Erection of a two-storey side extension altering and enlarging existing extension; addition of side entrance porch to form new main entrance; external hard landscaping to create elevated garden terrace; enclosure of space under elevated terrace for use as recreation room; change of roofing material from clay pantiles to natural or artificial slate; change of wall materials with overcladding of painted pebbledash render with fibre cement weatherboarding
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 19 February 2018
by John D Allan BA(Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 04 April 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/D0121/D/18/3192952
Fenwynds, Tower House Lane, Wraxall, BS48 1JT
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Holt against the decision of North Somerset Council.
The application Ref 17/P/1622/F, dated 20 March 2017, was refused by notice dated
4 December 2017.
The development proposed is the erection of a two-storey side extension altering and
enlarging existing extension; addition of side entrance porch to form new main
entrance; external hard landscaping to create elevated garden terrace; enclosure of
space under elevated terrace for use as recreation room; change of roofing material
from clay pantiles to natural or artificial slate; change of wall materials with
overcladding of painted pebbledash render with fibre cement weatherboarding.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. The application was amended through the submission of revised Drg Nos 1628-
03 Rev B, 1628-04 Rev B and 1628-06 Rev B. It is these drawings that were
considered by the Council, as stated on the decision notice. Amongst some
other minor changes, the revisions included removing the proposed enclosure
of space under an elevated terrace that would have created a recreation room.
This is reflected within the amended drawings and which show the space
altered to an open sided veranda.
3. There was originally a serious discrepancy in the floorspace calculations that
were presented by both parties in relation to the original building and the
proposed building. Following a written request for these matters to be clarified
there has been some convergence in the figures, with both parties revising
their original calculations.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are: -
Appeal Decision APP/D0121/D/18/3192952
2
Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green
Belt having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework (the
Framework) and any relevant development plan policies;
The effect of the proposal on the openness of the Green Belt;
The effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area;
and
If it is inappropriate development, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations so as to amount to the very special circumstances
necessary to justify the development.
Reasons
Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt
5. The appeal site lies within the Green Belt. The Framework explicitly states that
inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful to the Green Belt.
However, the extension of an existing building is not inappropriate if it does not
result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original
building. Policy DM12 of the Council’s Development Management Policies Sites
and Policies Plan Part 1 (July 2016) deals with extensions of existing buildings
and is consistent with the Framework but adds that an extension will not
normally be regarded as disproportionate provided it does not exceed 50% of
the gross floor area (GFA) of the original building. It goes on to state that
consideration will also be given to the impact of extensions on the openness of
the Green Belt and regard will be taken of the design (including bulk, height
and floorspace), siting and overall scale of the development on the site and the
open and rural character of the area in general.
6. An ‘original building’ is defined in the Glossary to the Framework as a building
as it existed on 1 July 1948 or, if constructed after 1 July 1948, as it was built
originally. This differs from the definition given in Policy DM12 which states
that For North Somerset ‘original’ relates to the building as existing on 26 July
1985 or for buildings constructed after this date as so built.
7. The original property has previously been enlarged including through the
addition of extensions that were granted planning permissions in 1991 (Ref:
1171/91) and 2004 (Ref: 04/P/0186/F).
8. The appeal proposal would comprise various elements but would principally
involve a two-storey side extension to replace an existing side conservatory
addition. The new extension would incorporate into it an existing two-storey
side and rear extension which would have a remodelled and fully integrated
roof as part of the works. Part of the proposal would also include alterations to
the existing terraced arrangements to the south side of the building to create a
new larger terraced area at ground floor level with the open sided veranda
below.
9. Based on the Council’s definition of the ‘original building’ both parties have
provided figures for the original and proposed GFAs for the dwelling. The
Council gives the GFA for the original dwelling as around 178sqm and a
proposed GFA, based on the accumulated size of extensions including the
Appeal Decision APP/D0121/D/18/3192952
3
additions that are now proposed, as around 281sqm. This would amount to an
increase in floorspace of around 57%. The appellant gives the GFA for the
original dwelling as around 191sqm and a proposed GFA of around 292sqm.
This would give an increase of around 52%. The appellant remains critical of
the Council’s methodology for their calculations of the original floorspace,
particularly in relation to the first floor and undercroft areas, where it is argued
that they have failed to follow their own guidance by taking measurements
from internal rather than external faces of the walls in places.
10. The difficulty in obtaining definitive figures is clear from these disparities, but
there is close to agreement upon the additional floorspace proposed as being
just over 100sqm. This figure would include the open veranda at lower ground
level, which I agree should be included as it would be a covered and accessible
space. Therefore, even if the appellant’s original floorspace is taken as
accurate, for the purpose of the development plan the percentage increase of
52% would still add more floor area to the dwelling than the 50% limit
suggested by Policy DM12.
11. It is also necessary to consider the form, bulk, height and overall scale of the
enlarged building. The proposed side extension would project the full height
ridge and eaves levels of the existing building sideways. Despite a hipped roof,
the span of the original ridge would more than double in length. Even though
this element would replace an existing side conservatory extension, when
taken with the under-build to the new terrace on the south side of the building,
the side addition would add significantly to the mass and scale of the house.
This would result in a building of considerably more bulk than the existing.
This element of the proposed works would be a noticeably dominant feature of
the resulting building, even if seamlessly designed to appear as if it was an
original part of the building. The side entrance porch would be much more
subservient. But when taken together, and with the previous side/rear
extension, which itself added some noticeable bulk to the original dwelling in a
fairly dominant form, I find that the proposal would contribute to an
accumulation of additions that would be disproportionate when assessed
against the size of the building as it existed in 1985. It follows that the
proposal would also amount to a disproportionate addition over the size of the
original building when considered against the Framework’s definition.
12. Regardless of the degree to which the dwelling can be seen from the public
domain, in relation to the first main issue I conclude that the proposal would be
inappropriate development in the Green Belt for the purpose of the Framework
and development plan policy. By definition this is harmful to the Green Belt
and I attach substantial weight to this harm.
The effect of the proposal on the openness of the Green Belt
13. The effect of the proposal on openness is not a determinative factor in gauging
inappropriateness in the case of extensions or alterations to buildings.
However, the Framework states that an essential characteristic of Green Belts
is their openness and that the fundamental aim of Green Belt policy is to
prevent urban sprawl by keeping land within them permanently open.
14. Openness is the absence of development. The addition of the side extension
would result in a part of the building that would be taller and bulkier than the
Appeal Decision APP/D0121/D/18/3192952
4
existing. The side entrance porch and the forward projecting veranda would
encroach into space around the existing building that is currently either open or
free from development. As such, there would be some loss of openness to the
Green Belt from the combination of these new works. Although the degree of
this loss would be minimal, this must be regarded as some additional harm,
even if only slight, to add to the harm by reason of inappropriateness.
The effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area
15. The Council has raised no concern about the impact of the proposal upon the
character and appearance of the existing dwelling or the wider area. Whilst the
scale of the proposal would change the character of the dwelling in terms of its
bulk, it would not appear more intrusive in the landscape or otherwise detract
from the character of the area. However, the absence of harm in relation to
these matters is neutral and not a positive factor in the scheme’s favour.
Other Matters
16. I appreciate that the appellant wishes to extend the dwelling for the benefit of
his family and that the proposed works would alter an existing awkward roof
configuration. These factors carry limited weight in the scheme’s favour.
17. I have noted that the appellant has been frustrated by his efforts to discuss the
proposals with the Council’s officers prior to the application’s determination but
this is not directly relevant to the planning merits of the case.
18. The appellant has argued that the proposal would result in a more balanced
looking dwelling with an improved appearance. Whilst I accept that the
proposed alterations would result in a dwelling that would be acceptable in
terms of its impact upon the character and appearance of the area, I am not
persuaded that the existing dwelling impacts in any harmful way. I therefore
detect no tangible benefit from the proposal that would add any weight in the
scheme’s favour.
19. Reference has been made to other dwellings in the Green Belt where it is
suggested that planning permission has been given for extensions beyond the
Council’s normal guideline. However, I have no specific information about any
other examples and am therefore unable to draw any direct comparison
between them and the appeal proposal. What is more, each case is
determined on its individual planning merits and in this instance I have
considered the appeal based on the circumstances and context of the appeal
property.
Whether the harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly
outweighed by other considerations
20. I have found the proposal to be inappropriate development for the reasons
identified. This amounts to very substantial weight against it. In addition, I
have also found that it would prejudice the openness of the Green belt, albeit if
only to a small degree. The other considerations that have been put to me do
not carry sufficient weight to clearly outweigh the harms that I have identified.
The very special circumstances necessary to justify the development do not
exist.
Appeal Decision APP/D0121/D/18/3192952
5
21. Accordingly, and having regard to all other matters raised, the appeal is
dismissed.
John D Allan
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.