Two storey extension to rear and side elevation of annex providing two bedrooms at first floor level and a lounge and covered patio at ground floor level, together with ancillary works

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Character & Appearance
Rural Impact
Conversion/Use

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 25 April 2018 by JP Tudor BA (Hons), Solicitor (non-practising) an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 13 June 2018 Appeal Ref: APP/P1615/D/18/3194447 The Barn, Greenwood Farm, Joyford, Coleford, Gloucestershire GL16 7AS  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Mr Ryan Powell against the decision of Forest of Dean District Council.  The application Ref P1493/17/FUL, dated 4 September 2017, was refused by notice dated 3 November 2017.  The development proposed is two storey extension to rear and side elevation of annex providing two bedrooms at first floor level and a lounge and covered patio at ground floor level, together with ancillary works. Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Preliminary Matters and Background 2. I have taken the description of development used in the banner heading above from the planning application form. Although it has been altered in the Council’s decision notice and in the appeal form, there is no indication of agreement between the parties to any change and the original description adequately describes the proposed development. 3. The planning history indicates that the barn was considered redundant and converted to holiday accommodation via a permission granted in 2005.1 Subsequently, permission was granted in 2013 for a change of use to residential annex accommodation and for the erection of a carport and utility/wet room (part retrospective).2 That application was supported by a unilateral undertaking, in the form a s106 agreement, which I am advised ties the use of the annex, known as The Barn, to the main farmhouse. The proposal refers to the building as an annex and, therefore, I have considered the appeal on that basis. Main Issues 4. The main issues are:  the effect of the proposed development on the character and appearance of the existing building; and,  whether the proposal would result in the creation of a separate dwelling. 1 P0487/05/COU 2 P2015/10/COU Appeal Decision APP/P1615/D/18/3194447 2 Reasons Character and appearance 5. The appeal site comprises a two storey detached barn conversion with garden land, which is a residential annex incidental to the main dwelling at Greenwood Farm. Fields lie to the south, east and west with main farmhouse just to the north. It is accessed off a no through lane and a driveway shared with the farmhouse and stables. 6. It is proposed to extend the annex to the rear over two storeys to provide new bedrooms at first floor level with a lounge and covered patio area below. Internal reorganisation would create a larger bathroom and increase the overall number of bedrooms from 2 to 3. The existing annex consists of a lounge/dining room, kitchen and utility room/WC on the ground floor, with two bedrooms and a bathroom on the first floor. A car port is attached to the west. Whilst the existing bedrooms are relatively small, overall the annex building, as a former barn which has already been extended, is of a reasonable size for use ancillary to a main dwelling. 7. According to the Council, the two storey extension would, at ground floor level, increase the existing 67m2 footprint by about 40m2, including the covered patio area. At first floor level, the existing footprint of about 40m2 would be increased by approximately another 40m2. Therefore, the proposed extension would be substantial, especially given that the use is as an annex incidental to the larger farmhouse just across the garden. Whilst I understand that the proposal is a resubmission of a previously refused scheme3, which the appellant says has been reduced substantially in size, the Council advises that it is only 15m2 less than the previous scheme at first floor level, with the extent of the ground floor remaining much the same. The above figures have not been specifically disputed by the appellant. 8. Therefore, the extension would be a sizeable addition, as also evidenced by the refashioning of the rear roof and southern elevation. Two gables would protrude from the existing pitched roof whilst the arrow slit windows, more often associated with barn conversions, would be covered and replaced by more extensive glazing in the new elevation. At first floor level, the built form would extend beyond the existing ground floor side extension and overhang the new patio area below. Although the advice in the Forest of Dean Residential Design Guide – Alterations and Extensions (RDG)4 refers to particular house types, it does make the general basic point that ‘extensions should not dominate the original building’. 9. In support of the scale of the extension, the appellant refers to the limited size of the two existing bedrooms and advises that they are below the minimum areas specified in the government’s ‘Technical housing standards - nationally described space standard’.5 However, the Written Ministerial Statement of 25 March 2015 makes it clear that such standards can only be applied where there is a relevant current local plan policy. In this case, I have not been referred to any such policy and consequently, this is not a matter which carries significant weight in favour of the proposal. Moreover, those standards relate to new 3 P0971/17/FUL 4 2002 5 March 2015 (Department of Communities and Local Government) Appeal Decision APP/P1615/D/18/3194447 3 dwellings rather than residential annexes, which are intended for use incidental to a main dwelling. The proposal does not seek a change of use. 10. The overall bulk, scale and design of the extension would overwhelm and be out of character with the existing barn conversion. That adverse effect would not be sufficiently mitigated by the use of matching materials. As I saw on my site visit, although the adjacent public highway is a no through road, it leads to at least one other dwelling, and it offers clear public views of ‘The Barn’ and the main farmhouse, which are relatively prominent as they are sited on slightly higher ground. 11. Whilst the appellant notes a sentence in the Council Officer’s report indicating that the extension would be ‘in keeping in terms of design’, that appears to be at odds with the Council’s overall conclusions in its decision notice. It refers to the adverse effects of its bulk, scale and detailing, which are aspects of design, and its refers to conflict with its RDG. I find the proposal to be unsympathetically designed, for the reasons already given. 12. Therefore, I conclude that the proposed development would harm the character and appearance of the existing building. It follows that it would be contrary to the high quality design encouraged within part 7 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)6, an important material consideration in all planning decisions, and emerging policies AP1 and AP4 of the Council’s Allocations Plan (AP)7, to which I afford moderate weight due to its relatively advanced stage. 13. Policy CSP.1 of Council’s Core Strategy (CS)8 appears more directly focussed on the relationship between design and the environment. However, buildings are an aspect of the environment and the policy states that design and construction of new development must take into account important characteristics of the environment. The supporting text, which is a legitimate aid to interpretation, also refers to the importance of good design. Therefore, the proposal would conflict with CS policy CSP.1 to that extent. 14. Policy AP5 of the AP concerns the style and nature of materials used. Materials to match the existing building are proposed, which could be secured by condition. Therefore, the scheme is not contrary to that emerging policy. Creation of a separate dwelling 15. The Council has expressed concern that, as annexes are normally expected to provide more limited accommodation commensurate with their ancillary function, the size of the extension and amount of additional living space would be tantamount to the creation of a separate dwelling. Although not fully explained within the Officer’s Report, that concern is presumably related to the possible creation of a new separate dwelling in the countryside. Such dwellings are generally discouraged because of effects on the character and appearance of the countryside, likely remoteness from services and the variable sustainable transport options available, as detailed in policies within the Framework. 16. Whilst the existing annex does provide facilities for independent day-to-day living including a kitchen, bathroom, living space and bedrooms, albeit the 6 Published March 2012 7 Allocations Plan Submission Draft, August 2015 8 Forest of Dean District Council: 23 February 2012: Core Strategy Adopted Version Appeal Decision APP/P1615/D/18/3194447 4 bedrooms are small, as stated above it is subject to a s106 agreement, which ties the annex to use ancillary to the main farmhouse and prevents its independent sale. Therefore, the principle of its use as an annex is well established. 17. The proposal continues to describe the unit as an annex and the appellant is content for its use to continue to be restricted as ancillary to the main farmhouse. The Council is also satisfied that the current s106 agreement prevents use of the existing annex as a separate dwelling and I see no clear reason to disagree with that view. 18. However, the Council also advises that the s106 agreement would need to be amended to reflect the proposed development, in order for it to remain effective. The appellant has expressed a willingness to enter a new s106 agreement. However, no copy of a revised or new agreement or undertaking has been submitted with the appeal documentation. Nevertheless, the appellant suggests that the matter could also be dealt with by means of an appropriate condition. 19. The proposal would increase the amount of living accommodation on the ground floor and the size and number of bedrooms on the first floor, making ‘The Barn’ more likely to be considered as an independent dwelling rather than as ancillary accommodation. However, set against that the building would still be smaller than the main farmhouse which is in close proximity, just opposite, and it would continue to share a driveway with that property. Therefore, whilst limited evidence has been submitted about living arrangements and occupation of the main farmhouse, on balance, a suitable condition could potentially ensure that the annexe remained ancillary to the farmhouse. 20. A number of policies are cited in the Council’s decision notice in relation to this issue, but there is limited explanation or identification of specific conflict. As described above, CS policy CSP.1, the only current development plan policy referred to, is mainly concerned with the relationship between design and the environment. Similarly, apart from emerging AP policy AP1, which reflects the general sustainability principles of the Framework, the other emerging policies are more focussed on design and character and appearance issues. Although pages 5 of the RDG is referred to, the detail mainly concerns garages with accommodation above and annexes being linked to or accessed from a main property. Therefore, the majority of those policies have limited direct relevance to this aspect which could, in any event, be potentially dealt with by condition. Other Matters 21. Whilst I appreciate that the appellant wishes to increase the amount of living space for his family, particularly with regard to the bedrooms, the planning system is more generally focussed on the wider public interest, unless exceptional personal circumstances have been evidenced. Furthermore, the proposal relates to a residential annex, which although a separate building, is presented as incidental to the use of the larger main farmhouse. Therefore, I give limited weight to those personal circumstances. Appeal Decision APP/P1615/D/18/3194447 5 Conclusion 22. Overall, although the concerns about the creation of a separate dwelling could potentially be dealt with by means of a suitable condition, that would not overcome the harm which I have identified to the character and appearance of the existing building. Consequently, for the reasons given above, and having regard to all other matters raised, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed. JP Tudor INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →