Excavation to provide a basement
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 29 May 2018
by Gary Deane BSc (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 31 May 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/Y5420/D/18/3197201
102 Wargrave Avenue, Tottenham, London N15 6UA
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr H Moskowitz against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Haringey.
The application Ref HGY/2018/0260 was refused by notice dated 2 March 2018.
The development proposed is excavation to provide a basement.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural matter
2. At the time of the site visit, construction work was underway at the appeal
property with security hoardings placed around the front of the site. As the
entrance door to the hoardings was open views into the site were available
from the adjacent footway. Consequently, I was able to able to proceed with
site visit unaccompanied, as scheduled.
Main issues
3. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on the character
and appearance of the local area and whether or not the proposal would
provide satisfactory living conditions for the occupiers of the host property.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The appeal property is a mid-terrace dwelling that has been externally altered
and extended to include a large full width dormer and, from the plans before
me, a sizable ground floor rear addition. Like No 102, most properties along
Wargrave Avenue stand behind a short front garden. This arrangement,
coupled with low-level boundary walls, soft planting and diverse range of
paving treatments, is an important feature of the street scene to which the site
belongs. Despite their modest size, the front gardens contribute to the sense
of space and provide some uniformity within the local street scene. The site is
not within a conservation area. The appeal property is not a listed building.
5. The proposal is to excavate a new basement beneath almost the full extent of
the main building including its rear extension. No additional living space would
be created at or above ground level. The proposal would feature 2 new front
windows below street level that would face onto a proposed light well. The
Appeal Decision APP/Y5420/D/18/3197201
2
plans show that 1.1 metre high metal railings would enclose the void although
the grounds of appeal indicate that a glass panel at a similar height would
secure the front light well. Either way, this form of enclosure would be a
significant feature at the front of the property and it would be evident from the
adjacent footway on the immediate approach to the site.
6. From what I saw, front lightwells, railings, glass panels and windows below
street level visible from the road, as proposed, were unfamiliar features of
properties along Wargrave Avenue and adjoining streets. As the only example
of an existing building with such features in its immediate context, the proposal
would be highly obtrusive and an uncharacteristic addition. By signaling a
lower ground floor, the new light well and railings or glass panel would also
amplify the perceived scale and height of No 102 resulting from the existing
dormer. As a result, the finished building would appear overly large compared
to other nearby properties and overdeveloped in its restricted plot. This harm
would clearly outweigh the benefits for the appellant and his family that would
result from the additional accommodation proposed, the need for which is
pressing. Extra planting to provide additional screening or a different type of
enclosure to the void would not satisfactorily mitigate its harmful visual impact.
7. Reference is made to the Council’s decision to grant planning permission1 for a
new basement with front and rear light wells at 121 Wargrave Avenue, which
was also secured by hoardings at the site visit. I did, however, observe that
No 121 does not have a front dormer and so its existing built form differs to
that of the appeal dwelling. Furthermore, the basement at No 121 was
approved before the Council adopted its Development Management DPD, which
now forms part of the development plan before me. Consequently, this
example is not directly comparable with the appeal scheme. In any event,
each proposal should be assessed on its own merits, as I have done here.
Living conditions
8. With no external windows, the storeroom in the new basement would lack an
outlook towards the outside. There would also be limited opportunity for
sunlight and daylight to reach this internal space or for it to be naturally
ventilated. Two windows would serve each of the front and rear rooms in the
new basement, which are denoted on the plans as a study and playroom.
However, these windows would be modest in size and would look into relatively
small light wells. As such, the amount of natural light reaching to, and the
external outlook from, each of these rooms would be unacceptably poor.
9. The appellant states that the internal space within the new basement would be
ancillary to the main dwelling with no intention to provide extra habitable
rooms. However, future occupiers of the enlarged dwelling might seek to use
the basement space differently and create extra bedrooms or a living room,
which would be difficult to control through the imposition of a condition.
Conclusion on the main issues
10. On the main issues, I conclude that the proposed development would
materially harm the character and appearance of the local area and that it
would provide unsatisfactory living conditions for the occupiers of the property.
Accordingly, it conflicts with Policies 3.5, 7.4 and 7.6 of The London Plan, Policy
1 Ref HGY/2016/0614 dated 18 May 2016
Appeal Decision APP/Y5420/D/18/3197201
3
SP11 of Haringey’s Local Plan and Policies DM1, DM12 and DM18 of the
Council’s Development Management DPD. These policies aim to ensure that
residential extensions are of a high quality; that development enhances and
enriches the built environment and provides a high standard of amenity for all
occupiers; and that basements avoid harming the appearance of the host
building or the established character of the surrounding area.
11. The appeal scheme is also at odds with a core principle of the National Planning
Policy Framework (the Framework), which states, amongst other things, that
development should respond to local character; add to the overall qualities of
an area; and provides satisfactory living conditions for all residents.
Other matters
12. That others do not object and a representation fully supports the proposal does
not, in itself, indicate that the appeal scheme is therefore acceptable. For the
reasons given, I have concerns that the proposal would harm the character and
appearance of the local area and that the quality of the extra living
accommodation provided would be below an acceptable standard.
13. The submitted Basement Impact Assessment indicates that any predicted
damage to neighbouring properties would be well within acceptable limits.
Nevertheless, the likely lack of significant damage does not outweigh the harm
that I have identified.
Conclusion
14. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the proposal should be dismissed.
Gary Deane
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.