Erection of conservatory to rear of property, two storey side extension and replacement painted, timber framed, double glazed like for like windows
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 28 February 2018
by Peter D Biggers BSc Hons MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 20th March 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/U5360/D/17/3188257
92 Culford Road, Hackney, London N1 4HN
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Alister Mackie against the decision of the London Borough of
Hackney Council.
The application Ref 2017/2536, dated 21 June 2017, was refused by notice dated 22
August 2017
The development proposed is erection of conservatory to rear of property, two storey
side extension and replacement painted, timber framed, double glazed like for like
windows.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed
Procedural Matter
2. A second appeal APP/U5360/D/17/3188256 is under consideration at the
appeal site at the same time as this appeal. All elements are the same except
that the side extension in the other appeal is single storey. For simplicity I have
issued a separate decision letter for each appeal.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of the host dwelling, the surroundings of Culford Road and of the
De Beauvoir Conservation Area.
Reasons
4. Culford Road, where the appeal site is situated, lies within the De Beauvoir
Conservation Area. Its form and development is typical of the character of the
Conservation Area being lined with short runs of two storey terraces with
stepped entrances to an elevated ground floor over a lower ground floor or
basement level. They are built in brick and with stucco detailing under butterfly
roofs with parapets to the street frontage. The terraces have a uniformity of
scale, design, fenestration and materials which gives an attractive rhythm to
the street frontage that is punctuated in places by space between the groups
although typically these are closed off at street level by close-boarded fences
or screen walls.
5. No 92 Culford Road sits at the end of a group of 4 dwellings with a side space
between it and No 90. The intervening space is currently screened off from the
street by a high close boarded fence with a trellis top.
Appeal Decision APP/U5360/D/17/3188257
2
6. It has been put to me that one of the Conservation Area’s characteristics is the
groupings of dwellings and the spaces between them and the appeal proposal
would erode this. The De Beauvoir Conservation Area Appraisal and
Management Guidelines (CAAMG) advises that the maintenance of the space
around the blocks is fundamental to the legibility of the layout. The insertion of
the 2 storey side extension, extending to the plot boundary with minimal set
back from the frontage, would introduce significant scale and mass into the
space between the terraced groups. Being clearly visible in views along the
street, this would be an intrusive addition disrupting the repeating pattern of
buildings and spaces in the street. In contributing to closing the characteristic
gaps in the street scene it would have a significant and adverse impact on the
character and appearance of the street. I acknowledge that the current fence
provides some enclosure in the side space between the blocks but this
proposed extension would be substantially higher. For these reasons the
proposal would be contrary to Policy 24 of the Hackney Local Development
Framework Core Strategy (HCS) which requires development to adopt a
rigorous design assessing heights and bulk of buildings in relation to existing
surroundings. It would also conflict with the design objectives of Policy DM1 of
the Hackney Development Management Local Plan (HDMLP) which requires
development to respect the visual integrity and established scale, massing and
rhythm of the building, frontages or street scene.
7. I have been referred to many examples of existing 2 storey side extensions
within the Conservation Area including on Culford Road which the appellant
considers justifies the appeal proposal. It is true that elsewhere on other
sections of Culford Road there are several examples of 2 storey side
extensions. However on the section where the appeal site is located between
Northchurch Terrace and Englefield Road there are very few examples. Where
side extensions have taken place on this stretch at Nos 82, 107 and 114 they
are on the ends of this section of Culford Road where there is no adjacent
property before the crossing street. The immediate vicinity of the appeal site
therefore appears to have retained the characteristic gaps between the short
terraces and the cases cited by the appellant elsewhere would not justify the
insertion of a 2 storey side extension closing off this characteristic gap. I have
therefore determined the case on its own merits.
8. The effect of the extension would appear as an anomaly in the designed
uniformity in this part of Culford Road. As such it would harm the significance
of the Conservation Area and would fail the statutory test of preserving or
enhancing the character of the De Beauvoir Conservation Area. Accordingly,
the proposal would be contrary to paragraph 132 of the National Planning
Policy Framework (The Framework) which anticipates great weight being given
to a heritage asset’s conservation. For the same reasons the proposals would
be contrary to Policy 25 of the HCS which requires development to make a
positive contribution to the character of Hackney’s historic and built
environment. The proposed extension would also conflict with Policy DM28 of
the HDMLP, which requires that alterations and extensions in conservation
areas should not upset the scale or proportions of buildings or adversely affect
the character, appearance or setting of neighbouring buildings.
9. Even if I was to conclude that the harm to the significance of the heritage asset
would be less than substantial, allowing Paragraph 134 of the Framework to be
applied, I am not satisfied that the harm would be outweighed by any public
benefit.
Appeal Decision APP/U5360/D/17/3188257
3
10. Whilst I accept that the appellant, in proposing the side extension, is seeking to
improve the quality of the accommodation and make sustainable and effective
use of his home, an objective which is encouraged by the Framework, this is
not a public benefit. No public benefit has been put to me in this case that
would outweigh the harm to the significance of the Conservation Area.
11. Regarding the rear single storey extension, the design represents a lightweight,
predominantly glazed addition sitting on the rear of the house at the lower
ground level which would not adversely impact on either the character or
appearance of the house or the surroundings of the Conservation Area.
12. The rear extension would be physically and functionally separate to the side
extension and it is possible to issue a split decision allowing just this element of
the appeal. However, as it received permission in 2017, (Ref 2017/2427), a
split decision on this appeal is not necessary.
Conclusions
13. I have considered the matters before me and, for the reasons given above, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
P.D. Biggers
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.