Single storey rear and two storey side extensions

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Extensions
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 26 February 2018 by Graeme Robbie BA(Hons) BPl MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 16 March 2018 Appeal Ref: APP/R5510/APP/D/17/3190067 35 Cherry Orchard, West Drayton, Middlesex UB7 7JR  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs M & S Arnell against the decision of the Council of the London Borough of Hillingdon.  The application Ref 71213/APP/2017/2259, dated 16 June 2017, was refused by notice dated 13 September 2017.  The development proposed is single storey rear and two storey side extensions. Decision 1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for single storey rear and two storey side extensions at 35 Cherry Orchard, West Drayton, Middlesex UB7 7JR in accordance with the terms of the application, Ref 71213/APP/2017/2259, dated 16 June 2017, subject to the following conditions:. 1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years from the date of this decision. 2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the following approved plans: MPA4/17/01 and MPA4/17/02. 3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing building. Main Issues 2. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on:  The character and appearance of the host property and the surrounding area;  The living conditions of occupiers of 37 and 39 Cherry Orchard, with particular reference to outlook; and  Parking provision. Reasons Character and Appearance 3. The appeal property is a two storey semi-detached dwelling. It is located within a small cul-de-sac of similarly styled and scaled semi-detached dwellings clustered around a small, tree-lined, circular turning head. With shallow front gardens and limited spacing between the buildings the cul-de-sac has a Appeal Decision APP/R5510/APP/D/17/3190067 2 somewhat intimate feel to it. Although there are subtle differences between the pairs of dwellings in terms of proportions and features, hipped main roofs are consistent features across all bar the appeal property. 4. No. 35 however differs from the prevailing form, character and spacing in two main ways. As one of the end properties in the cul-de-sac, it sits at 90° to the rears, and rear gardens, of 37 and 39 Cherry Orchard. It has also previously been extended1 with a large rear-facing dormer extension and a hip-to-gable conversion. Although the former is not visible within the streetscene, the latter is clearly evident on entry into the cul-de-sac. As a consequence the gable elevation is a prominent feature and clearly sets the property apart from others within the cul-de-sac. 5. The symmetry and balance of the pairs of semi-detached properties, to which the hipped main house roofs contribute, has already been eroded in the case of the appeal property and the adjoining half of the semi (No. 33) with the recent hip-to-gable extension. This is particularly evident not just from within the cul- de-sac’s turning head, but also upon entry into the cul-de-sac from where the prominent gable elevation is clearly visible as an alien feature. 6. Although the proposed extension includes single storey rear and side elements, the Council’s first refusal reason refers solely to the two storey side extension element of the proposals. It is also clear, having considered the officer’s delegated report, that the Council’s concerns relate solely to the two storey side extension and not to the single storey elements of the proposal. I agree, and I have not been presented with any evidence to persuade me otherwise. 7. However, with regard to the two storey side extension, and contrary to the Council’s concern that the proposed pitched hipped roof would not reflect the roof form and pitch of the host dwelling, I consider instead that it would go some way to reinstating not just a semblance of balance between Nos. 33 and 35, but also reduce the dominance of the existing gable elevation. It would re-introduce a roof form more in keeping with those of other dwellings within the cul-de-sac and therefore rather than resulting in an unsympathetic addition to the existing dwelling, I find that the hipped roof extension would be in keeping with the intrinsic character and appearance of the host property and with other properties within the cul-de-sac. 8. Moreover, any real sense of symmetry and balance between Nos. 33 and 35 has already been significantly eroded by the earlier hip-to-gable extension. The current proposal, whilst it would not reverse that earlier erosion, would nevertheless reintroduce a more typical roof form that would not cause harm to the character or appearance of Nos. 35 or 33 or the wider cul-de-sac. 9. Having regard to the provisions of the Hillingdon Design and Accessibility Statement (HDAS): Residential Extensions Supplementary Planning Document (SPD), the Council accept that the two storey side extension would be set back sufficiently from the front face of the appeal property. It would also be set back at the rear from the rear face of the property, set below the ridge level of the main house roof and its width would be considerably less than that of the main house. Nor would it, despite the Council’s suggestion to the contrary, be built up to the property’s boundary with Nos. 37 and 39. Instead the existing 1 LPA Ref: 71213/APP/2015/4456 Appeal Decision APP/R5510/APP/D/17/3190067 3 walkway at the side of the garage would be retained and the gap to the boundary maintained. 10. Thus, although the first of the Council’s refusal reasons refers to the two storey side extension as being an insubordinate addition to the dwelling, I do not consider the Council has made this case in an adequate or compelling manner. For the reasons that I have set out I consider that the proposed extensions would harmonise with the character and appearance of the existing streetscene and with the intrinsic character and appearance of the host building in terms of scale, form, proportions and detailing. The proposal therefore complies with policy BE1 of the Hillingdon Local Plan: Part One – Strategic Policies (LP1) and policies BE13, BE15 and BE19 of the Hillingdon Local Plan: Part Two – Unitary Development Plan Saved Policies (LP2). Living Conditions 11. The rear elevations of Nos. 37 and 39 are positioned at 90° to the flank elevation of the appeal property. The Council state that as a consequence of the proposal there would only be in the region of 13 metres between the proposed flank elevation and the rears of these properties. This would be less than the 15 metre minimum set out in the Hillingdon Design and Accessibility Statement (HDAS): Residential Layouts Supplementary Planning Document (SPD). 12. Although the appellant has questioned whether the datum for this measurement should be the rear of the original dwellings at Nos. 37 and 39 or the rear elevations of any extensions to those dwellings, the Council’s figure has not been directly refuted. However, I noted that the bulk of the first floor extension’s flank elevation would not be directly to the rear of either of the two adjacent properties. Instead, it would be aligned more with the gap between Nos. 37 and 39 and the outlook from these properties over the front and rear of No. 35 would remain expansive and relatively open. 13. I also noted that there were intervening outbuildings within the rear gardens of both of those properties. Not only therefore are those outbuildings immediate features in the foreground to the extension, they also assist in breaking up the added extent and proximity of the first floor flank elevation. Moreover, the proposed extension would feature a recessive hipped roof and its extremities would not viewed as extending beyond those of the retained gable elevation or rear dormer window of the main house. 14. The extension is sited due north of the rear elevations of Nos. 37 and 39 and so, whilst there is a technical breach of the guidelines set out in the HDAS: Residential Layouts SPD, levels of daylight and sunlight would not be adversely affected. Thus, with the factors that I have identified above, I am satisfied that the proposal would not result in a materially greater or more harmful impact upon the outlook experienced by occupiers of adjoining properties. There would therefore be no conflict with LP2 policies BE19, BE20 or BE21. Parking Provision 15. LP2 policy AM14 (and Annex 1 thereto) sets out parking standards applicable to, amongst other things, extensions. In the case of dwellings, those with in- curtilage parking provision will be expected to provide a maximum of two spaces. Appeal Decision APP/R5510/APP/D/17/3190067 4 16. The proposal would remove an existing garage, albeit one that is stated by the appellant to be no longer fit for purpose due to its dimensions and those of the current generation of cars. However, although the proposed storeroom at ground floor level would not be of sufficient space to park a vehicle, it would be set back behind the front face of the house. The effect of this would be to increase the driveway length which the appellant considers to already be sufficient to park two vehicles on. 17. However, more significantly, whilst the Council suggest that the proposal would result in the creation of a 4-bedroomed dwelling, the appellant has stated that it is already a 4-bedroomed dwelling and that there would therefore be no increase in the number of bedrooms at the appeal property. The proposed floor plans support this, the additional first floor area within the proposed extension being shown as an extended bedroom 1 with en-suite facilities. 18. Thus, on the evidence available, I cannot conclude that the proposal would give rise to additional parking pressures in the manner the Council suggest. Instead, the proposal would result in the creation of a longer driveway at a property which it is stated can already accommodate the parking of two vehicles, a requirement which is, in any event, stated in LP2 to be a maximum figure. Manoeuvring arrangements would be no different to those currently experienced at the appeal property, or at other dwellings within the cul-de-sac, and I am not persuaded that the proposal would result in overspill parking of the type feared by the Council. There would therefore be no conflict with LP2 policies AM7 or AM14. Conditions 19. I have considered the conditions set out in the Council’s appeal questionnaire against the provisions of the Framework and Planning Practice Guidance. I agree that time limit, approved plans and matching materials conditions are necessary in order to provide certainty and in the interests of character and appearance. No other conditions have been suggested nor, having carefully considered the matter, do I consider there to be a need for any further conditions. Conclusion 20. For the reasons set out, and having considered all other matters raised, I conclude that the appeal should be allowed. Graeme Robbie INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →