To erect a replacement domestic garage
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Policy Weight
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 September 2018
by Geoff Underwood BA(Hons) PGDip(Urb Cons) MRTPI IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 5 November 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/D2510/D/18/3199711
Barnaby Cottage, Moat Lane, Old Bolingbroke, Spilsby, Lincolnshire
PE23 4HH
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr P Bogg against the decision of East Lindsey District Council.
The application Ref S/018/02107/17, dated 10 November 2017, was refused by notice
dated 15 January 2018.
The development proposed is to erect a replacement domestic garage.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. Since the Council made their decision and the appeal was made the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) has been revised and the East
Lindsey Local Plan – Core Strategy, 2018 (CS) has been adopted. The appeal
must be determined on the basis of the development plan as it exists at the
time of my decision and I have taken these changes into account in
determining the appeal. Both main parties are aware of the changes and have
had the opportunity to comment on the implications of the revised Framework
and new development plan.
3. The Council’s refusal reasons include that they consider that appellant has not
provided appropriate information in respect of the proposed development’s
effects on non-designated heritage assets. However, the Council have not
explicitly identified any non-designated heritage assets which they consider
would be affected, only designated ones. I have determined the appeal on that
basis.
Main Issue
4. Therefore, the main issue raised by this appeal is the effect the development
would have on the significance of designated heritage assets including whether
sufficient information has been provided to understand the potential impact of
the proposal on their significance.
Reasons
5. The appeal site is a plot of land situated opposite a pair of semi-detached
houses. The site contains a prefabricated type garage in a partly dilapidated
condition and a small brick outbuilding. At the time of my visit the site had
Appeal Decision APP/D2510/D/18/3199711
2
been cleared to the rear of the existing garage but was heavily overgrown
adjacent to Moat Lane. The proposal would replace the current garage with
one which would be longer, extending farther into the site than the present
arrangement. Although the proposed drawings show the garage being built on
a flat site, from my observations it would extend beyond the position of the
existing gable into that part of the site which slopes down towards the rear
boundary.
6. Bolingbroke Castle (the Castle) lies immediately to the south of the site. This
is a grade I listed building and a Scheduled Ancient Monument (SAM),
classifications that the Framework identifies as designated assets of the highest
significance.
7. The appellant advises that the site does not fall within the scheduled area,
pointing to existing boundaries with hedges. The Council are of the view that
the site may extend into the scheduled area. The scale of the plan
accompanying the Heritage List for England (HLE) entry for the SAM and the
relatively small size of the site means that on the basis of the information
before me it is not certain whether the application site lies wholly outside the
SAM boundary. Existing site boundaries may not necessarily reflect the extent
of the SAM. However even if all of the site is outside the scheduled area it
would be surrounded on three sides by the SAM.
8. The site slopes down towards the moat feature of the SAM. The HLE entry
notes the architectural remains and earthworks survive in good condition and it
is a nationally rare example of an enclosed castle with the added historic
significance as being known as the birthplace of King Henry IV. Part of this
significance is derived from the moat feature and from its immediate setting
which includes the appeal site. The County Council’s Historic Environment
Officer considers that the site is in an area of high archaeological interest,
including being near a possible medieval kiln site and the HLE entry notes that
waterlogging in the area of the moat indicates the likely survival of organic
remains.
9. The significance the Castle derives from its setting is not only through a historic
and visual relationship with the village of Old Bolingbroke which partly
surrounds it but also with features, landforms and the potential for buried
archaeology. The site is one in which the setting of the Castle can be
experienced and understood, including potentially from buried archaeology,
and this is not necessarily only reliant on a visual relationship. Consequently
the site occupies a particularly sensitive location in respect of the setting of the
Castle and the area’s historic environment.
10. The appellant’s assumption that any archaeological value on the site was lost
when a former cottage on the site was constructed, subsequently demolished
and the garage erected is not supported by a detailed assessment or evaluation
of the site and the contribution it makes to designated heritage assets.
Although old photographs have been provided, the exact position and extent of
the cottage in relation to the site, the proposed garage and the Castle have not
been ascertained. It is not possible to conclude purely on the basis that part of
the site was occupied by a cottage and the subsequent garage that any buried
features of interest would necessarily have been lost or disturbed.
11. As the proposed garage would occupy a materially larger footprint than the
existing and project into the sloped part of the site, even by a limited amount,
Appeal Decision APP/D2510/D/18/3199711
3
it cannot be concluded on the basis of the information provided that buried
archaeology would not be adversely affected. In the particular circumstances
of the site and proposed development it would be reasonable to take a
precautionary approach. For the same reason it has not been satisfactorily
demonstrated that the significance that the Castle derives from its setting and
from features including the moat would not be harmed. Similarly, there is the
potential for other evidence to be present, perhaps not directly related to the
Castle but to the historic character of Old Bollingbroke Conservation Area.
12. Therefore a level of detail, proportionate to the assets’ importance has not
been provided and that limited amount which has been is insufficient to
understand the potential impact of the proposal on their significance. As such
the development would not accord with the Framework’s approach to
understanding effects on significance. The Framework goes on to point out
that where a development site has the potential to include heritage assets with
archaeological interest, local planning authorities should require developers to
submit an appropriate desk-based assessment and, where necessary, a field
evaluation.
13. I am conscious that this was not requested by the Council when considering
the application as the Framework requires. Nevertheless, without a
proportionate assessment of the Castle’s significance, including any
contribution the site made by its setting, it is not possible to assess what the
likely effect of development would be. The development would be contrary to
paragraph 189 of the Framework.
14. Extensive vegetation along the boundary limits intervisibility between the site
and the earthworks and stonework of the Castle, although glimpses are
possible and could be more extensive when trees and hedges are not in leaf.
The slightly larger garage has the potential to be more noticeable than the
existing one from the Castle especially when overgrown foliage engulfing the
front of the site and existing structure is removed to necessitate demolition and
construction. The effects of a relatively modest scale, traditionally constructed
garage with a pitched roof may be limited in terms of the significance the
Castle derives visually in the context of the variety of buildings in the village
including those along Moat Lane. However this considers only one component
of the significance the Castle derives from its setting and does not override the
need for an appropriate understanding of significance.
15. Much of the Conservation Area’s significance is derived from the historic
townscape of older buildings interspersed with newer ones, arranged in an
irregular street pattern around landmark heritage assets including the Castle.
In this context the appearance of the Conservation Area would be preserved by
the simple building of materials and type similar to others in the vicinity.
However, the Castle, its surroundings and its physical and historic relationship
with the village are also an important part of the Conservation Area’s
character, and therefore significance. This does not rely on its appearance or
visibility, and for the same reasons it has not been demonstrated that the
historic character of the Conservation Area would not be harmed by the
development.
16. The absence of a visual relationship between the situation of the proposed
garage and the grade II* listed Church of St Peter and St Paul and its distance
from the site may mean that there is less likelihood that the site contributes to
Appeal Decision APP/D2510/D/18/3199711
4
any significance the Church derives from its wider setting. However, again this
cannot be certain given the Church’s age and likely relationship over time with
the Castle and the location of the site between the two. An appropriate
assessment of significance would enable this to be established and the effects
on it to be evaluated.
17. In giving great weight to the assets’ conservation and in having special regard
to the desirability of preserving the listed buildings and their setting, it has not
been demonstrated that the development would preserve the special
architectural or historic interest of the Castle, or indeed the Church. Also, in
paying special attention to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the
character of the Conservation Area, it has not been demonstrated that the
development would preserve its historic character.
18. The development would consequently not accord with CS Policy SP11 which,
amongst other criteria, requires that development does not harm the site or
setting of a SAM and that appropriate evaluation should be undertaken.
19. I have considered the appellant’s suggestion that a planning condition requiring
an archaeological watching brief could have addressed any concerns about
buried archaeology. However, given the level of importance of the designated
heritage asset and the uncertainty raised by the lack of an appropriate
assessment of significance relative to the site and the particular development,
it would not be reasonable to reply on a condition to ensure that any harm to
significance would be avoided.
20. Avoidance of harm in and other respects does not amount to a positive
consideration in support of the appeal and does not indicate that the
development would be acceptable.
Conclusion
21. For the above reasons it has not been satisfactorily demonstrated that the
significance of designated heritage assets would not be harmed, contrary to the
development plan and the Framework. The appeal is therefore dismissed.
Geoff Underwood
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.