Demolition of existing detached garage and construction of two storey side/rear extension with extension to roof above, single storey extension to front and single storey extension to rear (resubmission further to 18/00856/FUL)
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Highways & Transport
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 January 2020
by Matthew Woodward BA (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 27th January 2020
Appeal Ref: APP/G4240/D/19/3241129
12 Kenilworth Grove, Audenshaw M34 5RZ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Zain Gani against the decision of Tameside Metropolitan
Borough Council.
• The application Ref 19/00527/FUL, dated 27 June 2019, was refused by notice dated
22 August 2019.
• The development proposed is described as ‘demolition of existing detached garage and
construction of two storey side/rear extension with extension to roof above, single
storey extension to front and single storey extension to rear (resubmission further to
18/00856/FUL)’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. Amended plans were submitted with the appeal which remove a projecting
gable roof form feature and increase the internal width of the proposed garage1
in comparison with the plans which the Council considered when determining
the application. Furthermore, the amended plans have not been subject to
consultation with interested parties. Nevertheless, the amendments are
relatively minor in nature and would not prejudice the interests of interested
parties. Therefore, I have determined the appeal on the basis of the amended
plans.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are the effects of the proposed development on:
• The character and appearance of the area; and,
• Highway safety having regard to on-street parking.
1 Amended plans entitled ‘Existing Floor Plans Existing & Proposed Elevations’ Rev E and ‘Proposed Floor Plans’ Rev
E
Appeal Decision APP/G4240/D/19/3241129
2
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The appeal site is a semi-detached house in a street of properties with a similar
character. It adjoins 10 Kenilworth Grove and lies adjacent to 14 Kenilworth
Grove and, like other properties on the street, has a hipped roof with a
prominent front facing gable element, along with bay windows. The building
line on each side of the street is regimented and there are gaps between each
pair of semi-detached houses. Various alterations and extensions are apparent
to properties in the vicinity, including side extensions, but the street retains its
identity and uniform character.
5. The proposed side extension at first floor would be aligned with the front
elevation of the appeal dwelling and slightly set back from the projecting bay
window. The extended ground floor would include a small projection which
would extend beyond the front elevation of the appeal dwelling, generally in
line with the bay window. The projection to the side would ensure a gap of
1.23m between the extension and the side boundary of No 14.
6. The appellant has drawn my attention to an existing two-storey extension at
1 Kenilworth Grove and I had the opportunity to view it from the street on my
site visit2. Like the extension at No 1, the proposal does not include a setback
from the front of the main dwelling and, save for variations in the fenestration
design and disposition, there are clear parallels between the appeal proposal
and No 1 in terms of their overall design and form. However, the dwelling at
No 1 occupies an angular plot at the end of a short stretch of semi’s and lies
some distance from the adjacent property. Therefore, it does not correspond
with the prevailing character of the built form close to the appeal site, which
comprises well balanced pairs of semi-detached dwellings.
7. The Tameside Residential Design Supplementary Planning Document, March
2010 (SPD) provides guidance for household extensions. Policy RED 1 of the
SPD requires extensions to acknowledge the character of the house, whilst
Policy RED 5 sets out more detailed guidance for side extensions, including that
they should be designed with a minimum setback of 0.5m from the main
façade. In this regard, the development would not accord with the SPD.
8. Due to the lack of set-back from the existing dwelling and the continuous roof
form that would arise from the extension, it would not appear subordinate to
the existing dwelling and it would be un sympathetic to its original size and
scale. Although a gap to the side boundary would be provided in excess of that
stated by the SPD , if the neighbouring property was extended in a similar
manner to the proposal , it would result in a prominent and homogenous built
form which would lack sufficient visual relie f, thus the pairs of semi’s would
lose their semblance of individuality . Consequently, I find that the extension
would appear overly dominant and would disrupt the regular rhythm of
development on the street.
2 Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council planning reference – 14/00518/FUL
Appeal Decision APP/G4240/D/19/3241129
3
9. I appreciate that the gap between the appea l dwelling and No 14 is greater
than some of the other gaps between semi’s on the street. Furthermore, the
relatively inconspicuou s alteration to the proposed roof pitch in comparison
with the existing roof pitch is not objectionable in itself. However, these
considerations do not adequately compensate for the visual harm which would
arise due to the scale of the proposed extension which would not appear
ancillary to the main dwelling, to the detriment of the street-scene.
10. In conclusion therefore, the development would harm the character and
appearance of the area. It would conflict with Policy H10 of the Tameside
Unitary Development Plan 2004 (UDP) and Policies RED 1 and RED 5 of the
SPD which require, amongst other matters, that developments complement or
enhance the character and appearance of the surrounding area by ensuring
that extensions acknowledge the existing house and reduce the terracing
effect.
Highway safety
11. Kenilworth Grove is a cul-de-sac which has a narrow carriageway. The thrust
of the Council’s contention is that the proposal to increase the number of
bedrooms in the appeal dwelling from three to four would result in an
unacceptable level of harm to pedestrian and highway safety.
12. Both main parties agree that whilst the proposed integral garage would be
larger than the existing detached garage, it would be narrower than the 3m
internal garage width requirement set out in Policy RED 12 of the SPD.
Furthermore, the garage would be set forwards of the existing, thus reducing
the amount of parking space available between the highway and front of the
garage. However, I could see on my site visit that the existing space available
is so diminutive that it makes the parking of a vehicle wholly within the
curtilage of the property impractical. Consequently, the proposal would have
no effect on the displacement of cars onto the road, as the garage and existing
space within the curtilage of the property do not appear to provide a useable
space to park cars. However, if car ownership within the appeal property was
to increase, there would be a strong likelihood that those vehicles would have
to park on the street.
13. I observed on my site visit that Kenilworth Grove was lightly trafficked. On-
street parking was sporadic, and it was commonplace to see cars parked on the
footway. Other vehicles were parked on the driveway of properties partially
overhanging the footway. I accept that the parking arrangement in the area is
less than ideal, but the footway appeared wide enough for cars to park on it
whilst allowing pedestrians to safely pass.
14. Whilst I undertook my site visit during mid-morning and outside the morning
and afternoon ‘peak’, I did not find that the street suffered unduly from parking
stress. The Council have not included any evidence with their submissions
relating to the levels of parking on the surrounding streets, nor how the
proposal itself would result in unacceptable highway safety impacts. Moreover,
there is no guidance contained in the SPD or UDP setting out parking standards
in relation to this form of development, nor is there any evidence before me to
suggest how the proposal to provide one additional bedroom would result in
unacceptable levels of parking stress over and above the existing situation. On
this basis, I am not persuaded that the proposal would be detrimental to
highway safety.
Appeal Decision APP/G4240/D/19/3241129
4
15. Despite the Council refusing a previous application which proposed a total of
five bedrooms in the appeal property3, that was a different application the
details of which are not for me to determine as part of this appeal.
Furthermore, contrary to the Council’s concerns, there is nothing on the
submitted plans to suggest that the development would provide more
bedrooms than is being applied for, and I am unable to give significant weight
to a future scenario based mainly on conjecture.
16. Therefore, for the foregoing reasons I find that the development would not
unacceptably affect highway safety having regard to parking provision. The
proposal would comply with the requirements of Policy H10 by ensuring
suitable arrangements for parking and access would not unacceptably impact
the surrounding highway network. There would be no loss of parking in
accordance with Policy RED 12 of the SPD and any increase in parking on-
street would not lead to unacceptable highway safety impacts, in accordance
with paragraph 109 of the National Planning Policy Framework.
Other Matters
17. I have taken into account representations received relating to the potential for
the proposal to impact on the living conditions of nearby occupants by reason
of overshadowing, loss of light and overlooking . I note that t hese concerns
were not included as a reason for refusal by the Council and as stated in the
Council’s officer report, the extension would exceed the spacing standards set
out in the SPD. I am also satisfied that the development would be sufficient
distance from the nearest properties so as not to unduly affect the living
conditions of occupants.
18. I have considered several other examples of extensions in the surrounding area
which the appellant has referred me to. However, I do not have the full details
of those cases and I am not satisfied that they are directly comparable to the
scheme before me given the relationship between the appeal dwelling and the
surrounding properties, and the visual harm I have identified.
19. Whilst the extended dwelling would allow additional space, creating a larger
family home, in connection with one extended dwelling, these benefits are
limited in scope and do not outweigh the harm I have identified.
Conclusion
20. Whilst I find that the effect on the number of vehicles parked on the street
would not be substantially altered to the detriment of highway safety, I find
that the development would have an unacceptable impact on the character and
appearance of the area. Therefore, the appeal is dismissed.
Matthew Woodward
INSPECTOR
3 Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council planning reference – 18/00856/FUL
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.