Modifications to existing dwelling house to include: Single-storey and two-storey rear extension, replacement roof with new attic accommodation with new rear-facing dormer window. Existing facing brick external walls to be insulated externally with new painted render finish throughout. New replacement windows throughout
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 April 2018
by Alison Roland BSc DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 24 May 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/L5810/D/18/3193502
31 Ormond Crescent, Hampton, TW12 2TJ.
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr G Woods against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Richmond-Upon-Thames.
The application Ref: 17/2679/HOT, dated 12 July 2017, was refused by notice dated
29 November 2017.
The development proposed is modifications to existing dwelling house to include:
Single-storey and two-storey rear extension, replacement roof with new attic
accommodation with new rear-facing dormer window. Existing facing brick external
walls to be insulated externally with new painted render finish throughout. New
replacement windows throughout.
Procedural Matter
1. Although revised plans were submitted at the planning application stage, the
Council determined the application on the basis of the original submission
including Drawing Nos 1.42 Rev G and 1.50 Rev E. I shall determine the appeal
likewise.
Decision
2. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
3. The main issues in this appeal are the implications of the proposal for (1) the
character and appearance of the area and (2) the living conditions of adjoining
residents with regard to the potential for overbearing effects and loss of
privacy.
Reasons
4. The existing dwelling comprises a detached brick built property set within an
estate of predominantly large detached houses which appear to date from the
mid twentieth century. It features a projecting two storey bay with vertical tile
hanging and pitched roof canopy across the ground floor beneath a hipped roof.
The proposal would effectively amount to the remodelling of the property,
changing the hip to a gable with crown roof and rear dormer, introducing
Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/18/3193502
2
contemporary box shaped single and first floor rear extensions, reconfiguring
the fenestration, changing the roof from tiles to natural slate and recladding the
exterior with painted render.
5. The Council take exception to the fact that the proposal is akin to a replacement
dwelling and fails to retain any of the original features. However, this in itself is
not necessarily the overriding issue, provided the resultant appearance of the
dwelling integrates satisfactorily with others in the street.
6. I take the appellant’s point that there are several examples along Ormond
Crescent where the original dwellings appear to have been extensively
remodelled and/or significantly extended. These include most notably Nos 30,
39, 49, 51 and 53. In the light of the materials palette employed on these
properties, incorporating painted render and a slate or synthetic slate, together
with what appears to be aluminium glazing, I take no issue with the materials
proposed in the scheme before me, with the exception of the cladding of the
front bay which I turn to later in this decision.
7. The rear extensions would impart an undeniably boxy contemporary form to the
rear of the property and employ different materials to each tier, which is not an
uncommon design approach and to which in principle I take no issue. However,
in scale and massing they would dominate the rear elevation of the property,
particularly in terms of their width across the first floor. Whilst they would
occupy a subservient elevation concealed from public view, they would be
clearly visible from adjoining properties and their gardens, as well as from the
houses and gardens on Manor Gardens, to the rear.
8. I have particular concerns about the resultant appearance of the property when
viewed from Ormond Crescent. The current property whilst arguably
unexceptional in design, is nonetheless attractive, well composed and sits
comfortably amidst others in the street.
9. I do not consider the same could be said of the appeal scheme. Whilst there is
undeniably a range of window designs employed on the estate, many of which
have a horizontal emphasis to the openings themselves, they tend in the main
to be broken up into smaller sections through the use of casement windows, as
is the case with the appeal property, or more modern simplified glazing
patterns. This tends to counterbalance the horizontal emphasis of the openings.
10.In contrast, the windows on the front elevation would have only minimal
vertical subdivision, with lightweight frame profiles imparting an appearance
reminiscent of a 1970’s style. The lightweight flat roofed canopy running across
the front elevation would add to this retro effect. It is not entirely clear what the
cladding material is to the front bay, but it appears from the plans to be
consistent in appearance with the first floor rear extension suggesting metal
cladding. This would appear odd and incongruous on the front of the property
where most nearby bays are either brick built or clad in vertical tiles.
11.I also take issue with the hip to gable alteration given the immediate site
context. As this property stands markedly forwards of No 29 to the East, the hip
to gable would result in a tall flank gable wall appearing unduly dominant when
approaching the site from the East. I take this view despite the appellant’s
reference to the ridge level being around 625mm lower than existing, because
the resultant massing of the roof would nonetheless be appreciably greater. The
Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/18/3193502
3
relatively deep crown roof would mean that it would not read as a typical gabled
roof, but would have a markedly greater bulk when viewed from the East and
would appear incongruous, especially as hipped roofs predominate on this side
of the road at this easterly end of Ormond Crescent. I appreciate that No 39
also appears to employ a crown roof and it too is set forward of its neighbour to
the East, but the effect is rather different due to the hipped sides and that
particular property also employs sympathetic fenestration to the front elevation
unlike the appeal proposal.
12.I am mindful that there is a greater diversity of house types when one rounds
the bend in Ormond Crescent to the East, but that particular stretch of road
which runs broadly North-South has a different character to the stretch in the
close vicinity of the appeal site.
13.I have also considered the other examples cited by the appellant, including two
appeals on Manor Gardens (APP/L5810/D/17/3179314 &
APP/L5810/D/17/3183472), but it is difficult to make a meaningful comparison
with the appeal before me in the absence of full details and I must necessarily
determine this appeal on the basis of the site specific context and detailed
design advanced.
14.In all, whilst I take no exception to the materials palette on the whole, nor to
the principle of the contemporary design approach adopted to the rear, I
consider the rear extensions would nonetheless appear unduly bulky and would
dominate the rear elevation. In addition, the hip to gable with large crown roof
would appear discordant and impart an incongruous appearance to the property
when viewed from the East and the detailing on the front elevation would fail to
integrate with the prevailing character. The resultant appearance of the
property viewed from Ormond Crescent, compared to its present appearance
would be markedly retrograde in its design and it would not sit comfortably in
its context.
15.Overall therefore, I conclude on the first main issue that the proposal would fail
to satisfactorily integrate with the prevailing character and appearance of the
area. This would bring it into conflict with Policy CP7 of the London Borough of
Richmond-Upon-Thames Local Development Framework Core Strategy (2009),
Policy DM DC1 of the Development Management Plan (2011) (DMP), Policy LP1
of the Local Plan Publication Version for Consultation (4 January-15 February
2017) (LP) and the advice in the Design Guidelines for House Extensions &
External Alterations Supplementary Planning Document (2015) (SPD). These
seek to ensure that development recognises and is compatible with distinctive
local character and contributes to creating places of high architectural and
urban design quality and in the case of the SPD, that two storey rear extensions
should not dominate the building. However, Policy DM DC5 of the DMP and
Policy LP 8 of the LP which relate to neighbourliness and living conditions, add
nothing to the case on this issue.
16.In relation to the second main issue, the Council’s concern is confined to the
impact of the proposal on occupiers of No 33 Ormond Crescent at the rear. The
single storey rear extension would project 6.6 metres from the rear of No 31
with a height of around 3.18m and be offset around 1.7 metres from the
boundary with No 33. This depth would significantly exceed the 4 m guideline in
the SPD for the depth of single storey rear extensions. At present the boundary
Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/18/3193502
4
with No 33 is marked by a fence of approximately 2 metres in height, although
I understand that an adjoining hedgerow was previously significantly higher.
17.In my view, the single storey extension would be materially higher than the
existing fence and would loom large relative to the rear garden to No 33,
presenting an overbearing effect thereon. This is especially the case as it would
affect the area closest to the house which tends to be the most intensively used
for sitting out etc. Whilst I appreciate the height of the former hedgerow, the
very fact this has apparently been cut back illustrates the difference in terms of
the impact of a masonry structure compared to planting, with the former
tending to be a relatively permanent feature in contrast to the latter. Whilst the
Council refer to the loss of sunlight in the mornings, this would be limited to a
short duration of the day and would not add to my concerns.
18.In terms of privacy, there are two high level slot windows proposed in the side
of the single storey extension which the appellant states would not afford views
out due to their height above finished floor level. Whilst I do not disagree with
that assertion, the fact is that they would appear to peer above the existing
boundary fence to No 33 giving a perception of being overlooked at fairly close
quarters. The appellant states that the further slot window in the side of the
first floor extension would be obscure glazed which does not appear to be the
case on the revised drawing 1.50 Rev E. Either way, were I minded to allow the
appeal, this matter could have been addressed through a condition requiring all
three windows to be obscurely glazed. As such, this issue does not weigh
against the appeal.
19.Despite my findings in relation to privacy, I conclude on the second main issue
that the proposed single storey rear extension would be unduly dominant and
overbearing on the rear garden of No 33 Ormond Crescent, which would bring it
into conflict with Policy DM DC5 of the DMP and Policy LP8 of the LP, together
with the advice in the SPD. These seek to ensure that development protects the
amenity and living conditions for occupants of neighbouring properties,
including avoiding overbearing impacts and harm to the reasonable enjoyment
of gardens.
Overall Balance and Conclusion
20.I have found on the first main issue that overall the design of the proposed
extensions and alterations would not be acceptable. Added to this harm would
be the overbearing impact of the proposals on the occupants of No 33.
21.In terms of positive factors in the overall planning balance, I appreciate the
appellant’s point that the proposal would facilitate the thermal upgrading and
general updating of the property. I attribute this factor some albeit limited
weight, because the appeal scheme is not the only means of achieving this.
22.To the extent that the proposal would negate existing overlooking from a first
floor side window in No 29 across the appellant’s property, this would present a
small improvement to the living conditions of the occupants of the appeal
property, although I do not accept it would benefit the occupiers of No 33 due
to the distance therefrom.
23.The appellant cites the permitted development rights for larger home
extensions that could potentially allow an 8 metre deep extension. However,
Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/18/3193502
5
that would be subject to a notification procedure which requires objections to be
taken into account and there is no firm evidence it would likely be implemented.
As such I attribute it limited weight.
24.Overall, I do not consider that the points advanced in favour of the appeal
would outweigh the harm identified. It follows that the appeal fails.
ALISON ROLAND
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.