Replacement of windows in front elevation with wood grain heritage conservation UPVC windows
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 26 March 2018
by Caroline Jones BA (Hons) DipTP MTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 9 April 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/X1355/D/17/3192333
13 Mowbray Street, Durham DH1 4BB
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mrs Christine Stock against the decision of Durham County
Council.
The application Ref DM/2017/02685/FPA, dated 9 August 2017, was refused by notice
dated 5 October 2017.
The development proposed is replacement of windows in front elevation with wood grain
heritage conservation UPVC windows.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is whether the proposed development would preserve or
enhance enhance the character or appearance of the Durham City Centre
Conservation Area.
Reasons
3. 13 Mowbray Street is a modest Victorian terraced property which lies in within
the Durham City Centre Conservation Area (DCCA). The Councils ‘Durham City
Conservation Area Executive Summary’ (2016) (ES) states that the central
area of the City of Durham is one of the most important historic city’s in Britain
with the time-depth, quality and architectural coherence of the historic
buildings and the preserved Medieval street patterns, centred on the peninsula
and expanding outwards with dramatic topography and extensive greenery
making the DCCA exceptional.
4. Amongst other things, the ES identifies that the special interest of the historic
buildings within the DCCA is derived from the traditional building materials
used and the survival of original architectural details such as timber sliding
sash windows. These features are identified as contributing significantly to the
distinctiveness and identity of individual buildings and groups of buildings
generating rich and diverse historic streetscapes. The loss of historic fabric and
architectural features is considered harmful or a threat to the special qualities
and character and potentially damaging to the conservations areas significance
as a designated heritage asset.
Appeal Decision APP/X1355/D/17/3192333
2
5. In 2016 the Council introduced a Direction under Article 4(2) of the General
Permitted Development Order 1995, affecting the appeal property. Amongst
other things, it has removed the householders permitted development rights to
carry out certain works to elevations that front a highway, including
replacement doors and windows. The Article 4(2) Direction demonstrates the
importance placed by the Council on the contribution that the original period
design of doors and windows make to the character of individual historic
buildings and the DCCA as a whole and I have given this considerable weight.
6. The appeal property retains its original timber sliding sash windows with black
painted frames, horns and thin astragal bars. These surviving architectural
details and the use of traditional materials have considerable evidential,
historic and aesthetic value. They form an important constituent element which
makes a positive contribution to the character and appearance of the host
property and thus to the character and appearance of the wider conservation
area.
7. The Council acknowledge that the proposed replacement windows would be of
good quality and at the higher end of the market, superior to existing UPVC
windows within the street. Having regard to the submitted brochure I have no
reason to disagree. However, whether or not the windows would replicate the
windows aesthetically, the proposal would result in the loss of original
architectural features and historic fabric, which are identified as contributing to
the special qualities and character of the DCCA. The loss of the historic and
evidential value that the windows provide would diminish the special interest of
the appeal property and its contribution to the character of the DCCA.
8. The presence of UPVC windows and doors at various other properties in the
locality does not justify the proposed alterations at No 13. I accept that there
are examples of such replacements having been installed. However, I consider
that these demonstrate the material harm that can be caused to character and
appearance by such development. In addition, I cannot know whether these
changes were made before the Article 4(2) Direction took effect, and no
evidence has been submitted to indicate that they have been permitted
subsequently. Accordingly, I have given only limited weight to such other
examples.
9. For the aforementioned reasons, I consider that the proposed replacement
windows would harm the character of No 13 and of the DCCA. I attach
considerable importance and weight to this finding. However, I quantify the
extent of this harm to the DCCA as being less than substantial in the context of
paragraphs 133 and 134 of the National Planning Policy Framework given the
scale of the development and because the proposal would resemble the
existing windows to a degree.
10. I recognise the associated benefits of improved energy efficiency and noise
insulation to No 13. However, these are limited in their scope as public benefits
and there are other strategies available such a draught proofing and secondary
glazing (without draught-proofing to prevent possible condensation) which
could achieve such outcomes without removing traditional windows. There is no
compelling evidence that such measures do not work well in terraced
properties or in properties used as HMOs.
11. The appellant also asserts that there would be a public benefit in terms of
longevity, providing a low maintenance solution to a timber window that is
Appeal Decision APP/X1355/D/17/3192333
3
nearing its useful life. It is argued that the appearance is greater than their
condition and that they consist more of filler than timber in many places.
However, there is no substantive evidence before me that the windows are in a
state of decay or beyond viable economic repair and properly carried out
repairs can extend the lifetime of a window for many years. Accordingly, these
benefits do not outweigh the harm to the character of the DCCA that I have
identified.
12. I conclude that the proposed development would fail to preserve or enhance
the character of the DCCA. It is therefore contrary to Policy E6 and E22 of the
Durham City Local Plan (2004) (DLP) which seek to preserve or enhance the
special character, appearance and setting of the DCCA by, amongst other
things, using external building materials which are the same as, or are
sympathetic to the traditional materials of the historic city or an individual
street.
Other Matters
13. It is not a matter for this appeal to consider the merits and justification of the
Article 4(2) Direction. Whilst there may be other features at risk within the
DCCA, I must confine my consideration to the details of the proposal.
14. I note that the above policies or Article 4(2) Direction do not specifically
exclude the use of UPVC or specify the use of timber. They seek to protect the
character and appearance of the DCCA and I have found that the replacement
of the timber windows would result in harm in this instance.
15. I have had regard to the appellant’s remarks in relation to modern timber
windows and their quality. However, the appeal scheme is for the replacement
of the timber windows with UPVC and therefore the arguments pertaining to
the quality of modern timber is not a matter for this appeal. I note that the
proposed windows can be recycled and are guaranteed against discolouration
but these matters do not lead me to alter my conclusions. Policy Q9 of the DLP
relates to the alteration and extension of properties. However, as the policy is
not cited in the Council’s reason for refusal it has not had a material bearing on
my decision.
16. Each application and appeal must be considered on their own merits. However,
there would be many opportunities within the DCCA or areas covered by the
Article 4(2) Direction for similar proposals and in my view, allowing the appeal
could set a precedent for similar proposals which cumulatively would
significantly alter the character of the DCCA.
Conclusion
17. For the reasons given above, and having regard to all matters raised, I
conclude the appeal should be dismissed.
Caroline Jones
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.