Alteration to existing garage to create playroom at first floor level

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Trees & Landscape

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 13 March 2018 by Elaine Worthington BA (Hons) MTP MUED MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 23rd March 2018 Appeal Ref: APP/X4725/D/17/3190356 20 Boundary Drive, Wakefield, WF1 3QQ  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Lyte against the decision of City of Wakefield Metropolitan District Council.  The application Ref 17/02133/FUL, dated 11 August 2017, was refused by notice dated 9 October 2017.  The development proposed is an alteration to existing garage to create playroom at first floor level. Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Main Issue 2. The main issue in this case is the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the occupiers of 18 Boundary Drive, with particular reference to outlook, daylight and sunlight. Reasons 3. The appeal property is a detached house in a residential area characterised by similar properties. The proposal seeks the addition of a first floor to its existing detached single storey double garage which is positioned to the side of the house behind its rear elevation. 4. I am aware that planning permission has been recently granted for a number of extensions to the appeal property which are also indicated on the submitted plans. At the time of my visit these had not commenced. I also appreciate that the appellants amended the appeal proposal during the Council’s consideration of the application in order to reduce its height. 5. The existing garage has a pitched roof with a gable end to its flank elevation adjacent to neighbouring No 18. The proposal would see the switching of the gable ends to the front and rear of the building and an increase in its height. The Council estimates that the height of the eaves would be increased by 1.15 metres and the ridge by 0.5 metres. However, based on my own observations on site, it seems to me that the submitted plans show the existing garage to be taller than it actually is and with a steeper pitched roof. As a result, in my view the increase in height in relation to the existing structure would be greater. In any event, notwithstanding this discrepancy, the proposal would lead to a building with an eaves height of 3.6 metres and a ridge height of 5.8 metres. Appeal Decision APP/X4725/D/17/3190356 2 6. Neighbouring No 18 faces onto the side of the appeal property and has a front ground floor bay window. The council estimates that No 18 is 7.8 metres from the appeal property and advises that this is less than the 12 metre separation distance normally required for a main to side aspect relationship. Although the garage is not directly in front of No 18, and is set back in relation to it, it is still relatively close to it. The Council advises that it is within a 45 degree arc taken from the centre of the bay window and the appellants do not dispute this. 7. I accept that the proposal would not alter the existing position of the garage or the current relationship between No 18 and the appeal property. Nevertheless, with its tall overall ridge height (which would reach to around the level of the eaves of the main house) and its high eaves level, it would be clearly seen from there. Despite the intervening boundary fence and wall to No 18’s frontage, to my mind it would be appreciated as a much larger building than the existing garage. In the context of the already relatively close relationship between No 18 and the appeal property, on balance I consider the proposal would be seen as an unduly tall and overbearing feature from No 18 which would have an oppressive and overly dominant visual effect. 8. I have also had regard to the Council’s concern regarding the overshadowing of No 18’s front window. However, given the garage’s set back position and the separation distances that would be retained, and taking into account the proximity of the existing dwelling at the appeal site and the tall trees to the rear of the garage, I am not persuaded that any harmful loss of daylight or sunlight to No 18’s front window would arise from the appeal scheme. I am aware that the addition of a room above the garage was initially proposed but later deleted from the approved application for the other extensions. I note the Council’s concerns as to the cumulative effect of the appeal proposal alongside those permitted additions. However, since the garage is further way from No 18’s front window than the permitted two storey rear extension, I am not convinced that it would worsen the impact of that permitted scheme in terms of daylight and sunlight to any great extent. 9. I therefore conclude on the main issue that whilst the proposal would cause no harm to the living conditions of the occupiers of No 18 in terms of daylight and sunlight, it would be harmful with reference to outlook. This would be contrary to Policy D9 of the Wakefield Local Development Framework Development Policies Document (LDF) which requires new development to make a positive contribution to the environment and amenity of its locality. In particular proposals shall have no significant detrimental impact on the amenity of neighbouring users or residents and existing or prospective users (criterion k). It would also conflict with LDF Policy D10 which requires extensions and alterations to dwellings to respect residential amenity, the character and scale of the dwelling and its location. Furthermore, it would undermine the core planning principle of the National Planning Policy Framework to secure a good standard of amenity for all existing and future occupants of land and buildings. 10. The Council’s decision notice cites the guidance in the Council’s adopted Residential Design Guide and the officer’s report refers to both an adopted and 2017 version of this document. However, I have not been directed to any particular relevant policies or guidelines and have only been provided with a copy of the adopted 1996 version of the guide. This being so, and in the absence of any further clarification as to which guidance is currently in force, I have not assessed the appeal scheme against the design guide(s). Appeal Decision APP/X4725/D/17/3190356 3 Other matters 11. The Council raises no objections to the proposal’s design, its impact on the character and appearance of the host dwelling or the surrounding area (including the street scene or the wider landscape), the amount of amenity space that would be retained, or in terms of any overlooking. Along with my findings regarding the impact of the scheme on the living conditions of the occupiers of No 18 in terms of daylight and sunlight, the absence of harm in these regards counts neither for, nor against the proposal. 12. Although the appellants refer to the benefits of the case, it has not been put to me what those are. It seems to me that the proposal would give rise to enhanced living accommodation at the appeal property, but I confirm that any such benefits are insufficient to outweigh the harm I have identified in relation to the main issue in this case. Conclusion 13. For the reasons set out above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed. Elaine Worthington INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →