Hardstanding to front of property, replacement of wooden fence with concrete posts to west facing boundary, and proposed installation of vehicle crossover
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Parking Provision
Highways & Transport
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 19 June 2018
by M Seaton DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 21 September 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/E5330/D/18/3197592
55 Ashburnham Place, Greenwich, SE10 8UG
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Desmond White against the decision of Royal Borough of
Greenwich Council.
The application Ref 17/1963/F, dated 19 June 2017, was refused by notice dated
14 December 2017.
The development is a hardstanding to front of property, replacement of wooden fence
with concrete posts to west facing boundary, and proposed installation of vehicle
crossover.
Procedural Matter
1. During the course of the planning appeal, the Government published the final
version of its revised National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) on
24 July 2018.The revised Framework sets out the Government’s planning
policies for England and how they should be applied. Accordingly, and in light
of the reference made to the previous iteration of the Framework within the
submitted evidence, the parties have been provided with a further opportunity
to make submissions in respect of the publication.
2. In this respect, I am mindful that neither the appellant nor the Council have
made any further submissions regarding the revised Framework. However, in
light of this re-consultation, I am satisfied that any references made to the
revised Framework within this decision would not be unreasonable to the
parties.
Decision
3. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are;
whether the development of the boundary treatment and introduction of a
dropped kerb preserves or enhances the character or appearance of the
Ashburnham Triangle Conservation Area; and,
the effect of the proposed development on the highway safety of
pedestrians and road users, and whether there would be an unacceptable
loss of on-street parking capacity.
Appeal Decision APP/E5330/D/18/3197592
2
Reasons
Conservation area
5. The appeal site is occupied by a 3-storey Victorian end of terrace property, set
in a residential street within the Ashburnham Triangle Conservation Area (the
Conservation Area). The front of the dwelling is set-back from the pavement by
virtue of an existing paved front curtilage for which retrospective planning
permission is sought, along with the wooden boundary fence with concrete
posts, and a vehicle crossover.
6. Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990
(the Act) places a duty upon the decision-maker, in the exercise of planning
functions, to have special regard to the desirability of preserving or enhancing
the character or appearance of conservation areas. This is also reflected in the
approach set out within the Framework, which advises that when considering
the impact of a proposed development on the significance of a designated
heritage asset, great weight should be given to the asset’s conservation.
7. The Ashburnham Triangle Conservation Area: Article 4 Direction Guidance Note
2016 (the Guidance Note) identifies the heritage asset as possessing a rich and
varied organic character, with characteristic building materials and architectural
forms employed of the Georgian and Victorian periods. The Article 4 Direction
is identified as including control over the erection, alteration or demolition of a
gate, fence or wall to the front or side of the property, and the making or
altering of a hard surface at the front of a property. The Guidance Note
highlights that new boundary structures should match appropriate historic
examples for the property and the locality, whilst the loss of front gardens to
car parking damages the character and amenity of the conservation area and
will be resisted.
8. The hard surfacing at the front of the property is indicated to be a replacement
for a previously existing area of hard surfacing, and as such does not represent
the loss of a front garden which the Guidance Note advises should be resisted.
I note from the submitted evidence that similar works of improvement to
landscaping and hard surfacing appear to have been approved in June 2014 by
the Council at Nos. 53 & 54 Ashburnham Place, and I would agree with the
Council that the replacement hard surfacing represents a visual improvement in
the context of the street scene and the host property.
9. In respect of the creation of a vehicular crossover and dropped kerb, I am also
satisfied that in the context of the street and the conservation area, that these
works would not in themselves have a harmful impact on the significance of the
heritage asset. Whilst I have had regard to the Council’s contention that the
loss of front gardens to car parking damages the character and amenity of the
conservation area, the pre-existence of hard surfacing in the stead of a front
garden would have already allowed informal car parking to take place in this
location. Whilst I accept that the formalisation of such an arrangement would
have the potential to allow a greater permanency to the impact of the use of
the front area for parking, I am not persuaded that this would result in any
harm to the significance of the conservation area, particularly in light of the
Council’s identification of the substantial level of existing on-street car parking
which prevails in the street and the area.
Appeal Decision APP/E5330/D/18/3197592
3
10. Turning to the wooden fence and concrete posts, the Guidance Note sets out
that new boundary structures should match appropriate historic examples for
the property and locality. I note that the boundaries within the front gardens in
the street and area remain principally defined and characterised by low hedges,
brick walls, or railings. Whilst the boundary treatment as erected is consistent
with the generally low level of existing boundary treatments within the vicinity,
its appearance as a consequence of the use of materials would not reflect the
positive characteristics of the conservation area. Whilst I have had regard to
the appellant’s contention that the introduction of a defining boundary with the
neighbouring property should be regarded as a positive step, I am not
persuaded that this in itself provides adequate justification for the materials
used, or that there is any compelling reason to depart from the Guidance Note
in this respect.
11. I observed the storage sheds and other small structures in front gardens
elsewhere in the conservation area, as referred to by the appellant in the
Grounds of Appeal. However, I have no details about the circumstances which
led to their siting before me, or indeed whether these are structures which
benefit from consent. Furthermore, I am not persuaded that these provide any
form of justification to allow the materials and design approach adopted in this
instance, within the conservation area.
12. The Framework makes a distinction between a development causing substantial
harm to the significance of a designated heritage asset, and works that would
lead to less than substantial harm. Paragraph 196 of the Framework continues
by stating that where a development proposal will lead to less than substantial
harm to the significance of the designated heritage asset, this harm should be
weighed against the public benefits of the proposal.
13. In this case, I find that the works cause less than substantial harm for the
reasons described. However, whilst I acknowledge that the works have resulted
in a visual improvement to the existing front forecourt area of hardstanding,
and as a consequence the street scene and heritage asset, I am not persuaded
that this represents a level of public benefit which would be sufficient to
outweigh the otherwise identified harm.
14. I am satisfied that the physical works to provide the hardstanding and
vehicular crossover would not in themselves result in harm, but preserve the
character and appearance of the Ashburnham Triangle Conservation Area.
However, I find that the boundary treatment fails to preserve or enhance the
character and appearance of the conservation area, contrary to the
requirements of s72(1) of the Act.
15. Accordingly, I find there to be conflict with Policies DH1, DH3 and DH(h) of the
Royal Greenwich Local Plan: Core Strategy with Detailed Policies 2016 (the
Core Strategy), and Policies 7.4, 7.6 and 7.8 of The London Plan: The Spatial
Development Strategy for London Consolidated with Alterations since 2011,
2016 (the London Plan). These policies state that planning permission will only
be granted for proposals which preserve or enhance the character or
appearance of the conservation area, are of high quality design and use
appropriate materials, and promote local distinctiveness. In addition, given the
great importance of the heritage asset, the scheme fails to conserve the
heritage asset in a manner appropriate to its significance, and is contrary to
the Framework.
Appeal Decision APP/E5330/D/18/3197592
4
Highway safety and parking
16. The Council has indicated that the hard surfaced area to the front of the
property possesses a limited depth of 4 metres on the appeal site for parking
as a consequence of the position of a bay window. Given that there would be a
need to achieve a minimum of 4.8 metres length for a standard parking space
set at right angles to the road, as a consequence this would be likely to result
in a parked vehicle overhanging the pavement, creating an obstruction for
pedestrians.
17. However, I have had regard to the appellant’s submissions that demonstrate
that an angled space within the front area could achieve the necessary
standard dimensions for parking, without causing an obstruction to
pedestrians. On the basis of this evidence and my own observations of the site,
I do not consider that the manoeuvring required to achieve access to and from
an angled parking space would be significantly different to that which would be
required for a space set at right angles. I am satisfied that ensuring the vehicle
would remain entirely within the front curtilage is a matter which could be
enforced by other means and legislation, and an off-street parking space could
be achieved in the manner proposed.
18. In respect of visibility splays, despite the observed presence of significant
levels of on-street parking which would erode the visibility of traffic within the
street, I am not persuaded that the generally low levels of traffic and low
speeds would result in an unacceptable level of conflict with vehicles whilst
manoeuvring in and out of the parking space. I am also satisfied that the low
level of existing boundary treatments within existing front gardens would
present a reasonable level of visibility of approaching pedestrians.
19. Turning to the impact of the proposal on existing on-street parking capacity, it
is evident from the submissions and my own observations that the street and
wider area, designated as a Controlled Parking Zone (CPZ), experiences
significant levels of parking stress. The Council makes the reasonable assertion
that within the CPZ it is desirable to make the best use of available on-street
parking space for all users within the community, given the over-subscription
of permits to spaces.
20. In this respect, the proposal would have an undoubted adverse impact on the
existing available capacity for the wider community as a consequence of the
introduction of the dropped kerb and off-street parking space. The result would
essentially see the ‘privatisation’ of a parking space at the expense of 1 or 2
communal spaces on-street, dependent on the disposition of spaces on this
side of the street within the designated CPZ. As a consequence, the proposed
development would exacerbate existing high levels of parking stress.
21. Whilst I have concluded that the proposed development would not result in an
adverse impact on the highway safety of pedestrians and road users, I find that
there would be an adverse impact on the existing available capacity of on-
street parking, resulting in an increased demand for on-street parking. As a
consequence, the proposal would be contrary to Policy DH1 of the Core
Strategy, and Policy 6.3 of The London Plan. These policies seek to ensure that
development takes into account existing patterns of activity, achieves
accessible and inclusive environments for all, and ensures that development
does not have an adverse impact on transport capacity at the local level.
Appeal Decision APP/E5330/D/18/3197592
5
Conclusion
22. For the reasons given above, the appeal is dismissed.
M Seaton
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.