Appeal Against Conditions

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Green Belt Policy
Extensions
Character & Appearance

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 29 March 2018 by R J Maile BSc FRICS an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 01 June 2018 Appeal Ref: APP/G2245/D/17/3190129 Girdle Bridge Cottage, Shoreham Road, Eynsford, Dartford, Kent, DA4 0HX.  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 for the development of land without complying with a condition subject to which a previous planning permission was granted.  The appeal is made by Mr T Powell against the decision of Sevenoaks District Council.  The application ref: SE/17/01582/MMA, dated 16 May 2017, was refused by notice dated 17 August 2017.  The application sought planning permission for demolition of the existing double garage and outbuilding to facilitate the erection of a two storey rear extension, as amended by drawings received 14/7/2011, without complying with a condition attached to planning permission ref: 11/01288/FUL dated 15 July 2011.  The condition in dispute is no. 5, which states that: “The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the following approved plans: 2029/09, 2029/02A, 2029/03A, 04A, 11.05A (rec’d 14.7.2011), 2029/06A (rec’d 14.7.2011), 2029/07A (rec’d 14.7.2011), 2029/08A (rec’d 14.7.2011) 2029.”  The reason given for the condition is: “For the avoidance of doubt and in the interests of proper planning.” Application for costs 1. An application for costs was made by Mr T Powell against Sevenoaks District Council. This application is the subject of a separate decision. Preliminary/Procedural Matters 2. The appellant’s agent and the Council have variously referred to the reference number of the planning permission granted on 15 July 2011 as 11/01288/FUL and 11/01288/HOUSE. Both in this decision and my decision relating to the application for costs I have elected to use the reference number as it appears on the original planning permission, i.e. 11/01288/FUL. 3. The Council’s refusal notice states that: “The proposal is not considered to be a minor material amendment.” It further states that “Insufficient evidence has been submitted to demonstrate, on the balance of probabilities, that planning permission 11/01288 to which this minor material amendment application relates has been implemented and is extant.” 4. I propose to address this latter issue (implementation of planning permission ref: 11/01288/FUL) here before proceeding to consider whether the amended drawings represent a minor material amendment in my reasons below. Appeal Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3190129 2 (i) Whether lawful commencement of planning permission ref: SE/11/01288/FUL 5. Planning permission was granted on 15 July 2011 under ref: SE/11/01288/FUL for demolition of the existing garage and outbuilding to facilitate the erection of a two storey rear extension as amended by drawings received on 14 July 2011. I have been provided with a copy of the approved drawings relating to that planning permission. 6. The appeal site has a lengthy planning history, including an unsuccessful appeal (ref: APP/G2245/D/12/2175744) relating to a scheme similar to that before me at this appeal. I have a copy of that decision letter also, which is dated 28 June 2012. Importantly, it preceded the works that were carried out pursuant to the 2011 permission. 7. The 2011 planning permission was subject to a total of five conditions. None, however, are in the form of pre-conditions requiring the submission of further details prior to a lawful commencement of the development. 8. The information before me includes a Statutory Declaration by the appellant dated 21 November 2017, which sets out the train of events following the grant of planning permission in 2011. That document contains a number of exhibits, including details of fees paid to the Council’s Building Control Department following inspection of the 1m deep foundations for the extension. There are also photographs of the work, together with an invoice from the builder who undertook the construction of the foundations. 9. The Statutory Declaration and the attached eight exhibits, being dated 21 November 2017, were not available to the Case Officer at the time he prepared his report upon the application the subject of this appeal in August 2017. 10. Based upon the documentation before me and the observations made during my site visit, I have concluded that there has been a lawful commencement of planning permission ref: SE/11/01288/FUL dated 15 July 2011. Accordingly, I have determined this appeal by reference to section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. Decision 11. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for demolition of the existing double garage and outbuilding to facilitate the erection of a two storey rear extension, as amended by drawings received 14/7/2011 at Girdle Bridge Cottage, Shoreham Road, Eynsford, Dartford, Kent, DA4 0XH, in accordance with the application ref: SE/17/01582/MMA, dated 16 May 2017, without compliance with condition number 5 previously imposed on planning permission ref: SE/11/01288/FUL, dated 15 July 2011, and subject to the conditions set out in Annex A to this decision. Main Issue 12. The main issue in this case is whether the proposal before me would represent a minor material amendment; and, if so, whether the changes to the drawings would permit a development that would not unacceptably impact upon the character and appearance of the Kent Downs Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty or the openness of the Green Belt. Appeal Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3190129 3 Reasons 13. Girdle Bridge Cottage comprises a substantial detached house probably erected during the inter-war period, being located to the east of the Shoreham Road in an elevated position adjacent to the railway line. The site is heavily wooded, much of the tree screening around the perimeter being within the extended curtilage of the property. 14. The appeal site is within the Metropolitan Green Belt and the Kent Downs Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (‘AONB’). 15. The existing house is predominantly two storeys, but with a number of single storey extensions, both attached and detached, to the side and front. There are also two small rooms within the roof space. From my observations on site these appear to be original, as is the flank dormer window to the roof slope that provides the rooms with limited natural light. 16. The majority of the proposed extension remains unchanged from that for which permission was granted in 2011. The present scheme involves an increased depth to the rear extension of approximately 800mm and a squaring off of the ground floor dog room and first floor bathroom above. 17. Cumulatively, the proposed amendments would result in an increase in floor area of 27.26m2 over and above that of the permitted scheme. There is no change to the overall design concept of the extension, although the additions to the dog room/bathroom allow a more natural continuation of the approved roof line over the side extension area. 18. National policy in the Framework1 states that inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very special circumstances (see paragraph 87). Paragraph 89 does allow for some exceptions, including the extension or alteration of a building provided that it does not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building. 19. An ‘original’ building is defined in the Glossary to the Framework as a building as it existed on 1 July 1948 or, if constructed after 1 July 1948, as it was built originally. 20. Policy GB1 of the ADMP2 states that proposals for residential extensions within the Green Belt will be permitted where the design is in keeping with the original form and appearance of the building and the proposed volume of the extension, taking into consideration any previous extensions, is proportional and subservient to the ‘original’ dwelling and does not materially harm the openness of the Green Belt through excessive scale, bulk or visual intrusion. 21. Criterion c) of the policy also requires the applicant to provide clear evidence that the total floorspace of the proposal, together with any previous extensions, alterations and outbuildings would not result in an increase of more than 50% above the floorspace of the ‘original’ dwelling (measured externally) including outbuildings within 5m of the existing dwelling. 22. The amendments affect the rear elevation only, which is not visible from the public domain and is well screened by the topography and mature tree planting 1 The National Planning Policy Framework. 2 Sevenoaks Local Plan: Allocations and Development Management Plan (adopted February 2015). Appeal Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3190129 4 to the rear of the extensive curtilage. As such, I am satisfied that the amend- ments would not have any implications for the appearance of the AONB or have any harmful effect upon the openness of the Green Belt. In this regard, it is necessary to consider the proposal against national policy and Policy GB1 of the Local Plan ADMP. 23. The Officer’s Report provides a detailed analysis of floor areas including and excluding those attributable to the garage and the accommodation within the roof space. 24. By including both the garage and the accommodation in the roof space within the calculation of the original floor area the current proposals would represent a 47.46% increase above the floorspace of the original dwelling, thereby meeting the requirements of national policy and Policy GB1 of the ADMP. 25. The Council calculates that if the dwelling with the extension as now proposed retains the accommodation within the roof space for habitable purposes the scheme before me would represent a 58.66% increase, thereby breaching the policy constraints referred to above. 26. Such a situation led to the dismissal of the 2012 planning appeal. In that case, the Inspector could find no legitimate use of a planning condition to ensure that the roof space was no longer utilised as habitable accommodation. However, the drawings before me clearly indicate that the roof space will not be included within the living accommodation and will be retained for storage purposes only (see Drawing no. 471/06D, which indicates that the current staircase serving the roof space will be removed and replaced by a cupboard at first floor level). 27. As part of the appeal the appellant’s agent has provided amended drawings3 which indicate the removal of the dormer window and has also suggested the imposition of a condition to give effect to this to provide greater certainty that the roof space will not be used as habitable accommodation. 