To extend existing single detached single-storey garage and convert the building to a Granny Annexe
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Rural Impact
Sustainability
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 21 May 2018
by J L Cheesley BA(Hons) DIPTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 22 May 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/Y2620/D/18/3196224
The Cottage, Metton Road, Roughton, Norwich, Norfolk NR11 8QT
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr John Bowen against the decision of North Norfolk District
Council.
The application Ref PF/17/2083 was refused by notice dated 5 February 2018.
The development proposed is to extend existing single detached single-storey garage
and convert the building to a Granny Annexe.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main issue
2. I consider the main issue to be whether the proposal would constitute the
creation of an independent dwelling and if so, whether the proposal would
constitute sustainable development in this countryside location.
Reasons
3. The proposal includes the conversion and extension of an existing garage to
provide a bedroom, living room/kitchenette and a shower room. I realise that
the proposed accommodation is required for dependent relatives to live in, as
overspill accommodation.
4. Whether the proposal would be an annexe or an independent dwelling is a
matter of fact and degree. The distinctive characteristic of a dwelling house is
its ability to afford to those who use it the facilities required for day-to-day
private domestic existence.
5. In my opinion, the proposal would be more than an annexe to the main house
and would be capable of being used independently with no functional or
practical linkage. In particular, the provision of a kitchenette would indicate
that the building would be capable of being used independently with no
functional or practical linkage to the main dwelling.
6. Although the proposed kitchenette area would be small, it would be part of a
larger room, allowing for an expansion of eating and cooking facilities. From
Appeal Decision APP/Y2620/D/18/3196224
2
my observations, with the provision of a kitchenette and shower room, I see no
difference between the proposal and a small independent dwelling. The
facilities within the building would make the building capable of being used as a
separate dwelling. In my opinion, this would be more than an annexe to the
main house. In addition, the independent separate vehicular access together
with the physical separation would enable it to be primary living
accommodation capable of being used as a completely independent dwelling.
7. For the above reasons, I consider that the proposed annexe would be
tantamount to being a new dwelling in the countryside. Therefore, I have
determined the appeal before me in this respect.
8. The appeal property lies within a countryside location where Policies SS 1 and
SS 2 in the North Norfolk Core Strategy (2008) seek to restrict development. I
consider these policies are broadly in accordance with the National Planning
Policy Framework as far as they meet the Framework’s core principles;
particularly that planning should be taking account of the different roles and
character of different areas and recognising the intrinsic character and beauty
of the countryside.
9. It must be acknowledged that at the heart of the Framework is the
presumption in favour of sustainable development. It sets out the three
dimensions that need to be considered, and that the roles should not be taken
in isolation.
10. In terms of the social role, paragraph 55 in the Framework seeks to promote
sustainable development in rural areas by locating housing where it will
enhance or maintain the vitality of rural communities. It seeks to avoid new
isolated homes in the countryside unless there are special circumstances.
Although I acknowledge the need for accommodation for elderly relatives, I do
not consider this to be a special circumstance as it could be repeated many
times elsewhere.
11. In terms of its location, the proposal would contribute little towards maintaining
the vitality of this sporadic rural community and thus would make little
contribution to the social role of sustainability.
12. Turning to the economic role, some very small benefit would accrue in relation
to the conversion of the building. I now turn to the environmental role.
Although the proposal is for a conversion and small extension of an existing
building, the Framework maintains that development should be sustainable and
that the countryside should be protected for its intrinsic character and beauty.
By converting and extending the outbuilding to primary living accommodation
capable of being used as a completely independent dwelling, I consider this
would be detrimental to the character of the surrounding countryside due to
the intensification of domestic use.
13. Taking the three dimensions together, the proposal would not be sustainable
development in this countryside location.
14. In reaching my conclusion, I have taken into consideration all matters raised. I
have been referred to an example at Sereynis, close to the appeal property. I
was able to view that property from the public highway. That annexe does not
have a separate access to the highway and therefore there are not identical
circumstances to the proposal before me, which I have determined on its
individual merits.
Appeal Decision APP/Y2620/D/18/3196224
3
15. I conclude that the relationship to the main dwelling, the separate access and
self-contained nature of the proposal would likely result in the proposed annexe
being occupied with little or no reliance on the main dwelling. The facilities
within the building would make the building capable of being used as a
separate dwelling. This would be tantamount to being a new dwelling in the
countryside which would be contrary to Core Strategy Policies SS1 and SS2 and
I do not consider the proposal would constitute sustainable development in this
countryside location.
J L Cheesley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.