Two-storey side extension and single-storey rear extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Highways & Transport
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 27 March 2018
by W Johnson BA (Hons) DipTP DipUDR MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 9 May 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/X3025/D/18/3196577
2 Jadella Close, Mansfield NG18 5EQ
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Lack against the decision of Mansfield District Council.
The application Ref 2017/0739/HHA, dated 6 November 2017, was refused by notice
dated 13 December 2017.
The development proposed is two-storey side extension and single-storey rear
extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues of this appeal are:
the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the appeal site
and the surrounding the area, and;
the effect on highway safety with particular regard to the proposed
arrangements for off-street parking.
Reasons
Character and appearance
3. Jadella Close is a small cul-de-sac located off Sheepbridge Lane comprising a
small number of recently constructed 2-storey brick and tile houses. The
appeal scheme would comprise a 2-storey side extension and a single storey
rear extension. The single storey rear extension would be of brick construction
with a parapet style flat roof and would extend across the full rear elevation of
the original property. The 2-storey side extension would be located on the left
side of the host property when viewed from the front. The resultant effect is
that the scheme, in overall terms, wraps around the property.
4. The Council has raised no adverse comments in relation to the single storey
rear extension and, by reason of its size, siting and design, I also find no harm
in that regard. The 2-storey side extension, would extend the full depth of the
original house, and this would involve no set back from the front elevation and
no lower ridge line. Additionally, the proposal would create slightly greater
width to the host dwelling and would extend beyond the existing garage, but a
side space to the boundary with the adjacent property would still be
maintained.
Appeal Decision APP/X3025/D/18/3196577
2
5. The 2-storey side extension albeit without a set back on the front elevation or a
lower ridge line, would still have a modest width when considered in isolation.
The proposal does not propose any set back at first floor that in turn would
naturally lower the ridge line. In 3.11 of Interim Planning Guidance Note 2
(IPG2) it indicates that a setback should be incorporated at first floor level and
should create a subordinate appearance relative to the main dwelling. Whilst
the proposal would not result in a terracing effect with the adjacent dwelling, I
have little reason to find that this in itself would represent an instance where a
variation should be accepted as paragraph 3.12 of IPGG2 suggests.
6. Due to the overall size and location of the proposed 2-storey extension in
conjunction with the absence of design features that would give it a
subordinate appearance to the existing dwelling, the scheme would amount to
an excessive addition. The scheme would result in a disproportionate increase
in the scale and massing of the dwelling. This in turn would result in a visually
intrusive and overbearing addition to the street scene, especially when read in
conjunction with the single storey side extension on the opposite side of the
host dwelling.
7. Whilst the previous appeal (APP/X3025/D/11/2147638) noted that Jadella
Close is relatively secluded and that only a small number of properties are
served by this private road, the scheme, and its resulting harm to local
character and appearance, would still be readily evident in the public domain.
8. I therefore conclude that the proposed extension would unacceptably harm the
character and appearance of the appeal site and surrounding area. This would
be contrary to Policy BE1 (paragraph 1) and Policy H13 (paragraph 1) of the
Mansfield District Local Plan. These policies seek a high standard of design and
to ensure that development should relate well to neighbouring buildings and
the local area generally, whilst safeguarding against detrimental effects on the
character and/or appearance of the street scene or the surrounding area
generally. Additionally, the proposal conflicts with the guidance contained in
the Interim Planning Guidance Note 2 (IPG2) on ‘Extensions to Dwellings’. This
document sets out advice towards the development of extensions to dwellings.
Furthermore, the proposal would not accord with the National Planning Policy
Framework (the Framework), which amongst other things, underlines the
importance of high quality design and seeks to promote or reinforce local
distinctiveness.
Highway safety
9. The proposal would replace the existing garage situated towards the rear of the
property and an area of driveway that runs alongside the house. Although this
would result in the loss of 2 off-street parking spaces, the proposal would
incorporate a replacement garage at ground floor. Whilst the two storey side
extension would have no set back from the front elevation at ground floor, the
garage door would be internally recessed within the scheme, which would
ensure availability of a space large enough to park one vehicle directly in front
of it.
10. The Council has submitted and made reference in the officer report to Draft
Interim Planning Guidance Note 10 – ‘Parking for New Developments’.
However, the Council has confirmed that this document has not been formally
adopted and I only give it limited weight in the context of this appeal. The
Council suggests that 3 off-street car parking spaces should be provided for
Appeal Decision APP/X3025/D/18/3196577
3
dwellings of 4 or more bedrooms and I have little reason to disagree with the
Council in this regard. The appeal scheme would maintain 4 bedrooms, with
one bedroom being significantly enlarged as part of the proposal.
11. The scheme would reduce the current level of off-street parking by a minimum
of one space, which would potentially displace parking onto the carriageway to
the detriment of highway safety. I also note comments from local neighbours
who have raised concerns in this regard and I observed during my visit that the
host property is located at a point where the road narrows and is already of
limited width as the previous appeal decision acknowledged. The appellant
contends that provision of 2 spaces would be appropriate in this instance and
that it would be possible to park one car directly in front of the proposed
garage and another car parked in the garage itself. The extent of the remaining
area of hard standing in front of the host dwelling in my assessment would not
be sufficient to satisfactorily accommodate a further space. Therefore, any
further vehicles would have to be parked on the street.
12. I have had regard to the accessibility of services and facilities from the appeal
site, and the emphasis in the Framework on encouraging the use of sustainable
modes of transport. Additionally, I note the absence of formally adopted
parking standards, but my finding remains for the reasons indicated that the
provision of 2 off-street parking spaces at this property would not constitute an
appropriate level, and would potentially result in the occurrence of further on-
street parking.
13. For all of these reasons, I therefore conclude that the proposed extension
would unacceptably harm highway safety with particular regard to the
proposed arrangements for off-street parking. There would be conflict with the
requirements of Mansfield District Local Plan Policy M16, in particular
paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 that seek to avoid detrimental effects on the
surrounding highway network; incorporating safe vehicle access, egress and
internal movements; and to ensure that a scheme provides the minimum car
parking necessary to the needs of the development.
Other matters
14. In addition to those matters considered above, the neighbouring occupier of
the adjacent property has raised concerns relating to loss of light and
overshadowing, but I note that the Council raises no objections and I too
consider the proposal not to be harmful in this respect. I have had regard to
various other matters raised by the neighbouring occupiers including facing
materials, drainage and the use of the existing garage, but these do not alter
my conclusions on the main issues.
15. My attention has been drawn by the appellant to other developments that have
been approved by the Council. Relatively little detail has been provided
regarding the particular planning backgrounds to those schemes. Without such
information a full and detailed comparison between those developments and
the case before me cannot be drawn, but I find on the basis of the information
provided that the other developments cited have little implication for the
specific impact of the appeal scheme. I have considered this appeal proposal on
its own particular merits and concluded that it would cause harm for the
reasons set out above.
Appeal Decision APP/X3025/D/18/3196577
4
Conclusion
16. For the reasons given above, and having regard to all other matters raised, the
appeal is dismissed.
Wayne Johnson
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.