28. I am satisfied that the amended plans would not prejudice the Council or any third party and they would ensure that the scheme meets the requirements of Policy GB1 of the ADMP. As such, I have decided to accept them. 29. I have been referred to a number of High Court Judgments relating to what comprises a minor material amendment to an original permission, together also with a series of tests published by Lewisham Borough Council and adopted by other Local Planning Authorities to assess the acceptability of a change to an approved scheme under the minor amendment procedure. It is also relevant that the Planning Practice Guidance states there is no statutory definition of a minor material amendment. 30. I am satisfied that the scheme before me would not bring about a significant change in the scale of the extension as originally approved and that it would not result in a materially detrimental impact in visual or amenity terms. The amendments would not be contrary to any relevant Development Plan policy taking into account the calculations to include the roof space as original accommodation, whilst ensuring that the staircase and dormer window serving the roof space are removed, such that it will be retained for ancillary storage purposes only. 3 Drawing nos. 471/05 Rev C, 471/07 Rev C, 471/08 Rev D and 471/09 Rev C. Appeal Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3190129 5 31. For all of these reasons I conclude that the scheme the subject of this appeal is not substantially different from that for which planning permission was granted in 2011 and in respect of which I have found that there has been a lawful commencement. 32. I have therefore found on the main issue that development as proposed would comprise a minor material amendment to planning permission ref: SE/11/ 01288/FUL dated 15 July 2011 and would permit a development that would not unacceptably impact upon the character and appearance of the Kent Downs AONB or the openness of the Green Belt. As such, the scheme would accord with both national policy and the policies of the Development Plan to which I have referred above. Conditions 33. The Planning Practice Guidance makes clear that decision notices for the grant of planning permission under section 73 should repeat the relevant conditions from the original permission unless they have already been discharged. I have therefore considered those conditions against the tests of the Framework and advice provided by the Planning Practice Guidance. 34. Having regard to my finding that there has been a lawful commencement of planning permission ref: SE/11/01288/FUL, Condition 1 (commencement) is not required. Conditions 2, 3 and 4 remain relevant and I intend to re-impose them, albeit that I have elected to combine nos. 3 and 4 into a single, more appropriately worded condition (no. 2 as imposed). 35. I have amended Condition 5 in order to reflect the plans before me and have also imposed a new condition (no. 3), as suggested by the appellant’s agent, relating to the removal of the dormer window in the southern roof slope of the dwelling. 36. My reasons for the conditions are: 37. Condition 1 will ensure a satisfactory appearance to the completed development in the interests of the visual amenities of the area. Condition 2 will allow the Council to exercise control over future development at the appeal site having regard to its location within the Green Belt and the strict policies of restraint that apply. 38. Condition 3 is necessary in order to ensure that the accommodation in the roof space remains suitable for ancillary storage purposes only. Condition 4, which requires the development to be carried out in accordance with the approved plans, provides certainty. Conclusion 39. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should be allowed. R. J. Maile INSPECTOR Appeal Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3190129 6 Schedule of Conditions Annex A 1) The brickwork and tiles to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing building. 2) Notwithstanding the provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 (or any order revoking and re-enacting that Order, with or without modification) no development shall be carried out within Classes A, B, C and E of Part 1, Schedule 2 to that Order without the prior written approval of the Local Planning Authority. 3) The development hereby permitted shall not be occupied until the dormer window within the southern roof slope of the existing building has been removed as indicated on Drawing nos. 471/05 Rev C, 471/07 Rev C, 471/08 Rev D and 471/09 Rev C. 4) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the following approved plans: Drawing no. 471/01 Rev C: Location Plan – scale 1:2500; Existing Block Plan – scale 1:500. Drawing no. 471/02 Rev C: Existing Floor Plans – scale 1:100. Drawing no. 471/03 Rev B: Existing Elevations Sheet 1 – scale 1:100. Drawing no. 471/04 Rev B: Existing Elevations Sheet 2 – scale 1:100. Drawing no. 471/05 Rev C: Proposed Block Plan – scale 1:200. Drawing no. 471/06 Rev D: Proposed Ground and First Floor Plans – scale 1:100. Drawing no. 471/07 Rev C: Existing and Proposed Roof Plans – scale 1:100. Drawing no. 471/08 Rev D: Proposed Front and Side Elevations – scale 1:100. Drawing no. 471/09 Rev C: Proposed Rear and Side Elevations – scale 1:100.
