Detached residential annexe
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Highways & Transport
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 15 March 2018
by Ian McHugh DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 5 April 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/X3025/D/18/3193809
125 Southwell Road East, Rainworth, Mansfield, NG21 0DE
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Paul Cullen against the decision of Mansfield District
Council.
The application Ref 2017/0697/HHA, dated 26 October 2017, was refused by notice
dated 7 December 2017.
The development proposed is a detached residential annexe.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for a detached
residential annexe at 125 Southwell Road East, Rainworth, Mansfield,
NG21 0DE, in accordance with the terms of the application
Ref 2017/0697/HHA, dated 26 October 2017, subject to the following
conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plan: Drawing No. 2017- 070 rev 3.
3) The annexe hereby permitted shall be occupied solely as ancillary
residential accommodation to the host dwelling at number 125 Southwell
Road East. It shall not at any time be let, sold or occupied as a separate
dwelling from the host dwelling.
4) Prior to any development commencing, samples of the materials to be
used in the external surfaces of the annexe building shall be submitted to
and approved by the Local Planning Authority. The development shall be
carried out in accordance with the approved details.
Procedural Matter
2. The Council’s decision notice refers to the annexe as having two bedrooms. It
is clear from the submitted plan that the annexe has one bedroom. This has
also been confirmed in the appellant’s evidence. Therefore, I have considered
the proposal on the basis of the submitted plan.
Appeal Decision APP/X3025/D/18/3193809
2
Main Issues
3. These are:
Whether the appeal development would be tantamount to a separate
dwelling.
The effect of the development on the character and appearance of the
area.
The effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the occupants of
neighbouring properties.
Whether the proposal would create a precedent for further development
in the area.
Reasons
Separate Dwelling
4. The appeal site is currently part of the long and irregular-shaped rear garden of
number 125 Southwell Road East (number 125). The site is generally flat and
is enclosed by trees, hedges and fencing. It contains a number of ancillary
domestic buildings, including a garage, various sheds and storage buildings
plus a greenhouse.
5. The site is served by a relatively narrow access drive that runs between
number 125 and the neighbouring dwelling at number 123 Southwell Road East
(number 123).
6. The proposal is to construct a single storey annexe building. The annexe would
be wholly self-contained in terms of its internal accommodation, comprising an
open-plan kitchen/dining/lounge area, one bedroom with en-suite and a wc.
Externally, the garden and parking areas would be shared. The annexe would
be occupied by the existing resident of number 125, who is registered disabled
with mobility difficulties, whilst a family member/carer would occupy the main
dwelling.
7. The Council contends that the proposed accommodation exceeds what would
normally be expected in an annexe and that the proposal would create a
separate detached bungalow, which would be out of character with the area.
8. The Council also refers to the planning history of the site, including an
application for a dwelling in 1996, which was refused, and a more recent
proposal for a two bedroomed annexe, which was also refused in October 2017
(Council reference: 2017/0531/HHA) for reasons similar to the current appeal
proposal.
9. In considering whether the proposed development would be tantamount to a
separate dwelling, I have taken into account the judgement in Uttlesford DC v
SSE & White [1992], in which the judge found that it is a matter of fact and
degree as to whether a ‘granny annexe’ would constitute part of the main
planning unit, or create a separate one. If the proposal does not create a new
planning unit, then the annexe could be considered a part of a single family’s
occupation and would be an incidental use. In Uttlesford, the person
accommodated “would have her own bedroom, bathroom and, I assume,
lavatory, small kitchen, somewhere to sit and her own front door. To that
Appeal Decision APP/X3025/D/18/3193809
3
extent, she will be independent from the rest of her family”. The judge then
went on to say that he “finds no reason in law why such accommodation should
consequently become a separate planning unit from the main dwelling”.
Despite the fact that the judgement was given almost 25years ago, this
principle remains valid today.
10. With regard to the current appeal, I note the Council’s concerns regarding the
size of the proposed annexe in comparison to the existing dwelling at number
125 and to the proposed separation distance between the two buildings.
However, there is no proposal to create a separate curtilage or garden for the
annexe, and parking and vehicle manoeuvring spaces would be shared. The
appellant also states that utility services would be shared with number 125.
Furthermore, the internal space provides relatively easy access and
manoeuvring for a wheelchair user. The appellant also points to the fact that
the planning application was submitted to and considered by the Council as a
householder development, not as a separate dwelling.
11. For the reasons given above, I consider that the proposed development may
justifiably be regarded as an annexe to the existing dwelling and that its
occupation should be restricted to that purpose.
Character and Appearance
12. The Council contends that the proposal would represent a form of
backland/tandem development that would be out of character with the existing
pattern of development in the locality. As such, the Council considers that the
proposal would conflict with Saved Policies H2 and H13 of the Mansfield District
Local Plan (LP), which require new ‘housing’ development to integrate with the
existing settlement and surrounding land uses; and to not have a detrimental
effect on the character and/or appearance of the area. I have also taken into
account the provisions of paragraph 58 of the National Planning Policy
Framework (the Framework), which requires developments to respond to local
character and to reflect the identity of local surroundings.
13. Although the proposal would undoubtedly result in a new ‘residential’ building
in the rear garden area, I return to my findings above, which are that the
proposal can be considered as an annexe and as an ancillary building to the
main dwelling. In that context, the rear garden of the appeal property already
contains a number of detached buildings. Furthermore, the rear garden is
substantially enclosed by relatively tall evergreen hedging and other vegetation
and, therefore, the proposed building would have little visual impact on the
character or appearance of the site and its surroundings. In addition, its
overall design and external appearance would not appear at odds with its
surroundings. Accordingly, I consider that the proposal would not conflict with
the Development Plan.
Living Conditions
14. Concern is expressed by the Council that the use of the proposed annexe would
result in an unacceptable loss of residential amenity to the occupiers of
neighbouring property, because of increased activity, movement and vehicular
traffic. Policy H2 of the LP states that new housing developments should not
lead to a reduction in residential amenity for adjacent occupiers.
Appeal Decision APP/X3025/D/18/3193809
4
15. I note that the Council’s reason for refusal in relation to this issue is worded on
the basis that the harm would result if the proposed development was to be
separated from the host property. Whilst this is not what is proposed, I accept
that the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the occupiers of
neighbouring dwellings is a material consideration, particularly as the driveway
between number 125 and the adjoining property at 123 is relatively narrow.
16. The proposal is for a one-bedroomed annexe, which is to be occupied by a
registered disabled person. Although the evidence shows that the proposed
occupier uses a car, I am not persuaded that activity associated with the
annexe, including any vehicular movements, would amount to such a level that
it would result in unacceptable noise and disturbance to neighbouring residents
at either number 123 or other nearby properties. The separation distances
between the appeal building and other dwellings, plus existing screening add to
my findings on this issue.
17. Paragraph 17 of the Framework states that planning should always seek to
secure a good standard of amenity for all existing and future occupants of land
and buildings. In my opinion, the proposal would provide a good standard of
amenity for the occupier of the annexe and it would not be unacceptably
harmful to others. Accordingly, there would be no conflict with the
Development Plan or the Framework, as referred to above.
Precedent
18. The Council argues that, if approved, the proposal would create a precedent for
other similar developments, which would have an adverse impact upon the
character of the area and residential amenity. I have not been provided with
any evidence which shows that similar developments are proposed. However,
it remains an established principle that each proposal should be considered on
its own merits. In my opinion, the circumstances relating to this appeal
proposal indicate that the development is acceptable.
Conditions
19. The Council has suggested conditions in the event of the appeal being allowed.
These have been considered in the light of the advice contained within the
Planning Practice Guidance.
20. A condition requiring the development to be carried out in accordance with the
approved plans is necessary, for the avoidance of doubt and in the interests of
proper planning.
21. To ensure a satisfactory appearance, a condition requiring the submission and
approval of external materials is also necessary.
22. A condition is also imposed to ensure that the annex is remains ancillary to the
host dwelling at number 125. Although such a condition is not strictly
necessary, as the creation of a separate dwelling would require planning
permission, I see no reason why it should not be used in order to reinforce the
description of the development.
Appeal Decision APP/X3025/D/18/3193809
5
Conclusion
23. I have taken into account all other matters raised, including representations
made to the Council by third parties. However, for the reasons given above, it
is concluded that the appeal should be allowed.
Ian McHugh
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.