Erection of two storey wrap around extension and second floor extension. Alterations to roof pitch and fenestration
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 23 June 2020
by M Seaton DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 7 July 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/E2734/D/19/3243273
37 Burn Bridge Road, Burn Bridge, Harrogate, HG3 1PB
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Andrew North against the decision of Harrogate Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 19/03763/FUL, dated 3 September 2019, was refused by notice
dated 5 November 2019.
• The development proposed is the erection of two storey wrap around extension and
second floor extension. Alterations to roof pitch and fenestration.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. The Harrogate District Local Plan 2014 - 2035 (the Local Plan) was adopted in
March 2020. As a consequence, Policy SG4 of the Harrogate District Core
Strategy 2009, and saved Policies H15 & HD20 of the Harrogate District Local
Plan 2001: Saved Policy Version – Sept 2007, have been superseded. However,
it is noted that the reasons for refusal included reference to policies from the
emerging Local Plan.
3. Further to the receipt of confirmation from the Council of the Inspector’s Final
Report concluding the emerging Local Plan was sound subject to main
modifications, the appellant and Council were provided with the opportunity to
comment on the timetable leading to the adoption of the Local Plan. However,
no further comments have been received and the emerging policies, subject to
any modifications, have subsequently been adopted. I have therefore
determined the appeal on the basis of the updated Development Plan.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are;
• The effect of the proposed development on the character and appearance of
the street scene and the host dwelling; and
• whether the proposed development would safeguard the living conditions of
the neighbouring occupiers of No. 35 Burn Bridge Road, having regard to
outlook and loss of light.
Appeal Decision APP/E2734/D/19/3243273
2
Reasons
5. The appeal site is occupied by a detached bungalow set back on the north-
eastern side of Burn Bridge Road and positioned within a line of dwellings,
which are predominantly two-storey in scale. The property possesses a rear
garden beyond which are the curtilages of further dwellings on Burn Bridge
Oval.
6. During the course of the appeal, planning permission (LPA Ref: 20/00507/FUL)
dated 11 May 2020 has been approved for the demolition of the existing
garage, erection of a two-storey wrap-around extension, and raising of the roof
to form an additional floor of living space, as well as alterations to the
fenestration and the formation of a hardstanding. This proposal is extant and
capable of implementation and sets a baseline for the assessment of the appeal
proposals.
Character and appearance
7. I observed the existing single-storey dwelling to appear as an uncharacteristic
design and scale of development within the street scene between Nos. 25–41
Burn Bridge Road where 2-storey dwellings finished with brick and render are
prevalent.
8. The proposed extensions would result in an uncharacteristically designed two-
storey dwelling which would appear as a departure from the design approach
and appearance of existing development in the immediate vicinity. The
inclusion of a prominent asymmetric gable roof and incorporation of a balcony
feature on the front elevation are aspects of the proposed design that would
appear as uncharacteristic features when considered in the context of the
street scene. Whilst I acknowledge that the asymmetry of the gable remains
within the approved scheme, it is incorporated as an element of the overall
design rather than being the defining feature and focus of the proposal.
9. I recognise that the insertion of a building exhibiting a more contemporary
design approach and involving a departure from the prevailing character and
use of materials within the area would not be without precedent within the
wider area. However, despite there being a certain degree of variety in terms
of detailed design and overall scale of dwelling along Burn Bridge Road, there
remain some unifying design factors particularly with regards the
characteristics of the roofs, which the proposed dwelling would not reflect. In
this regard, the appeal proposal would represent such a significant departure
from existing development as to be obtrusive in design terms within the street
scene.
10. Turning to the impact on the host building, it is inevitable that the proposed
extensions in adding an additional floor would significantly alter the character
and appearance of the dwelling, and I would not therefore disagree with the
Council’s assessment that the existing character of the dwelling would be lost.
Nevertheless, even allowing for my conclusion that the existing dwelling does
not make a positive contribution within the streetscene, the extent of the
proposed extensions would be substantial and I would agree with the Council
that in particular the bulk and massing of the side of the property would be
significant and harmful in this regard.
Appeal Decision APP/E2734/D/19/3243273
3
11. For these reasons, I am satisfied that the proposed development would result
in an adverse effect on the character and appearance of the street scene and
the host dwelling. There would therefore be conflict with Policies HP3 and HS8
of the Local Plan, which seek to ensure that development incorporates high
quality building design that protects, enhances or reinforces local
distinctiveness, and that extensions to dwellings be permitted where there is
no adverse impact to the character or appearance of the dwelling or the
surrounding area.
Living conditions
12. I observed that No. 35 Burn Bridge Road is set at a slightly higher level than
the appeal site, with the Council indicating a ground level difference of
approximately 400mm. The Council has indicated that the extent and depth of
the proposed extensions to the dwelling, when considered in conjunction with
the impact of the retained garage structure, would undoubtedly have an impact
on the neighbouring property with regards the perception of a sense of
enclosure close to the boundary which would not currently be experienced.
Given the two-storey form of the resultant dwelling and orientation from the
neighbouring property, there would also be an increased potential for
overshadowing.
13. I have carefully considered the Council’s reasoning and have noted that in
assessing the impact of the sense of enclosure it is the accumulation of the
proposed extensions and existing garage structure that is concluded to have
the adverse impact. However, whilst both the Council’s assessment and rather
confusingly the appellant’s Grounds of Appeal reflect on the retention of the
garage, this is not what is in fact shown on the proposed site plan. The plans
submitted by the Council with the appeal as used to determine the planning
application, show a garage incorporated within the ground floor layout of the
resultant dwelling and indicate that the existing garage is to be demolished. I
am mindful that the demolition of the garage was included within the
description of development for the approved scheme but has not been in this
instance. Nevertheless, it would appear in the absence of any further
clarification that an incorrect basis for assessment has been utilised in
concluding on the cumulative impacts.
14. Despite this, even allowing for the discounting of the garage from the
assessment, I would agree with the Council’s conclusion that the depth and
scale of the proposed extensions in close proximity to the boundary with No. 35
Burn Bridge Road would result in an adverse impact on the neighbouring rear
windows and garden having regard to both a sense of enclosure and
overshadowing. Whilst I recognise that some landscaping is in place on the
common boundary, this would not provide a significant degree of screening or
mitigate the level of impact, nor would the difference in ground levels.
15. In addition to the above assessment, I have also considered the relationship
between the appeal proposals and the neighbouring property at No. 39 Burn
Bridge Road, as well as with properties to the rear on Burn Bridge Oval.
16. Having observed the relationship with the neighbouring properties, I accept
that the proposed extensions would result in a significant alteration from the
current relationship with the single-storey dwelling. However, due to the
position of the neighbouring dwelling at No. 39 Burn Bridge Road, the presence
of existing extensions and significant boundary walling, and noting the position
Appeal Decision APP/E2734/D/19/3243273
4
of windows, I am satisfied that the proposed extensions would not result in an
unacceptable impact on living conditions. Similarly, whilst the resultant two-
storey dwelling would undoubtedly change the relationship with properties to
the rear on Burn Bridge Oval due to its scale and increased proximity to the
shared boundary, I am also not persuaded in this instance that this would be
so significant as to warrant the dismissal of the appeal for this reason.
17. On the basis of the above reasoning, I must conclude that the proposed
development would fail to safeguard the living conditions of the neighbouring
occupiers of No. 35 Burn Bridge Road, having regard to outlook and loss of
light. The proposal would not accord with Policies HP4 and HS8 of the Local
Plan which seek to ensure that development proposals are designed to protect
amenity considerations including overbearing impacts of development and loss
of light, and that extensions to dwellings do not result in an adverse impact on
neighbouring residential amenity.
Conclusion
18. For these reasons, the appeal is dismissed.
Martin Seaton
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.