avoidance of doubt, this is: “planning application
submission for the rear patio and raised level of the strip of ground situated
between the patio and the site's northern boundary which was carried out
during the works of the approved front and rear extension (application No.
P17/V2719/HH). Proposed erection of a timber fence on the northern boundary
at a height of 1.8 metres from the rising ground level. Amendments to the rear
extension approved by planning permission P17/V2719/HH, and the insertion of
a first floor, en-suite window in the rear elevation of the dwelling.”
6. The Council issued a split decision. As per section 79(1)(b) of the Town and
Country Planning Act 1990, this appeal is not restricted to dealing with only the
elements which the Council refused. However, it is clear from the Council’s
decision that it has no objection to the amendments to the rear extension
approved by planning permission P17/V2719/HH, and the insertion of a first
floor, en-suite window in the rear elevation of the dwelling, and I have no
evidence before me to reach a contrary view to the Council in this regard.
Therefore, the consideration of this appeal focuses on the effect of the rear
patio, the raised level of the strip of ground situated between the patio and the
site's northern boundary, and the proposed timber fence. I am satisfied that
the amendments to the rear extension, and the insertion of a first floor, en-
suite window in the rear elevation of the dwelling, are clearly severable from
the remainder of the proposal.
7. The main parties were asked for their observations as to whether or not the
raised level of the strip of ground situated between the patio and the site's
northern boundary (including the retaining wall) is clearly severable, both
physically and functionally, from the patio. The appellant confirmed that these
elements are severable, both physically and functionally. As I have no evidence
Appeal Decision APP/V3120/D/19/3243832
3
to indicate otherwise, I have assessed the proposal on the basis that those
elements are clearly severable.
8. At my site visit I saw that a patio and a retaining wall had already been
constructed, and a green screen was in place that was a similar height to that
proposed. A fence had been constructed on the boundary between Nos 51 and
49 Yarnells Hill, but I observed that its height was lower than that proposed in
this appeal. The appeal proposal is therefore partly retrospective and I have
assessed it on that basis.
Main Issue
9. The main issue is the effect of the patio, the raised level of the strip of ground
situated between the patio and the site's northern boundary, and the proposed
fence, on the living conditions of the occupants of No 49 Yarnells Hill (‘No 49’),
with particular reference to privacy, outlook, sunlight, and daylight.
Reasons for the Recommendation
Privacy
10. This appeal involves development to the rear of No 51 Yarnells Hill (‘No 51’). As
this part of Yarnells Hill slopes downwards from south to north, the slab level of
the appeal property is approximately 1.3m higher than the slab level of No 49.
The new patio is set off the party boundary with No 49 and is at a lower level
than the host property. It is however set at a higher level than the dwelling at
No 49 and the area of rear garden closest to it. Near the party boundary are
French doors serving the living room of No 49, and a short patio is beyond this
that leads to a fairly expansive garden.
11. Although the patio area extends beyond the rear elevation of No 49, I am
satisfied that given its level relative to the rear windows and garden of this
property that users of it would be unlikely to have clear views of the rear of No
49, given the landscaping that has been planted along the edge of the patio,
which could be secured by planning conditions.
12. However, from the extended pathway on the raised strip of ground located
between the patio and the boundary with No 49, I observed that clear views of
a substantial portion of No 49’s garden and patio were possible. Additionally, it
was possible to see through the windows into the living room of No 49. The
proposed fence would eliminate this harm caused to the occupants of No 49, in
terms of overlooking.
13. Whilst the new fence would not completely obscure the view to the nearest
upper-room window of No 49 when viewed from the pathway, I am satisfied
that due to the height and set-back of that window, that it would not usually be
in view for users of that path, and therefore a loss of privacy to this window
would be unlikely to occur. Moreover, any views to that window would be of a
frequency tolerated in a residential area such as this.
14. As such, the scheme is acceptable in relation to matters of privacy and
accordingly the living conditions of the occupiers of No 49 are not harmed in
this respect, subject to landscaping being secured on the northern boundary of
the patio. In this respect, there is no conflict with Development Policy 23 of the
Vale of White Horse Local Plan 2031 Part 2 – Detailed Policies and Additional
Sites (adopted 10 October 2019) (‘Local Plan’), which seeks to prevent
Appeal Decision APP/V3120/D/19/3243832
4
significant adverse impacts on the amenity of neighbouring uses in relation to
loss of privacy.
Outlook
15. The rear garden at No 49 is a pleasant space, in part because the majority of
the boundary between Nos 51 and 49 is composed of hedging and shrubbery.
The new retaining wall, composed of red brick masonry and approximately
1.3m high, is not an imposing feature, and accordingly is acceptable on its
own.
16. However, the total height of the retaining wall and the fence combined would
be approximately 3 metres, when measured from No 49’s patio. The fence,
when seen in the context of the side elevation of the host property facing No
49, which consists of a blank wall, would appear overly-dominant, materially
detracting from the pleasantness of the garden at No 49, and harming the
outlook from it and particularly from the patio area to the rear of this property.
Moreover, the fence would be significantly overbearing on the outlook from the
living room windows in the rear elevation of No 49. The fence would be a
dominant, intrusive feature which would be likely to make this room less
pleasant to use. A condition specifying a minimum and maximum height of the
hedge would not mitigate the harm to outlook, due to the scale and position of
the proposed fence, nor would an alternative design of the fence.
17. Therefore, the proposal would cause material harm to the living conditions of
the occupants of No 49, with respect to outlook. In this respect, the proposal
conflicts with Development Policy 23 of the Local Plan, which seeks to prevent
significant adverse impacts on the amenity of neighbouring uses in relation to
dominance or visual intrusion. The proposal would also conflict with the
guidance given in the Vale of White Horse Design Guide 2015 that proposals
should not have an adverse impact on neighbouring properties in relation to
oppressive or overbearing impacts.
18. As the fence, which is unacceptable, is the only method proposed to prevent
overlooking from the raised strip of ground between the patio and the site’s
northern boundary treatment, it follows that the raised strip of ground element
of the proposal is also unacceptable.
Sunlight & daylight
19. The fairly substantial tree cover in the garden close to the rear of No 49 would
be likely to affect the amount of sunlight that the rear of the property receives.
Due to this, and that the retaining wall and the fence would not be in the direct
path of the sun, the effect of the proposal on sunlight would be minimal. The
proposal as a whole, but particularly the fence, would result in some loss of
daylight, because it would result in a solid mass where there was none
previously. I consider however that the reduction would not be enough to
cause material harm to the living conditions of the occupiers of No 49, due to
the existing built features at the host property and the existing landscaping. In
this respect, the scheme complies with Development Policy 23 of the Local
Plan, which seeks to prevent significant adverse impacts on the amenity of
neighbouring uses in relation to loss of daylight or sunlight.
Appeal Decision APP/V3120/D/19/3243832
5
Conditions
20. I have considered the conditions found in the Council’s decision notice against
the advice on conditions set out in the National Planning Policy Framework and
the Planning Practice Guidance. Considering the planning history of the site, a
condition is necessary specifying the approved plan, to provide certainty. A
condition is necessary to ensure that the first floor window at No 51 remains
obscure glazed and top hung, to safeguard the living conditions of the
occupants of No 49. Conditions are also necessary to control the landscaping
along the edge of the patio, to safeguard the living conditions of the occupants
of No 49, with respect to privacy.
Other Matters
21. Whilst the patio and associated works, and the new fencing, would not
constitute overdevelopment, and would have a minimal impact on the visual
appearance of the host property and the local area, this does not overcome the
harm identified in terms of outlook.
22. It is recognised that the proposed fence would provide a barrier between the
appeal site and No 49, thus contributing to the safety of users of the patio,
including children. However, there is no evidence before me to suggest that a
less harmful scheme could not achieve the same aims. The proposal would
modernise the existing property and assist in meeting the needs of the
appellant’s family. However, this would offer mainly private benefits. Thus, I
give these considerations little weight.
23. It has been suggested that a comparable development could be carried out
under The Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development)
(England) Order 2015 (as amended). However, as only limited details have
been provided it is not possible to ascertain whether such development would
be more harmful than the appeal scheme, and therefore limited weight is given
to this matter.
24. Whilst I have found the proposal to be acceptable in terms of privacy, sunlight,
and daylight, this does not overcome the conflict with the development plan
with respect to outlook. Overall, I find that the matters advanced in support of
the proposal, do not, either individually or collectively, outweigh the harm
identified, nor the conflict with the development plan.
Conclusion and Recommendation
25. Based on the above, and having regard to all matters raised, I recommend that
the appeal is dismissed insofar as it relates to the raised level of the strip of
ground situated between the patio and the site's northern boundary which was
carried out during the works of the approved front and rear extension
(application No. P17/V2719/HH), and the proposed erection of a timber fence
on the northern boundary at a height of 1.8 metres from the rising ground
level, and that the appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to the rear patio, and
the amendments to the rear extension approved by planning permission
P17/V2719/HH, and the insertion of a first floor, en-suite window in the rear
elevation of the dwelling.
Alex O’Doherty APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER
Appeal Decision APP/V3120/D/19/3243832
6
Inspector’s Decision
26. I have considered all the submitted evidence and the Appeal Planning Officer’s
report and on that basis a split decision is issued dismissing the raised level of
the strip of ground situated between the patio and the site's northern boundary
which was carried out during the works of the approved front and rear
extension (application No. P17/V2719/HH), and the proposed erection of a
timber fence on the northern boundary at a height of 1.8 metres from the
rising ground level, and the appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to the rear
patio, and the amendments to the rear extension approved by planning
permission P17/V2719/HH, and the insertion of a first floor, en-suite window in
the rear elevation of the dwelling.
R C Kirby
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.