£ Costs decision section
Costs Decision Site visit made on 29 March 2018 by R J Maile BSc FRICS an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 01 June 2018 Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/G2245/D/17/3190129 Girdle Bridge Cottage, Shoreham Road, Eynsford, Dartford, Kent, DA4 0HX.  The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78, 322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).  The application is made by Mr T Powell for a full award of costs against Sevenoaks District Council.  The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for minor material amendment to SE/11/01288/FUL for the demolition of the existing double garage and outbuilding to facilitate the erection of a two storey rear extension to show amendments to the rear and side elevations and roof plans. Decision 1. The application for an award of costs is allowed in the terms set out below. Reasons 2. The Planning Practice Guidance advises that costs may be awarded against a party who has behaved unreasonably and thereby caused the party applying for costs to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process. 3. Girdle Bridge Cottage is located within the Green Belt and the Kent Downs Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (‘AONB’). It has a lengthy planning history, the 2011 permission the subject of this appeal pre-dating the National Planning Policy Framework, the Planning Practice Guidance and changes to the Develop- ment Plan. In such circumstances it was proper of the Council to exercise care in the consideration of the application the subject of this appeal. 4. The Planning Officer’s Report correctly concluded that the changes to the 2011 permission sought by the application would not adversely affect the wider AONB. However, it failed to acknowledge that sufficient information had been submitted to demonstrate, on the balance of probabilities, that works had commenced on site in accordance with that permission. This was in spite of the fact that evidence had been provided with the application indicating that work had commenced on 9 July 2014 (i.e. within the statutory period). 5. The evidence submitted included documentation from the Council’s Building Control Officer and an email dated 28 March 2017 from Jenny Nash, a Building Control Inspector of the Council, confirming that works had commenced in July 2014. Costs Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3190129 2 6. It is clear from the receipt dated 7 July 2014 that the works at Girdle Bridge Cottage related to a two storey rear extension. The proposed accommodation was detailed on the Building Regulations form dated 7 July 2014 and accords with the plans approved under the 2011 permission. Moreover, there were apparently no other similar planning permissions as at July 2014 to which the Building Regulations would apply. 7. The Council advised that the appellant could make an application for a Lawful Development Certificate (‘LDC’) to determine whether a lawful commencement of the 2011 planning permission had taken place prior to 15 July 2014. However, it would have been possible for the Planning Officer to verify the situation with the Building Control Officer if he had any doubts as to the veracity of the documentation before him. This would have obviated the need for an LDC application. 8. In further support of my decision is the subsequent planning history relating to the existing and proposed status of the roof space accommodation. By including the loft space as original, the proposed amendments to the 2011 permission would fall below the 50% tolerance allowed for by Policy GB1 of the Local Plan and thereby meet Green Belt policy. 9. In its rebuttal statement the Council has suggested that the applicant did not advance his own floorspace figures as part of the application. However, the applicant had offered to provide amended plans to support his figures. Those amended plans are before me and simply involve removal of a pre-existing dormer window to ensure that the roof space is suitable for storage purposes only. 10. Moreover, the Officer’s Report provides a calculation to include both the garage and the accommodation within the roof as original. This resulted in an increase in floorspace of 47.66% and would render the proposal acceptable by reference to Policy GB1 of the Local Plan. 11. Finally, and for the reasons set out in my decision, I do not accept the Officer’s comment that “The proposed minor material amendment produces a scheme which is substantially different from that previously approved …” This is clearly not the case having regard to the modest alterations that are proposed to the rear elevation. The Officer himself concluded that the amendments “would not adversely affect the wider AONB …” and that “the perception of bulk would be limited …” 12. I therefore find that unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary or wasted expense as described in the Planning Practice Guidance has been demonstrated and that a full award of costs is justified. Costs Order 13. In exercise of the powers under section 250(5) of the Local Government Act 1972 and Schedule 6 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 as amended, and all other enabling powers in that behalf, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Sevenoaks District Council shall pay to Mr T Powell the costs of the appeal proceedings described in the heading of this decision; such costs to be assessed in the Senior Courts Costs Office if not agreed. Costs Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3190129 3 14. The applicant is now invited to submit to Sevenoaks District Council, to whom a copy of this decision has been sent, details of those costs with a view to reaching agreement as to the amount. R. J. Maile INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →