Demolition of existing garages and roof structure and replace with new roof structure and extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Rural Impact
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 December 2017
by Kenneth Stone BSc Hons DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date:22nd December 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/C3620/D/17/3188881
Brambles, Oaks Lane, Mid Holmwood, Surrey RH5 4ES
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr James Stelly against the decision of Mole Valley District
Council.
The application Ref MO/2017/1229/PLAH, dated 14 July 2017, was refused by notice
dated 29 September 2017.
The development proposed is described as ‘demolition of existing garages and roof
structure and replace with new roof structure and extension’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green
Belt having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework and any
relevant development plan policies;
The effect on the openness of the Green Belt;
The effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the
original dwelling and the surrounding area including the Surrey Hills Area
of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB);
Would the harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, be
clearly outweighed by other considerations. If so, would this amount to
the very special circumstances required to justify the proposal.
Reasons
3. The parties agree that the site lies in the open countryside, is within the Green
Belt and is in an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty.
4. The site presently includes a previously extended unoccupied bungalow
accessed off an unmetalled road and is located in a small isolated group of
dwellings in a small woodland clearing.
Would the proposal be inappropriate development in the Green Belt?
5. The proposal includes the alteration and extension of an existing dwelling to
which policy RUD7 of the Mole Valley Local Plan (MVLP) would be applicable.
RUD7 relates to all extensions to dwellings in the countryside including within
Appeal Decision APP/C3620/D/17/3188881
2
the Green Belt and indicates permission will be granted where the proposals
would not result in a disproportionate addition over and above the size of the
original dwelling, it would not detract from the appearance and character of the
existing dwelling or rural area, and by itself or together with the existing
building create a dwelling capable of conversion into more than one dwelling.
The paragraphs following the policy clarify that: the original dwelling is as it
stood at the end of 1968; that account will be taken of the relative increase in
floorspace and whether the proposal would be out of proportion with the
original dwelling in terms of form, bulk, or prominence when considering if an
extension was disproportionate; and that the floorspace of a dwelling shall be
measured by gross external floor area and shall exclude garages, car ports and
detached buildings.
6. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) advises at paragraph
89 that the construction of new buildings should be regarded as inappropriate
in the Green Belt subject to exceptions. One of these exceptions is bullet point
3, the extension or alteration of a building provided that it does not result in
disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building. In
the context of the Framework the glossary advises that original building refers
to a building as it stood on 1 July 1948 or as constructed if built after that date.
The Framework does not define what it means by disproportionate.
7. There are differences between the Council policy, which relates to dwellings in
the Countryside, and the Framework which refers to all buildings and is in the
context of Green Belt policy. However these do not raise any issues in the
context of this appeal. There is a difference in the interpretation of the original
building between the Framework and the policy advice and in this regard
greater weight is given to the Framework’s advice as this is more recent.
Overall however the policy is reasonably consistent with the Framework and I
afford it significant weight.
8. The proposed extensions add minor increases to the footprint of the building in
the region of 4 sqm to the rear and 11 sqm to the front totalling approximately
15 sqm. There are some minor differences in the figures between the precise
measurements but I have rounded and these are not of such a difference as to
affect my overall conclusions. These additions would be minor infilling of the
footprint and seen against the backdrop of the existing building and would not
add substantively to the bulk or mass of the building and would not affect the
effect the building has on the openness of the Green Belt. This would be
consistent with the Framework and policy RUD7.
9. The proposal however results in alterations to the roof form both in terms of a
double pitched roof over the flat roofed existing eastern extension and an
increase in the length of the ridge and pitched roof area covering the majority
of the new extension to the west. The overall ridge height on the original
property would also be raised by in the region of 1.2m. The increase in the
main roof encloses additional space and increases the useable floorspace within
the altered building envelope by in the region of 50 sqm. The additional
volume of the new building would be increased by the increase in ridge height,
the enclosure of additional space above the line of the flat/low pitched roof of
the existing western extension, which would be rebuilt in the proposed
development, and the increase in length of the existing ridge. In my view this
would add a large additional volume to the existing building. Further volume
Appeal Decision APP/C3620/D/17/3188881
3
would be added to the building through the double ridged roof at the eastern
end albeit this would not accommodate additional floorspace.
10. The advice in terms of Policy RUD7 from the Council does not give a figure as
to what may be considered disproportionate but it is suggested by the Council
that this is normally taken to be in the region of 50%. The MVLP states
account will be taken of the relative increase in floor space and also whether
the proposal would be out of proportion with the original in terms of form, bulk
or prominence. I am advised the original bungalow (minus the garages as
advised by the policy) was in the region of 130 sqm. There have been previous
additions, again excluding the garages these amount to in the region of 52
sqm, since 1968. When the total additional floorspace proposed in this appeal,
65 sqm, is added to the existing previous extensions this would amount to
approximately 117sqm. When compared to the original floorspace this would
be an approximate 90% increase. Taking account of the relative increase and
when considering the additional volume bulk and mass of the new roof form I
am satisfied that this would amount to a disproportionate addition over and
above the size of the original property. The Council have also noted that there
are pre 1968 additions that have not been included in these calculations which
given the Frameworks definition of original building would also come into play
and further add to the disproportionate nature of the additions.
11. I agree with the Council’s advice at paragraph 5.46 in the MVLP that it is
important not to undermine the original policy through additions to a dwelling
over a period of time. The consequence of this approach is that even small
additions may cumulatively fail to meet the policy.
12. For the reasons given above I conclude that the proposed development would
be inappropriate development in the Green Belt having regard to the National
Planning Policy Framework and any relevant development plan policies. The
proposal would result in disproportionate additions to the dwelling and would
therefore conflict with policy RUD7 in the MVLP and would not be an exception
to new buildings in the Green Belt under bullet point three in paragraph 89 of
the Framework. Paragraph 87 of the Framework advises inappropriate
development in the Green Belt is by definition harmful and should not be
approved except in very special circumstances.
Effect on the openness of the Green Belt
13. The Framework states that the fundamental aim of Green Belt policy is to
prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open, paragraph 79.
14. Openness has both a spatial and visual aspect as has been confirmed in recent
case law1. The proposed extensions would enclose space and are in a location
where there was no built form previously. The extended building would be
larger and bulkier than the original bungalow and indeed the existing. In this
regard the building would reduce the openness of the site. Whilst it is screened
to some extent from the main road by woodland and other buildings this does
not totally obscure views of the structure from neighbouring properties and
land and the access lane. In both spatial and visual terms the building would
result in a reduction in the openness of the site. The screening would to some
extent reduce this impact, but not remove it. I therefore attach moderate
harm to the impact on the openness of the Green Belt resultant from the
1 Turner v SSCLG &East Dorset Council
Appeal Decision APP/C3620/D/17/3188881
4
development. Paragraph 88 in the Framework advises that substantial weight
is given to any harm to the Green Belt. Therefore, although the effect is
moderate this is to be given substantial weight.
Character and appearance including the Surrey Hills AONB
15. The appeal site is located in the Surrey Hills AONB and within an Area of Great
Landscape Value (AGLV). There is a statutory duty to ensure development
conserves and enhances the distinctive character of the area and paragraph
115 of the Framework advises that great weight should be given to conserving
landscape and scenic beauty in Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty.
16. Whilst I have concluded that the proposals would not preserve the openness of
the Green Belt to which the site contributes the effect on the character and
appearance of the area including the AONB and area of great Landscape value
and the effect on character of the existing property require consideration in
their own right. The area is characterised by small rural settlements and
dispersed groups of properties in woodland settings. The proposals would add
additions to a modest bungalow in a small group of other properties in a small
woodland clearing. The overall footprint of the building would not be
substantively increased and the general area is well screened and discreetly
located. In broader landscape character terms the additions to the buildings
would not change the context within which the building sits and would not be
significantly intrusive in the wider landscape. In this regard I am satisfied that
there is no material harm to the AONB or the AGLV.
17. The proposed additions and alterations would see the building re-clad in white
weather boarding and plain tiles for the roofing. The additions would improve
the coherence of the elevations and overall appearance of the building and
result in an attractive finish which is consistent with materials in the wider
area.
18. For the reasons given above I conclude that the proposed development would
not result in material harm to the character and appearance of the original
dwelling and the surrounding area including the Surrey Hills Area of
Outstanding Natural Beauty and the Area of Great Landscape Value.
Consequently it would not conflict with policy CS13 in the Mole Valley Core
Strategy or policies LU2 or LU3 of the Surrey Hills AONB Management Plan
which seek to secure development that respects the special landscape
character of the locality and is of high quality design. The absence of harm is
not a positive benefit and therefore this would be a neutral factor in the Green
Belt balance.
Other considerations
19. The appellant has drawn attention to the poor condition of the existing
dwelling, the impact of water damage the use of asbestos and the poor quality
workmanship that has been undertaken over the years. It is suggested much
of the work would not meet present standards and that the proposal would
improve the energy and thermal efficiency of the building.
20. It is contended by the appellant the extensions are modest and the
development would improve the appearance of the building and bring back into
use an unoccupied dwelling.
Appeal Decision APP/C3620/D/17/3188881
5
21. Whilst I accept that these are positive factors that can be attributed to the
proposed development they are factors that could be addressed by carrying out
other alterations to the buildings which do not necessitate the extent of the
extensions proposed and in particular the additional roof volume added to the
building. As such therefore whilst I accept these as positive features in my
balance I only attach moderate weight to the benefit.
22. The appellant has also suggested that there are some permitted development
rights that could be exercised but has not suggested what those are or what
may be undertaken. Given the previous extensions to the house it is unlikely
that significant additional extensions could be added and only limited
alterations to the roof. It maybe that some ancillary buildings could be erected
but again these would be controlled by permitted development. There is no
permitted development scheme before me to consider as a reasonable fall-back
position and the wider permitted development rights for ancillary buildings
could be addressed through the imposition of conditions to restrict these if it
was considered necessary. The Council has policies to address the provision of
garages and outbuildings in the open countryside and the appellant would then
need to satisfy the Council in this regard. I will therefore give this only limited
weight in my Green Belt balance.
Green Belt balance
23. Paragraph 87 of the Framework advises that inappropriate development is by
definition harmful and should not be approved except in very special
circumstances. Paragraph 88 goes onto advise that ‘Very special
circumstances‘ will not exist unless any potential harm to the Green Belt by
reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by
other considerations.
24. I attach substantial weight to the harm to the Green Belt by virtue of the fact
the extensions are inappropriate development and the harm it has to the
openness of the Green Belt, as I am required to do by paragraph 88 of the
Framework. Against this harm I weigh the improvements to the buildings
structure energy and thermal efficiency, its appearance and the limited fallback
position of potential other unspecified permitted development being undertaken
to which I give moderate or limited weight. In my view the other
considerations do not clearly outweigh the harm that arises from the existing
building.
25. The conclusions on the effect on the AONB, AGLV are neutral factors which do
not affect the Green belt balance.
26. I find in this case that the other considerations do not clearly outweigh the
harm that I have identified. Consequently, the very special circumstances
necessary to justify the development do not exist.
Overall conclusion
27. For the reasons given above I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Kenneth Stone
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.