Front elevation - alterations to garage door and fenestration to incorporate a new window and side door, rear elevation - extension to 1st floor and roof, and existing roof and dormer window remodelling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 13 August 2018
by R Sabu BA(Hons), BArch, MA, PgDip ARB
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 14 November 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/L5810/D/18/3199612
34 Kings Road, Richmond TW10 6NW
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Gibbs against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Richmond-upon-Thames.
The application Ref 17/4142/HOT, dated 20 November 2017, was refused by notice
dated 16 January 2018.
The development proposed is described as front elevation - alterations to garage door
and fenestration to incorporate a new window and side door, rear elevation - extension
to 1st floor and roof, and existing roof and dormer window remodelling.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. A single storey rear extension and front porch enclosure has been granted
planning permission under Council Ref 17/2049/HOT, and has been shown on
the proposed drawings as an illustration of its potential role alongside the
proposed development. Although the Council has indicated that the proposed
ground floor rear extension’s overall scale would contribute to the over
development of the application property, since these elements already have
planning consent, my assessment below focuses primarily on the proposed
development as described above.
3. I note that the Local Plan has been adopted since the Council’s decision notice
was issued. I have made my determination based on the adopted version
which was which forms part of the evidence before me.
Main Issue
The Council has no objections to the proposed alterations to the garage door
and fenestration to incorporate a window and side door. Therefore the main
issue is whether the first floor rear extension, roof alterations and new dormers
preserves or enhances the existing building and the setting of St Matthias
Conservation Area.
Reasons
4. The significance of St Matthias Conservation Area (the Conservation Area) lies
in the development that has arisen between 1860s and 1880s around three
main roads which lead to St Matthias Church, one of which is Kings Road. The
Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/18/3199612
2
high quality residential area was designated for its cohesive form of varied
architectural styles which range from mid to late Victorian to a few modern
examples. They serve as evidence of the development of the affluent London
suburb which grew since the consecration of St Matthias Church and the
construction of London and South Western railway at Richmond. Furthermore,
St Matthias Church lies at the top of Richmond Hill with Kings Road, Church
Road and Mount Ararat Road sloping down away from the church.
5. 34 Kings Road is a large detached dwelling which has been substantially
extended over time. During my site visit I found that the property contributes
to the Conservation Area by being one of a cohesive set of large detached
dwellings which line Kings Road forming an attractive residential
neighbourhood.
6. The existing dwelling is significantly wider than the other detached properties
on the street. Currently its mass is broken down by the smaller elements of the
roof. I acknowledge that the existing roof appears somewhat unbalanced;
however the overall effect of the smaller components of the roof makes the
building appear in proportion with the other detached properties. During my
site visit, I noted that the appeal property is visible primarily from the lower
part of Kings Road and from Chester Avenue and is for the foregoing reasons in
harmony with its setting.
7. Although the proposed ridge height would match that of the immediate
neighbouring building, the length of the highest ridge would be significantly
greater than the adjacent properties. Therefore a large part of the roof would
be visible from street level. Unifying the dormers to make them wider and
taller would add considerable bulk to the roof. Enlarging the hipped gable roof
components would further add to the massing of the roof, visually emphasising
the greater size of the property compared to its neighbours. The overall effect
would be a top heavy design which, given its prominent position near the top of
Richmond Hill, would result in the appeal property visually dominating its
neighbours when viewed from the main approaches.
8. The first floor rear extension would bring the rear extent of the building in line
with an existing rear projection. In broad terms, this in itself would not be an
incongruous addition; however the roof design which corresponds with this
extension would have a greater height and a steeper slope than the existing
roof. Furthermore, the proposed rear dormer extension forms a single larger
mass than the existing smaller windows which would add further bulk to the
roof and would dominate the view from Chester Avenue and from the rear of
the properties along Kings Road.
9. I acknowledge the appellant’s objective to balance the elements of the roof and
dormers to achieve a more coherent composition than the existing roof.
However, the proposed development would have a dominating effect on the
street scene of both Kings Road and Chester Avenue that would disturb the
cohesion of the varied architectural styles.
10. For the foregoing reasons, I find that the proposed development would be
contrary to Policy CP 7 of the Core Strategy (2009), DM DC 1, DM DC 5 and DM
HD 1 of the Development Management Plan (2011), LP 1, LP 3 and LP 8 of the
Local Plan and the 'House Extensions and External Alterations' (2015) and
'Richmond and Richmond Hill Village Planning Guidance' (2015) Supplementary
Planning Documents.
Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/18/3199612
3
11. The resulting harm to the character and appearance of the host building and
street scenes would have a negative effect on the significance of the
Conservation Area. The harm would be less than substantial in the terms of
paragraph 196 of the Framework (2018) and would fail to preserve or enhance
the Conservation Area. There are no public benefits in the terms claimed by the
appellant and any benefit including securing optimum viable use that would
outbalance the harm found to the street scenes of Kings Road and Chester
Avenue and to the significance of the Conservation Area.
Other Matters
12. I acknowledge the objection to the proposed development from a neighbour
whose concerns align with the reasons discussed earlier.
13. I note the proposed upgrades to insulation and services that are proposed as
part of the appeal scheme; however these considerations do not outweigh the
harm identified, given its significance.
Conclusion
14. For the reasons given above I conclude that the proposal would fail to preserve
or enhance the Conservation Area and the appeal should be dismissed.
R Sabu
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.