Appeal Against Conditions
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 21 March 2018
by Rory MacLeod BA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 29 March 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/A5270/D/17/3191439
45 Beaufort Road, Ealing, London W5 3EB
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73A of the Town and
Country Planning Act 1990 for the development of land carried out without complying
with conditions subject to which a previous planning permission was granted.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Mustafa against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Ealing.
The application Ref 171104VAR, dated 7 March 2017, was refused by notice dated
14 August 2017.
The application sought planning permission for retention of roof and chimneystack
following planning permission Ref: P/2012/0127 dated 16-06-2012 for two storey full-
width extension without complying with conditions attached to planning permission Ref
162314HH, dated 12/08/2016.
The conditions in dispute are Nos 2 and 3 which state that: (2) The development hereby
approved shall be carried out in accordance with drawing title number: Drawing No: 14-
91 titled "Comparison between the as built and approved" dated 28/07/16; (3) All
external materials to be used in the development shall match the appearance of those
of the existing building, or be in accordance with section 11 the materials of the
planning application form, or as described on the approved plan.
The reasons given for the conditions are: (2) For the avoidance of doubt, and in the
interests of proper planning; and (3) To ensure that the materials harmonise with the
surroundings, in accordance with policies 7.4, 7B and 7D of the Ealing Development
Management DPD (2013), policies 1.1 (h) (j), 1.2 (f), and 2.1 and 2.10, and policies
7.1, 7.2, 7.4 and 7.6 of the London Plan (2015).
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for retention of roof
and chimneystack following planning permission Ref: P/2012/0127 dated 16-
06-2012 for two storey full-width extension at 45 Beaufort Road, Ealing,
London W5 3EB in accordance with the application Ref 171104VAR, made on
the 7 March 2017 without complying with conditions Nos. (2) and (3) set out in
planning permission Ref 162314HH granted on 12 August 2016 by the Council
of the London Borough of Ealing.
Background and Main Issues
2. The application the subject of this appeal was refused by the Council as it
considered the changes proposed to not amount to a minor material
amendment and that a new full planning application is required. The Council
has also expressed concern about the effect of the proposed materials on the
character and appearance of the area.
Appeal Decision APP/A5270/D/17/3191439
2
3. The main issues are (a) whether the minor material amendment procedure is
appropriate and (b) if it is appropriate, whether the conditions are reasonable
and necessary in order to preserve or enhance the character or appearance of
the Hanger Hill (Haymills) Estate Conservation Area, within which the site lies.
Reasons
(a) Whether the minor material amendment procedure is appropriate
4. The appeal property is a detached two storey house that has been enlarged by
the provision of two storey side and rear extensions and a new crown roof. It
has a two storey bay at the front with a gable over. The gable is defined by a
triangle of white boards. The proposal is to retain these boards in white UPVC
rather than use painted timber.
5. The Council’s decision notice states that the proposal is not a minor material
amendment as “the proposed window replacement was not part of the original
permission, planning ref. P/2012/0127”. However, the appeal does not relate
to that permission but to 162314HH which was for “retention of roof and
chimneystack following planning permission P/2012/0127”. The appeal
application relates to works at roof level. Its scope does not include windows
below eaves level. The appeal submissions refer to the approval of application
PP/2014/0977 to discharge a condition relating to window details on permission
P/2012/0127. Compliance with that approval is not a matter before me.
6. There is not a statutory definition of a minor material amendment. The
Council’s advice on Minor Material Amendments accepts the government’s
definition that “A minor material amendment is one whose scale and nature
results in a development which is not substantially different from the one which
has been approved”. The use of UPVC as opposed to timber on the three
boards defining the gable over the bay windows would not result in a
development substantially different from that which has been approved. It
would therefore be appropriate to use the minor material amendment
procedure to assess the planning merits of the change.
(b) Character and appearance
7. The appeal property is set in a residential area within the Hanger Hills
(Haymills) Conservation Area, a planned estate based upon roads forming a
semi-circle shape. The Conservation Area Character Appraisal (2008) notes
that the area “offers a very diverse architectural character due to the
combination of different house styles, designs and types”.
8. The appeal property forms part of a row of detached houses in Beaufort Road
but differs in architectural style to the adjacent dwellings to either side. Several
houses in the road have black painted timber gable features over bay windows
but many have hipped roofs instead of gables, or gables formed from other
materials such as brick. The recently constructed crown roof to the appeal
property also sets its profile apart from that of most neighbouring dwellings.
9. The Conservation Area Management Plan (2008) cautions against the use of
UPVC for replacement doors and window frames, but makes no express
reference to their application to roof related features. One of the development
control principles set out in the document states that “contemporary and
modernist styles could be entirely acceptable if they are high in quality and
Appeal Decision APP/A5270/D/17/3191439
3
provided that they remain sympathetic in the context and towards the host
building and/or other neighbouring buildings”.
10. Condition 2 requires development to be carried out in accordance with the
specified drawing no. 14-91 titled “comparison between the as built and
approved” dated 28/07/16. Condition 3 requires the external materials used in
the development to match the appearance of those of the existing building or
to be as otherwise specified. The permission has been implemented. The
hanging tiles in the centre of the gable feature match those between the
ground and first floor bay windows and are sympathetic in appearance to the
tiles used on the main roof, resulting in a unified appearance to the house.
11. The fascia boards and soffits at eaves level on the appeal property have been
formed from white UPVC, in accordance with permission 162314HH. The use of
white UPVC for the triangle of boards forming the gable feature over the bay
window complements the appearance of the fascia boards particularly as the
horizontal element in the triangle continues their line across the frontage of the
site and along a return elevation. The change involved in the appeal proposal is
minor in relation to the scale of changes already undertaken at roof level and
results in a satisfactory appearance to the dwelling. Given the differences in
architectural style to neighbouring properties, the appeal proposal is also
acceptable in the context the character or appearance of Beaufort Road and the
wider conservation area.
12. For these reasons I conclude that the visual effects of using white UPVC instead
of painted timber for the three boards forming the gable feature would be very
limited. The works amount to a minor material amendment. Other works to the
roof of the building have been carried out using sympathetic materials.
Accordingly, condition 3 is not necessary to preserve or enhance the character
and appearance of the conservation area. It would be reasonable to allow the
proposed changes. Whilst I understand the Council’s aspiration to discourage
the inappropriate use of modern materials within the conservation area, my
decision is based firmly on the characteristics of this particular building and its
setting.
13. The proposal is consistent with the aims of policies 7.4 and 7.6 of the London
Plan (2015) and with policies 7.4, 7B and 7D of the Ealing Development
Management DPD (2013) that collectively promote the use of materials to
harmonise with the surroundings. There would not be conflict with the Hanger
Hill (Haymills) Estate Conservation Area Management Plan (2008) nor with the
aims for design and heritage assets within the National Planning Policy
Framework.
14. I have had regard to the objection raised by the Conservation Area Advisory
Panel that the development is out of keeping and recommending the use of
traditional renewable materials. However, in the particular circumstances of
this site and given the presence of white UPVC elsewhere on the roof, the
proposal is acceptable.
Conclusion
15. For the reasons set out above, I conclude that it is appropriate to consider the
proposal through the minor material amendment procedure and that the appeal
should be allowed. I shall grant a new planning permission without the
disputed conditions.
Appeal Decision APP/A5270/D/17/3191439
4
16. I have considered the further conditions suggested by the Council but regard
these as unnecessary. A condition relating to the commencement of
development is not needed since the development has been carried out. For
the same reason neither is it necessary to have a condition requiring the
development to be carried out in accordance with the revised approved plan.
Rory MacLeod
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.