First floor side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 6 February 2018
by Darren Hendley BA(Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 21st February 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/J4423/D/18/3193665
Bentiholme Farm, Bent Hills Lane, Sheffield S35 0GE
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr R Helliwell against the decision of Sheffield City Council.
The application Ref 17/04336/FUL, dated 16 October 2017, was refused by notice dated
11 December 2017.
The development proposed is a first floor side extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are a) whether the proposal would constitute inappropriate
development in the Green Belt for the purposes of the National Planning Policy
Framework (Framework) and the development plan policy, b) its effect on the
openness of the Green Belt, c) its effect on the character and appearance of
the building and the area and d) if it is inappropriate development, whether the
harm by reason of inappropriateness and any other harm, is clearly outweighed
by other considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances
necessary to justify the development.
Reasons
3. The appeal property is a 2 storey detached house, which has been extended to
the side to create 2 storeys of annexe accommodation. On the opposite side of
the house is also a single storey extension. The house is found to the front of a
complex of buildings that are largely agricultural in form, with a further
dwelling also located close by. The area in the vicinity of the site comprises of
countryside and open fields, with sporadic forms of mainly residential or
agricultural development located along narrow country lanes. As well as its
location in the Green Belt, the site also lies in an Area of High Landscape Value
(AHLV) under the Sheffield City Council, Sheffield Unitary Development Plan
(1998) (UDP).
Inappropriate Development
4. Paragraph 89 of the Framework states that the construction of new buildings is
inappropriate in the Green Belt unless, amongst other exceptions, it involves
the extension or alteration of a building provided it does not result in
disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building.
Appeal Decision APP/J4423/D/18/3193665
2
5. ‘Saved’ Policy GE6 of the UDP states that, in the Green Belt, proposed
extensions will only be permitted where they form a minor addition to the
original house. Guideline 9 of the Council’s Designing House Extensions
Supplementary Planning Guidance (SPG) defines a minor addition as up to one
third of the cubic content of the original house, for smaller houses.
6. The original building for the purposes of the Framework comprises the dwelling
prior to its extension by way of the annexe and single storey extensions. Both
of these form additions to the size of the original building. Although the
appellant considers that the annexe is a ‘de facto’ small family home, the
planning permission1 was granted for a 2 storey side extension to form a
granny annexe and, as such, it should be treated as an addition to the original
building.
7. With the annexe and single storey extensions, the original building has already
been significantly extended. The proposal would be another addition by
providing a further level of accommodation over the entirety of the single
storey extension, and increasing its height up to the same as the original
building. This needs to be considered with the extensions that have already
taken place.
8. Assessing proportionality with regard to the policy guidance which the
Framework sets out is principally an objective test based on size. Accordingly,
compared to what I consider what would have been the size of the original
building, the proposal, in combination with the existing extensions and
alterations, would constitute a disproportionate addition.
9. The cumulative volume of the proposal, with the existing additions, would also
be in excess of the one third of the cubic content guidance, as set out by the
SPG. Whilst this threshold may not be decisive on its own, as the SPG
acknowledges each case will be determined on its merits, this does not alter
my conclusions because the size of the proposal, with the existing additions,
has led me to consider that it would constitute a disproportionate addition.
10. Paragraph 89 of the Framework states that buildings for agriculture are an
exception to the construction of new buildings as inappropriate in the Green
Belt. However, this does not extend to buildings that are intended for
residential use, even if they may support an agricultural use. Consequently,
the proposal is not a building for agriculture and so this attracts limited weight
in my considerations.
11. Therefore, I conclude the proposal would constitute inappropriate development
within the Green Belt and it would not comply with the Framework and ‘Saved’
Policy GE6 of the UDP, and Guideline 9 in the SPG.
Openness
12. Openness is an essential characteristic of the Green Belt. The proposal would
alter the area of the land on which it would be sited by way of an increased size
of a side extension that would be of more substantial proportions. It would
not, though, project beyond the building lines of the existing house.
13. In terms of the visual component of openness, the proposal would be
noticeable from the lower reaches of the access roads on the approach to the
1 Council ref: 00/02285/FUL
Appeal Decision APP/J4423/D/18/3193665
3
site and from Bent Hills Lane, with the views afforded down to the site across
fields, although this would be at some distance. The proximity to the other
buildings would also limit broader visual effects.
14. I consider that the effect on the openness of the Green Belt, overall, would be
limited.
Character and Appearance
15. The original appearance of the house has been significantly altered by the
extensions, in particular by the annexe, and so what would have been the more
cohesive form of the original farmhouse has been, to an extent, diminished.
The proposal would broadly follow the form of the existing dwelling and utilise
matching external materials. It would not unduly detract from its character.
16. As regards broader impacts on the AHLV, the proposal would be modest in this
context. Its visibility would also be tempered by its proximity to larger
buildings, including the existing house and the larger agricultural buildings. It
would, therefore, not appear unduly visually intrusive in the landscape.
17. I conclude the proposal would not be unacceptable with regard to the effect on
the character and appearance of the building and the area, including the AHLV.
As such, it would comply with ‘Saved’ Policy GE8 of the UDP which states that
development must protect and, where appropriate, enhance the character of
the AHLV.
Other Considerations
18. The appellant has set out matters in relation to changing family circumstances
and the need for the proposal to provide improved accommodation. I am
sympathetic to these needs, however, this does not outweigh the strong
protection which is afforded to the Green Belt, and so this attracts limited
weight.
19. Concerning the location of the proposal and the need to attend to livestock, I
am also not persuaded this justifies the proposal, as the existing house would
appear to be able to fulfil this function, based on the evidence before me.
20. The appellant has referred to other examples of development in the Green Belt
in the area, although I have not been made aware of the full circumstances in
each case. Whether or not a proposal constitutes a disproportionate addition,
and the effects on openness, also requires an assessment based on each site’s
own characteristics and the particular merits of the proposal. I also note that
one of the examples cited concerned the conversion of farm buildings, and this
would have involved a different Green Belt policy test. As such, they do not
alter my conclusions.
Conclusion
21. The proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt and, in
addition, there would be a limited loss of openness. Paragraph 88 of the
Framework establishes that substantial weight should be given to any harm to
the Green Belt. I find that harm would not arise concerning the effect on the
character and appearance of the building and the area, but this attracts neutral
weight. Other considerations which arise do not clearly outweigh the totality of
the harm. Consequently, very special circumstances do not exist. The
Appeal Decision APP/J4423/D/18/3193665
4
proposal would not, thus, comply with the Framework with regards to Green
Belt national policy, ‘Saved’ Policy GE6 of the UDP, and Guideline 9 in the SPG.
The appeal, therefore, should be dismissed.
Darren Hendley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.