Erection of a replacement front wall, drive access and hard standing
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Green Belt Policy
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 5 March 2018
by John D Allan BA(Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 14th March 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/Q3820/D/17/3192235
126 Three Bridges Road, Three Bridges, Crawley, RH10 1JP
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Giovanni Biazzo against the decision of Crawley Borough
Council.
The application Ref CR/2017/0763/FUL, dated 5 September 2017, was refused by notice
dated 17 November 2017.
The development proposed is the erection of a replacement front wall, drive access and
hard standing.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for the erection of a
replacement front wall, drive access and hard standing at 126 Three Bridges
Road, Three Bridges, Crawley, RH10 1JP in accordance with the terms of the
application, Ref CR/2017/0763/FUL, dated 5 September 2017, subject to the
following condition:
1) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plan: Drg No RPP/RH101JP/GA.
Preliminary Matters
2. Despite the description of development that was given on the application form,
the appellant has confirmed that the application sought permission to include
the erection of a brick wall with piers and railings, iron gates, panel boarded
fences along the western and eastern boundaries of the site, and a pedestrian
gate to the rear of the front brick wall. These are reflected in the description of
development that was given by the Council on their decision notice and I have
considered the appeal based on the entirety of the proposed works.
3. The application was part retrospective and at the time of my visit I saw that
the brick wall and brick piers had been erected, as had the side boundary
fences.
Appeal Decision APP/Q3820/D/17/3192235
2
Main Issues
4. The main issues are the effect of the proposal on: - (i) the character and
appearance of the area; and (ii) the living conditions at 128 Three Bridges
Road with particular regard to visual impact and use of the existing access.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
5. Three Bridges Road is principally a residential street with a variety of house
types along its significant length. It has a semi-rural character with grass
verges and deep front gardens to each side of the road and an abundance of
mature vegetation. Despite this I saw a variety of front boundary treatments
such that any sense of openness and space to the area was derived mostly
from the width of the vista up to the back edges of the highway along the
street scene, and not from any meaningful contribution made by open
frontages. I did not detect the openness of any front gardens to be critical or
important in defining the character or appearance of the area.
6. The front wall that has been erected is reasonably low and short in length but
with three equally spaced taller brick piers. The intervening spaces would be
filled with metal railings. Such an arrangement is not alien to the area with
several other notable examples visible within the street scene, including a
similar arrangement obliquely opposite the appeal site at No 71 and not at all a
‘considerable distance away’, as suggested by the Council. I found none of the
existing comparable arrangements to be visually intrusive or harmful to the
character of Three Bridges Road which prevails along much of its length in both
directions away from the appeal site. Similarly, the work that was completed
at No 126 was not at all strident within the street scene and I am not
persuaded that the addition of railings would render it any more prominent.
7. The gates would be wide, but not excessively so to a degree that would appear
out of scale or proportion with the residential context of their setting.
Moreover, they would be recessed behind the front boundary so that they
would feature further less prominent or intrusive.
8. I have noted that the Council’s Urban Design Supplementary Planning
Document (SPD), October 2016, advises that low walls and fences are more
appropriate for front boundaries, but the guidance does not expressly prohibit
taller means of enclosure and in this instance I find that the proposal would fit
within the local context.
9. Most of the side fence panels are of a height that the Council accepts would not
normally require planning permission from the local planning authority
although they express concern that their erection is in significant contrast to
the open arrangement that pre-existed with No 128, and the hedge and shrub
boundary with No 124. Be that as it may, I again saw other examples locally
where solid boundary fences of comparable heights separated neighbouring
front garden plots. I saw none that were visually intrusive, including that
which had been erected at No 126, which had minor impact upon the street
scene, the open character of which was largely unaffected.
Appeal Decision APP/Q3820/D/17/3192235
3
10. I appreciate that the original layout at No 126 and the immediately
neighbouring plots may have been open plan, with no boundary demarcation
between the dwellings that share an access from Three Bridges Road over the
grass verge to the front. However, due to an existing mix of front boundary
enclosures to these same properties I saw no significance to this former
arrangement within the wider street scene. Neither did I detect any harm
through the introduction of the fence line that now separates the plots.
Living Conditions at 128 Three Bridges Road
11. The side fence that has been erected adjacent to No 128 is not an atypical
structure for a residential plot either in terms of its height or its form. In this
regard I do not find it to be overbearing. Neither have I found it atypical for
the area.
12. The front garden plot to No 128 remains wide. Furthermore, No 128 is set
away from the common side boundary with No 126 by the width of a
pedestrian access to the side of the property and is arranged with an integral
garage positioned nearest to the new fence line with a driveaway and parking
space to the front. Because of all this, I could detect no undue sense of
enclosure being imposed upon the neighbours’ living conditions that would
impact upon their outlook or use of their front garden to any significant degree.
13. The erection of a brick pier towards the front of the appeal site and adjacent to
the boundary with No 128 has segregated an arrangement where the entrances
to the driveways to both properties were originally open and aligned side by
side with a single crossover to the highway. The Council has suggested that
the brick pier has impacted upon the neighbours’ ability to turn and manoeuvre
into their property. However, there remains a single-width access to No 128
from the back edge of the verge that is typical for many residential properties.
Furthermore, the crossover and concrete surface over the grass verge is
unaffected by the works. There is no evidence before me that access to No
128 is denied by the works undertaken. Neither is there any evidence to
suggest that the works prevent any vehicles parked to the front of No 128 from
adequately turning. I accept the works may have impacted upon the previous
ease of access to No 128 by limiting the possibility of a vehicle using part of the
surface to the front of No 126, but I am not persuaded that this is detrimental
to the living conditions or residential amenities at No 128 to any significant
degree.
Other Matters
14. I have carefully considered the views that have been expressed by the
neighbouring occupiers at 128 Three Bridges Road. Matters relating to the
character and appearance of the works upon the street scene, and their effect
upon the neighbours’ living conditions have been addressed as part of the two
main issues above.
15. I accept that the position of the brick pier at the entrance to the site and
adjacent to the boundary with No 128 would obstruct some vision from a car
leaving No 128 for an initial period. However, the pier is recessed behind the
back edge of the public highway. Furthermore, there is no footpath to this side
of Three Bridges Road but instead a deep grass verge with a concrete surface
across it connecting the curtilage of No 128 with the carriageway. Beyond the
Appeal Decision APP/Q3820/D/17/3192235
4
pier, any vehicle emerging would travel several metres before connecting with
any part of the highway that would involve moving traffic. Appropriate visibility
onto Three Bridges Road would therefore be unaffected, as would highway
safety. I note also that the Highway Authority raised no objection.
16. Matters relating to works that may have affected land within the neighbours’
ownership or other third parties’ land are not directly relevant to the planning
merits of this case.
Conditions
17. As the proposal is partly retrospective there is no need for the standard time
limit condition to be imposed or for the materials of construction to be
controlled. It is necessary however to impose a condition specifying the
relevant drawings as this provides certainty in relation to the remainder of the
works that are to be implemented. The Council has suggested a condition
requiring details and implementation of a landscaping scheme however given
the scale and nature of the proposal, and the individual context of this plot
within a mixed residential area, I do not consider this to be necessary.
Conclusion
18. For the reasons given, I have found that the proposal would not harm the
character or appearance of the area or the living conditions of neighbouring
occupiers. I therefore find no conflict with the Council’s SPD, or with Policies
CH2 and CH3 of the Crawley Borough Local Plan 2015 – 2030, adopted in
December 2015, insofar as they require development to be of high quality
design that is sympathetic to its surroundings and that retains a good standard
of amenity for all existing and future occupants of land and buildings. Neither
do I find conflict with the National Planning Policy Framework as it relates to
similar issues. Accordingly, and in the absence of any other conflict with the
development plan, the appeal is allowed.
John D Allan
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.